New York man killed ex-girlfriend after breakup then kept her severed head in suitcase

The investigation moved rapidly from a welfare check to search warrants after Dale’s belongings were found along an Ulster County road.

KINGSTON, N.Y. — The murder case against Damon Foy began not with a homicide call but with worried relatives, an unanswered question about Alberta Dale’s whereabouts and a welfare check that failed to locate the Pennsylvania woman at a Kerhonkson residence where investigators knew she had recently been.

Within roughly two days, deputies had shifted from looking for a missing person to executing search warrants and recovering human remains. More than two years later, Foy, 50, admitted in Ulster County Court that he murdered Dale. He pleaded guilty Oct. 7 to second-degree murder before Judge Bryan E. Rounds. Prosecutors said Dale, 44, had recently ended their relationship when Foy killed her between March 31 and April 1, 2024, dismembered her body and began disposing of her remains.

The first official step came April 1, when Dale’s family in Pennsylvania contacted authorities because they were concerned for her welfare. The request reached the Ulster County Sheriff’s Office, and deputies went to Foy’s residence. Dale was not there. Investigators found circumstances that kept the inquiry open, including her vehicle at the property, according to later court reporting. A formal missing-person investigation followed, bringing in additional law enforcement resources as officials tried to determine when Dale had last been seen and where she might have gone.

A member of the public provided the next break. On April 2, someone found property belonging to Dale along a road in the town of Wawarsing and turned it over to authorities. The district attorney’s office said investigators quickly identified the property as hers. Law&Crime reported that the items included her cellphone and personal belongings. The find was significant because it placed possessions linked to the missing woman away from the residence and added to investigators’ concern that her disappearance could involve foul play.

Deputies returned to the residence as the inquiry escalated. The Sheriff’s Office sought warrants for Foy’s home and other locations, according to prosecutors. During the investigation, authorities encountered evidence they said connected the residence to Dale’s death. A public briefing in April 2024 said a search warrant was executed at Foy’s apartment on April 3 by the Sheriff’s Office, New York State Police forensic and major-crimes personnel and the district attorney’s office. Human remains found there were identified as Dale’s, officials said, and investigators later located additional remains in the town of Marlboro.

The district attorney’s 2026 account gives April 2 as the date Dale’s remains were ultimately located, while the 2024 Sheriff’s Office briefing said remains were found during the April 3 warrant search. The reports therefore differ on the precise discovery date. Both place the critical discoveries within the same narrow period after Dale’s family sought help and after her belongings were found in Wawarsing. Prosecutors have not suggested that the one-day discrepancy changes their account of when Foy killed Dale, which they place between March 31 and April 1.

Court filings reviewed by Law&Crime describe what happened inside the residence in more detail. Officers found a suitcase in a closet that appeared unusually heavy and later noticed what looked like dried blood on it, according to that reporting. After a warrant was obtained to search it, investigators discovered partial remains belonging to Dale. Other physical evidence was recovered in the apartment as well. The records said some portions of Dale’s remains were not located during that specific search, while the Sheriff’s Office later reported that additional remains were recovered during the continuing investigation outside the apartment.

The search also produced statements prosecutors could use to connect Foy directly to the killing. According to court filings reported by Law&Crime, Foy told investigators, “I killed her,” while they were at his residence. In a later police interview, he discussed his anger over the end of the relationship and being told to leave a residence. He described feeling that Dale had played him “like a fool” and “like a sucker.” Investigators and prosecutors treated those remarks as Foy’s own account, not as an independent finding about Dale or a justification for the violence.

The evidence trail extended beyond what investigators found during the search. Court records described prior domestic violence concerns between Foy and Dale and said a stay-away protection order was in effect. One earlier incident involved a gun, according to Law&Crime’s review of the records. Dale had also reportedly told a crime victims unit that if she disappeared, Foy would be responsible for killing her. Authorities said in 2024 that Foy was out on bail from an earlier domestic violence matter when Dale was killed.

By April 19, 2024, the investigation had produced an eight-count grand jury indictment. Prosecutors charged Foy with second-degree murder and concealment of a human corpse, along with aggravated criminal contempt, first-degree criminal contempt, third-degree criminal mischief, third-degree assault, criminal obstruction of breathing or blood circulation and fourth-degree criminal possession of a weapon. He was held without bail after his arraignment as the case moved into pretrial proceedings.

The prosecution then continued for about two and a half years. Chief Assistant District Attorney Elizabeth Culmone-Mills said her office worked closely with the Ulster County Sheriff’s Office, New York State Police and other agencies to build the case. The district attorney credited State Police forensic investigators, Bureau of Criminal Investigation personnel from several barracks, the Major Crimes Unit and the Ulster County Medical Examiner’s Office. Culmone-Mills and Senior Assistant District Attorney Luba Reznikova of the Special Victims Bureau are prosecuting the case.

Foy’s Oct. 7 plea ended the need to present that accumulated evidence to a trial jury. By admitting second-degree murder, he accepted criminal responsibility for intentionally killing Dale. Prosecutors have described the case as one rooted in domestic violence after the end of a relationship. District Attorney Emmanuel C. Nneji said after the plea that Dale’s killing demonstrated the danger faced by victims targeted by abusive partners and called for procedures that provide meaningful protection rather than protection that exists only formally.

The case is now moving toward punishment rather than fact-finding. Law&Crime reported that Foy is expected under the plea agreement to receive 23 years to life in state prison and that Dale’s family supported the prosecution’s recommendation. The district attorney’s office has scheduled sentencing for 1:30 p.m. Dec. 16 in Ulster County Court. Until Rounds imposes sentence, that hearing remains the final major court step in a case investigators began with a family’s request to find a missing woman.

Author note: Last updated November 19, 2026.