Florida man killed his two young children on day their mother had custody police say

Authorities have disclosed earlier calls to the home but have not said they amounted to warnings that the two children were in danger.

COCOA, Fla. — Cocoa police had been called about 11 times since 2021 to the home where two young children and their father were found dead Oct. 7, but authorities have not said those earlier contacts warned that 7-year-old Remy Dingwall and 5-year-old Aria Dingwall faced a threat.

The history of calls to the Sorrento Drive address emerged as investigators examined the deaths of Remy, Aria and their 37-year-old father, Joseph Kyle Dingwall. Police Chief Evander Collier IV said investigators believe Dingwall killed his children and then died by suicide. The department has not announced a motive. Its review of earlier calls provides background on police activity at the property, but Collier’s comments also drew a boundary around what those records can establish: some involved medical matters or suspicious activity, and officials had not publicly tied them to the killings.

One entry in the dispatch history was classified with “suicide” as the cause, Collier confirmed at a briefing after the bodies were found. He said he could not determine at that stage whether the call involved Dingwall or another person associated with the residence. Police did not identify the date, circumstances or subject of that entry in the reports reviewed for this story. Without those details, the record does not establish that Dingwall had previously threatened suicide, that the children were present during that incident or that officers had information pointing to the events of Oct. 7.

The unanswered questions surrounding those earlier contacts are separate from the evidence police say they found after the deaths. Officers were dispatched to 100 Sorrento Drive around midday after the children’s mother, Olivia Piccolo, entered the home and found all three. Piccolo had been trying to reach Dingwall, and it was a day on which she was supposed to have custody of Remy and Aria. Reports based on the 911 recording also say the children had been marked absent from school, prompting additional concern before she went to the house.

Piccolo found the front door partially open, entered and discovered Dingwall and the children unresponsive, police said. During the emergency call, she reported what she had found and told a dispatcher there was a gun at the scene. The call came at about 12:43 p.m. Officers secured the residence and began processing it as a death investigation. Police initially used tentative language, saying the scene appeared to involve a murder-suicide and that there was no continuing threat to the neighborhood while detectives worked through the evidence.

By the following day, the department had publicly identified the three people and said the investigation pointed to Dingwall as the person who killed the children. Police said the deaths involved gunfire. Because Dingwall was also dead, investigators could not question the person they believe was responsible. That makes physical evidence, electronic records, witness accounts, surveillance recordings and the medical examination of the bodies particularly important to reconstructing both the sequence and any possible reason for what happened.

A neighbor’s account gave detectives a potential overnight marker. Marcos Garcia, who lives across from the Dingwall home, said he heard two gunshots around 12:20 a.m. Surveillance footage from the area recorded a man outside the home near that time. Television reports showed the figure moving around the property with a light before going back toward the residence. Police said they believed the recording showed Dingwall. Collier said no one called the department that night to report the gunshots, so officers did not arrive in response to the sounds Garcia later described.

Investigators have not publicly said whether the noises Garcia reported were the shots that killed Remy and Aria, or whether additional gunfire occurred at another time. The department also has not released the exact times of death. Those limits are important because the surveillance video may help establish activity at the house, but a recording of a person outside cannot by itself show what occurred inside or when each death happened. Police have treated the footage as part of a broader evidentiary picture rather than a complete record of the crime.

The lack of an overnight emergency call became notable only after officers learned that a neighbor had heard the sounds. It does not establish what Garcia or anyone else understood at the time. The reports do not say he witnessed a shooting or knew children were in immediate danger. His later statement supplied investigators with information they did not receive when the noises occurred. Police then had to compare that recollection with the recording, evidence inside the home and other information gathered after Piccolo’s 911 call roughly 12 hours later.

The earlier service history at the address presents a similar problem of interpretation. A police dispatch to a home can involve circumstances ranging widely in seriousness, and Collier said the records included medical calls as well as suspicious-activity reports. Officials have not released a narrative for all 11 responses, and there is no public basis to say they formed a pattern of escalating violence. Nor has the department announced that any previous call concerned a threat by Dingwall against his children. Treating the raw number as a warning record would go beyond what police have disclosed.

What investigators have said with greater confidence concerns the final discovery. Piccolo was expected to receive the children under the parents’ custody arrangement, could not reach Dingwall and went to the home. The children were not killed during a custody exchange witnessed by their mother, according to the sequence police have released. Instead, she encountered the aftermath. The custody schedule explains why she appeared at the house and why the lack of communication became urgent, while the surveillance evidence suggests police were looking at events many hours before her arrival.

Relatives said the police conclusion was difficult to reconcile with their recent experiences. Dingwall’s grandmother, Cheryl Trimmer, told Florida Today that she had been around him and the children during the previous weekend and remembered a Friday trip to the movies. She said Dingwall loved his children and that she felt numb. Her remarks documented the family’s shock but did not offer a factual explanation for the killings, and investigators have not publicly identified an argument, message or other event that they say triggered them.

Remy and Aria have meanwhile been remembered independently of the evidence surrounding their deaths. Fundraising pages created to support Piccolo described the children as best friends as well as siblings. Remy was portrayed as kind, smart and protective, with interests in music, games and his friends. Aria was remembered as compassionate, brave and fond of animals and the color pink. The pages sought help for funeral expenses and other costs confronting their mother after the loss of both children.

The investigation therefore contains several different categories of information that should not be conflated: police have stated their conclusion about who was responsible; a neighbor and camera supplied evidence about activity around midnight; the mother provided the emergency call that brought officers to the scene; and dispatch logs show earlier contacts with the address whose relevance remains uncertain. Police have not publicly shown that the prior calls predicted the killings, nor have they announced a motive tying those pieces together.

Nothing released by Cocoa police has shown that the earlier calls for service amounted to advance notice that Remy or Aria faced a specific danger. The dispatch history may help investigators understand the household’s prior contacts with authorities, but its relevance remains limited by missing details, including who was involved in the entry coded “suicide.” Unless police release additional records connecting those encounters to Dingwall or the children, the prior calls remain background to the case rather than evidence that the killings were preceded by a documented warning.

Author note: Last updated November 18, 2026.