Louisville, Kentucky – Mary Spalding, aged 72, experienced a traumatic attack in her own home on December 17, 2018, which left her feeling unsafe and without closure. She was assaulted while in her basement, struck over the head with a metal object by someone lurking in the shadows. Despite the lack of forced entry, Spalding managed to call for help after regaining consciousness and being battered and bruised.
Detective Deidre Mengedoht initially led the investigation into Spalding’s case, instilling hope that justice would be served. Tragically, Mengedoht lost her life in a traffic accident a week later, transferring the case to other detectives who failed to make progress. Spalding’s ex-fiancé was a prime suspect in her eyes, with suspicions heightened by his knowledge of her routine and possession of a small bat.
The Office of the Inspector General took notice of Spalding’s complaint and launched a full investigation into the Louisville Metro Police Department’s handling of the case. Significant discrepancies and mishandling were found, pointing to institutional failures within the department. The report highlighted deficiencies in evidence collection and detective work.
Despite the suspicions surrounding Spalding’s ex-fiancé, the detectives failed to adequately pursue him or gather crucial evidence for testing. The investigation was marred by procedural errors, including improper DNA testing and flawed evidence collection. Recommendations for improvement were made to enhance case management and evidence handling within the department.
The findings of the investigation underscored the need for better supervision and training among detectives at LMPD. The report’s recommendations aim to prevent similar failures in future investigations. The Inspector General’s office plans to further review detective bureaus within the department, urging for necessary reforms to enhance investigative practices and ensure justice for victims like Mary Spalding.