Sheriff disarms murder suspect carrying two knives after chance encounter at his mother’s home

The investigation into Eden Sexton moved from a Columbus disappearance to an Alabama murder charge and an unexpected Mississippi capture.

COLUMBUS, Ga. — When police first asked for help finding Eden Sexton in February, they described a 49-year-old woman who had vanished after being seen along a busy Columbus corridor. Nearly eight months later, the search had become a murder case spanning Georgia, Alabama and Mississippi, with a suspect captured after a confrontation beside a sheriff’s mother’s property. That suspect, Comer McWaters, died Nov. 14 in Alabama custody before the murder charge against him could be tried.

Sexton’s case developed in stages rather than through a single public breakthrough. Columbus police initially focused on locating her. Alabama investigators joined months later after a person of interest was identified there. A murder warrant followed, but the man named in it was found hundreds of miles away in Mississippi only after deputies received a tip about someone living under an assumed identity. The arrest appeared to give prosecutors a path toward presenting their evidence in court. McWaters’ death before trial now means the allegations will remain without a verdict while investigators have yet to publicly answer several central questions about Sexton’s death.

The known chronology begins on Feb. 22. Columbus police said Sexton was last seen at about 11 a.m. in the 4000 block of Victory Drive. When her disappearance was reported five days later, the department’s Special Victims Unit took the case and police issued a public request for information. They described Sexton as 5 feet 5 inches tall and about 220 pounds, with blond hair and brown eyes, and said she had last been seen wearing a yellow shirt and black pants. Nothing in that initial public appeal identified a suspect or said police believed she had been killed.

As the weeks passed, people close to Sexton tried to draw attention to her disappearance while investigators continued working. Public accounts from friends said she had been staying at a motel around the time she vanished. One friend said motel employees believed Sexton had left with an older man. That information later became significant because investigators focused on McWaters, a 68-year-old man from Little Texas in Macon County, Alabama. Authorities have not publicly released a complete timeline showing when police first contacted him or precisely what caused investigators to shift their attention toward him.

The formal expansion into Alabama came in June. Columbus police asked the Alabama Law Enforcement Agency’s State Bureau of Investigation to open a missing-person inquiry there after McWaters was identified as a person of interest and investigators connected him to Macon County. Alabama agents developed evidence during that investigation that officials said supported a murder warrant. The agency later announced that McWaters was wanted in connection with Sexton’s death. It did not publicly disclose the full affidavit or investigative record explaining how agents concluded a murder had occurred.

That distinction matters because some of the most specific claims about the case have come from people close to Sexton rather than from a detailed official release. Family members have said investigators found DNA evidence connected to Sexton at locations associated with McWaters, including his property and vehicle. State investigators have not publicly confirmed all of those specific claims. Friends also relayed an account that McWaters had said Sexton left his vehicle after the two argued. Authorities have not released a full interview transcript or publicly described that statement as an accepted explanation of what happened.

By September, investigators had a murder warrant, but McWaters was no longer in Macon County. Perry County authorities in Mississippi said they received information Sept. 21 about an Alabama man staying in the Buck Creek community under an alias. The tip suggested he might be trying to avoid arrest. A deputy went to the area to contact him. McWaters allegedly fled into nearby woods before he could be detained, prompting deputies to search the area and warn residents while they tried to determine where he had gone.

The search did not end through tracking equipment, a roadblock or a planned raid. Sheriff Jacob Garner later went to visit his mother, whose home was in the same community. While there, he saw a man emerge from the wooded area and approach the private driveway near the property. Garner recognized him as the person deputies had been looking for. Authorities said McWaters was carrying two large knives and became aggressive when Garner confronted him. The sheriff and McWaters struggled before Garner disarmed him and took him into custody.

At that point, Mississippi authorities were dealing with conduct that allegedly occurred in their jurisdiction. McWaters was accused of trespassing, disorderly conduct, assault on an officer, resisting arrest and giving false identification to law enforcement. Once his identity was confirmed, officials learned he was the subject of the Alabama murder warrant. The discovery connected what had begun as a local report about a man using another name to the much older investigation into Sexton’s disappearance. McWaters was held in the Perry County Jail while officials prepared to return him to Alabama.

His extradition moved the case into its next legal phase. McWaters was returned to Alabama and formally charged with murder in Sexton’s death. Macon County Sheriff Andre Brunson later said McWaters was being detained in Montgomery so State Bureau of Investigation agents could conduct interviews with him. Still, authorities did not use the transfer to release the major factual details that remained unknown publicly. They did not announce a motive, provide a full account of Sexton’s final known movements or disclose a cause of death for her.

McWaters’ custody then ended unexpectedly. Macon County Coroner Hal Bentley said McWaters died early Nov. 14 at Baptist South Hospital in Montgomery. Brunson said he had been moved from jail to the hospital and underwent two surgeries. Officials did not immediately say what medical problem led to those procedures or whether it had developed before or during his detention. McWaters’ body was sent to the Alabama Department of Forensic Science for examination, and the official cause and manner of his death remained pending.

His death prevents the murder case from producing the normal sequence of hearings, discovery, evidentiary disputes and a trial verdict. A warrant and criminal charge reflect a finding of probable cause, not a determination of guilt. McWaters had not been convicted of killing Sexton, and the evidence against him had not been tested before a jury. That leaves the case in an unusual position: investigators had advanced far enough to accuse a specific person of murder, but the criminal justice system will not now determine that accusation through trial.

The absence of a trial also places greater importance on what investigators may eventually make public. Officials have not released a complete account of where they believe Sexton died, how she died, where key evidence was recovered or whether another person played any role. The public reporting available so far also does not settle every question about what happened to Sexton’s remains. Those gaps are especially significant because some details attributed to family members or friends remain outside the limited set of facts formally confirmed by the State Bureau of Investigation.

For people who followed the case from its earliest days, that leaves a striking contrast between the beginning and the present. The first official appeal centered on finding a woman whose whereabouts were unknown. Months later, authorities were preparing a murder prosecution against a named suspect. The transition from one stage to the other was substantial, yet the public has received only portions of the evidence behind it. McWaters’ death means many of those details may now emerge, if at all, through investigative disclosures rather than through testimony and exhibits introduced in open court.

Sexton’s disappearance therefore remains the center of the story even after the unusual arrest that brought national attention to McWaters. She was a missing woman before she became the victim named in a murder warrant, and much of what happened after her last known appearance on Victory Drive remains outside the public record. The case moved from Columbus to Macon County, then unexpectedly to a wooded Mississippi community before returning to Alabama. McWaters’ death closes the possibility of a trial against him, but it does not by itself answer what happened to Sexton after Feb. 22.

Author note: Last updated Nov. 16, 2026.