Savannah Streber’s death remained unresolved for years before a state prosecution collapsed and federal authorities brought a new arson charge.
ROCHESTER, N.Y. — The criminal case now pending in federal court began more than 22 years ago in a burning house on Yates Street, where 8-year-old Savannah Streber disappeared from a group fleeing the flames and was later found in her mother’s bedroom after an intentionally set fire.
What followed was not a straight path from investigation to prosecution. The case spent years without an arrest, returned to public attention when investigators revisited it, produced state murder and arson charges against Timothy Kuhn, then collapsed on the eve of trial because of a constitutional speedy-trial issue. Now Kuhn, 66, of Pensacola, Florida, has been indicted by a federal grand jury on one count of arson of property used in interstate commerce resulting in death. The charge carries a maximum sentence of life in prison. The new case remains pending, and Kuhn is presumed innocent unless prosecutors prove the allegation beyond a reasonable doubt.
On Feb. 28, 2004, Savannah’s mother, Lisa Routier, was at work while Savannah, her younger sister, a babysitter and the babysitter’s son were at the family’s home at 17 Yates St. Investigators said the fire began on the back porch shortly after midnight and was deliberately set. The babysitter’s son became aware of the fire, and those inside started getting out. Once outside, the babysitter realized Savannah was no longer with the group. She tried to return, officials said, but the fire was already too intense. Firefighters later found Savannah in Routier’s bedroom. Police said they believed the child had gone there looking for her mother.
Investigators soon considered Kuhn a suspect. Police said he had once been in a relationship with Routier and that she had a no-contact order of protection against him. Authorities later said they believed Routier was the target of the alleged arson. But the case did not produce an immediate arrest. Despite investigators’ suspicions, police said they did not have sufficient evidence to charge Kuhn at the time. Savannah’s death therefore entered the ranks of Rochester’s unresolved cases, leaving her relatives without a trial and leaving the government without a defendant it believed it could successfully prosecute.
Years passed before detectives again developed information they considered significant. The renewed investigation eventually led to Kuhn’s arrest in Florida in late December 2023. He was returned to Rochester and arraigned in January 2024 on state charges of second-degree murder and first-degree arson. Kuhn pleaded not guilty. The arrest was a major moment for Savannah’s family, which had spent nearly 20 years waiting for a case to reach court. Police Chief David Smith told relatives that an arrest could not bring Savannah back but said authorities hoped the proceeding would provide some solace by placing the accusation before the justice system.
Savannah’s older sister, Kelly Streber, said at the time that the family had never stopped fighting and that Savannah had not been forgotten. The comments reflected the extraordinary length of the investigation: a child who was 8 when she died in 2004 had become the center of a criminal prosecution launched nearly two decades later. The state case appeared poised to provide a forum for prosecutors to present the accumulated evidence and for Kuhn’s attorneys to contest it. Instead, the prosecution encountered a problem rooted not in the newest investigative work, but in information dating back to 2005.
As the case moved toward trial, a former jail cellmate of Kuhn testified that he had told Rochester police in 2005 that Kuhn confessed to killing Savannah, according to WXXI. The account raised a major legal problem because authorities had not handled the information as part of an active prosecution at the time. Rochester police Capt. Greg Bello said it was “insufficiently documented or acted upon.” The newly disclosed history changed the legal assessment of how long the government effectively had relevant information while the case remained unresolved.
On Oct. 7, 2025, State Supreme Court Justice Stephen Miller dismissed Kuhn’s indictment as jury selection was expected to begin. Monroe County District Attorney Brian Green said the disclosure concerning the 2005 report triggered Kuhn’s constitutionally protected speedy-trial rights. Green emphasized that the result was not a judgment on the merits of the evidence. Kuhn had not been acquitted after a trial; rather, the prosecution ended because the judge concluded the state could not proceed consistently with the defendant’s constitutional rights. The decision resulted in Kuhn’s release and stunned Savannah’s relatives, who had expected the long-awaited case to be heard by a jury.
Police acknowledged the record-keeping problem and said the department had made substantial changes since the early investigation, including new technology and procedures designed to ensure records are electronically submitted and remain trackable. Officials also said they would continue pursuing cold cases. Those reforms could not change what had happened in Kuhn’s state prosecution, however. The disclosure had transformed a case that had survived decades of uncertainty into one that ended before opening statements, leaving no verdict on the central allegation that Kuhn set the fire.
A year later, the case shifted jurisdictions. On Oct. 19, 2026, U.S. Attorney Michael DiGiacomo announced that a federal grand jury had returned a one-count indictment against Kuhn. The indictment alleges that he maliciously destroyed the rental property at 17 Yates St. by setting it on fire and that the offense resulted in a death. Federal authorities identified the person who died by the initials S.S.; local authorities have long identified Savannah as the child killed in the blaze. Unlike the state prosecution, the new case does not charge Kuhn with New York murder and first-degree arson offenses.
Instead, federal prosecutors are using a statute that applies to arson of property used in interstate commerce. The government describes the Yates Street house as rental property, a fact tied to the federal basis for the charge. That distinction makes the current case a separate prosecution rather than a simple reopening of the dismissed state indictment. The government must establish the elements of its federal charge in court, including the jurisdictional elements required by the statute. The federal indictment does not establish that Kuhn committed the offense, and no jury has returned a guilty verdict against him in connection with Savannah’s death.
Kuhn was arraigned on the federal indictment in the Northern District of Florida on Oct. 19 and ordered detained. The Justice Department said he would be returned to the Western District of New York. Rochester police and the Bureau of Alcohol, Tobacco, Firearms and Explosives participated in the investigation leading to the federal charge, and Assistant U.S. Attorney Melissa M. Marangola is prosecuting the case. The Western District’s public calendar now lists a status conference for Kuhn at 2 p.m. Nov. 23 before Magistrate Judge Mark W. Pedersen in Rochester.
The federal proceeding adds another stage to a timeline already spanning the greater part of Savannah’s would-be adulthood: the 2004 fire, years without charges, the 2023 arrest, the 2025 dismissal and the 2026 federal indictment. It also returns the unresolved accusation to a courtroom after the state case ended without a trial. What happens next will be determined under federal law, and the evidence has yet to be tested before a federal jury. More than 22 years after Savannah died, the legal process is active again, but it has still not produced a final judgment about who was responsible for the fire.
Author note: Last updated November 21, 2026.