Randal Moon Jr. admitted making the trip to Delaware County but denied knowing the victim was hidden inside the other vehicle.
MUNCIE, Ind. — Randal Moon Jr. did not deny following a rental car into rural Delaware County or driving two people away after the vehicle was set on fire. His trial instead turned on what he knew when he made that trip. An Indiana jury concluded the evidence proved criminal responsibility, convicting him of five felonies in Michael D. Greer’s death before a judge sentenced Moon to 86 years in prison.
The verdict resolved the central conflict presented during Moon’s September trial. Moon, 41, testified that he did not know Greer was in the trunk of the rental car and did not know co-defendants Amy Singhas and Ameariss Aponte intended to burn it. Prosecutors countered with cellphone records, evidence about Moon’s presence before the trip, his conduct after the fire and his handling of Greer’s financial information. They argued that those facts were inconsistent with an innocent driver who had unknowingly entered a homicide. After hearing the competing accounts over a weeklong trial, jurors convicted Moon of murder, arson resulting in serious bodily injury, kidnapping, obstruction of justice and conspiracy to obstruct justice.
Moon’s defense was possible in part because some important facts were undisputed. He acknowledged that he drove a pickup truck as Singhas and Aponte traveled in another vehicle from Indianapolis toward Delaware County in the early hours of Dec. 14, 2025. He also acknowledged being at the rural field after the rental car left the roadway. Once the car was burning, Singhas and Aponte got into Moon’s truck, and he drove them back to Indianapolis. Defense attorney Ron Smith emphasized that Moon never admitted knowing Greer was in the trunk. That gap between admitted conduct and disputed knowledge became the issue jurors had to weigh against the prosecution’s broader evidence.
Prosecutors asked the jury to begin earlier than the drive. Evidence placed Moon at an Indianapolis home where authorities said Greer had been assaulted before being transported from the city. Cellphone location data, prosecutors said, showed Moon at the residence at the relevant time. A video recovered during the investigation reportedly showed Greer being beaten, although prosecutors acknowledged Moon was not visible in that recording. For the state, the point was not that the video by itself proved Moon’s role. It was that Moon’s location, his later travel with the other defendants and his actions after Greer’s death formed a connected sequence that contradicted his description of himself as uninformed.
The condition of Greer’s body also shaped the prosecution’s account. A motorist or witness reported a vehicle fire at about 3:45 a.m. Dec. 14 along County Road 500 South west of Indiana 3. Delaware County deputies responded and eventually found Greer’s remains in the trunk. Investigators said Greer had been beaten and shot before the vehicle was set ablaze. An autopsy found soot in his lungs and trachea, which authorities said established that he was still breathing when the fire began. DNA testing later formally identified the remains as the 58-year-old Shelbyville resident. The findings transformed the vehicle fire into a homicide investigation and led detectives back toward Indianapolis.
The state then presented details from after the fire that prosecutors said exposed Moon’s knowledge. According to trial reporting, Moon had taken a photograph of Greer’s credit card on the morning Greer died and later attempted to use the card at a Menards store. Prosecutors also said Moon traveled with Singhas and Aponte to Greer’s Shelbyville home two days after the killing. Those events had no direct bearing on who physically ignited the rental car, but prosecutors used them to argue that Moon was participating in activity surrounding Greer rather than simply providing transportation to two acquaintances. The jury was asked to consider the conduct collectively rather than as a set of unrelated incidents.
Moon’s statements about when he learned someone had died were also challenged. Prosecutors presented cellphone data indicating he had viewed and photographed news coverage concerning the homicide. They contrasted that activity with statements in which he claimed not to have known initially that the car fire resulted in a death. The prosecution’s closing argument portrayed Moon as a participant whose actions helped the group move between the Indianapolis residence, the Delaware County field and later Greer’s property. Deputy Prosecutor Maricel Driscoll told jurors that the evidence made him more than a getaway driver, while the defense maintained the state had not proved that Moon knew Greer was inside the car.
The question mattered because prosecutors did not have to prove Moon personally carried out every act inflicted on Greer to establish liability under the charges presented to the jury. Court reporting described his murder conviction as aiding, inducing or causing murder. The state argued that his assistance and knowing participation were sufficient when considered alongside the conduct of the other alleged participants. That framework allowed jurors to focus on whether Moon intentionally aided the crimes instead of requiring evidence that he personally performed each violent act. The defense therefore concentrated on knowledge: If Moon truly did not know Greer was present or what the others planned, his admitted driving would take on a different legal meaning.
The jury rejected that account Sept. 18 after several hours of deliberations. The verdicts covered murder, arson resulting in serious bodily injury, kidnapping, obstruction of justice and conspiracy to obstruct justice. Delaware County Prosecuting Attorney Eric Hoffman said afterward that justice had been served and praised Chief Deputy Prosecutor Zach Craig, Driscoll, the prosecutor’s investigator and the sheriff’s office. Judge Judi L. Calhoun, who had presided over the trial and earlier denied Moon’s request for bond, scheduled sentencing for the following month. On Oct. 13, she imposed an 86-year prison term, making Moon the first defendant charged in Greer’s death to be convicted and sentenced.
The trial was also the first time a jury evaluated a substantial portion of the evidence gathered during the months-long investigation. Five people were ultimately charged: Moon, Singhas, Aponte, Megan Sloan and Tallis McCoy. Investigators alleged different roles for different defendants. Reports said Singhas acknowledged driving the rental car carrying Greer toward Delaware County, while authorities alleged Aponte later drove the vehicle off the road before it was burned. Moon’s case was distinct because his pickup truck provided transportation away from the scene. The convictions against Moon do not determine whether any of the four other defendants committed the crimes alleged against them, and unresolved defendants remain presumed innocent.
Even after Moon’s trial, public reporting has not supplied a verified motive for Greer’s killing. Greer’s relatives told WTHR that he had been in a relationship with Singhas, but authorities have not publicly established that relationship as the reason for the homicide. His obituary described him in terms far removed from the courtroom evidence, recalling his love of family and friends, generosity and humor. Those remembrances became part of a case otherwise dominated by location data, surveillance evidence, cellphone records and arguments over what Moon understood at each point in the night.
The distinction between fact and allegation remains particularly important as the other cases proceed. Moon has been convicted, so the conduct established against him at trial can be reported as the basis of a jury verdict. Allegations against Singhas, Aponte, Sloan and McCoy remain subject to their own court proceedings unless resolved through pleas or separate verdicts. Earlier reports listed court dates extending into December, though several dates associated with Singhas, Sloan and Aponte have now passed and no reliable source reviewed for this update established a final disposition for each of them. A Dec. 14 trial had most recently been reported for McCoy.
For Moon, however, the trial-level question has been answered. His own account put him on the trip and at the field, while the prosecution supplied evidence it said demonstrated he understood and assisted what was happening. The jury accepted the state’s interpretation, and Calhoun’s 86-year sentence converted that verdict into a prison term likely to keep Moon incarcerated for decades. Any further challenge to his conviction would proceed separately from the pending prosecutions of the other people charged in connection with Greer’s death.
Author note: Last updated November 20, 2026.