2-year-old Georgia girl dies with kratom and nitrous oxide in her system as parents face murder charges

Georgia law defines the charge through child cruelty, while police have released only part of the evidence in Nevaeh Wynn’s death.

CONYERS, Ga. — The second-degree murder charges filed against two parents in the death of their 2-year-old daughter carry a specific meaning under Georgia law, but authorities have not yet publicly explained the full conduct they say supports the accusation.

Rafael Pedron Wynn, 30, and Kerri Dysart, 28, were arrested Sept. 24 after a months-long investigation into the May 3 death of Nevaeh Wynn. Police have said detectives found used nitrous oxide canisters and an empty container of kratom capsules in the family residence, and later toxicology testing detected both substances in the child’s system. The DeKalb County Medical Examiner’s Office classified the manner of death as homicide. Those facts explain the broad outline of the prosecution, but the legal charge adds another layer: Georgia’s second-degree murder statute is tied to a death caused during cruelty to children in the second degree. Public reports have not yet set out the alleged child-cruelty conduct in detail.

That distinction separates the charge from the more familiar idea of intentional or premeditated murder. Georgia law states that second-degree murder occurs when a person causes another person’s death while committing cruelty to children in the second degree, irrespective of malice. A conviction is punishable by 10 to 30 years in prison. The statute does not mean that every child death involving alleged negligence automatically becomes second-degree murder, and it does not relieve prosecutors of the obligation to prove the required underlying conduct. In this case, the publicly available reporting does not include an indictment narrative, affidavit or prosecutor’s statement specifying whether the alleged cruelty consists of providing the substances, leaving them accessible, failing to intervene, or some other act or omission.

The investigation began as an emergency response, not as a publicly announced homicide case. Conyers police officers went to a home on McDonough Road on May 3 after a report of an unresponsive child. Nevaeh was transported to Piedmont Rockdale Hospital, where she was pronounced dead. Detectives later secured a search warrant. Police said they recovered used nitrous oxide canisters and an empty kratom-capsule container. No public report reviewed for this article says officers arrested the parents that day or immediately accused them of causing the death. Instead, the case remained under investigation while detectives worked with the medical examiner, a sequence that placed forensic findings at the center of the later charging decision.

Toxicology became the bridge between the death investigation and the homicide case. Conyers Police Lt. Kayla Hinds told WSB-TV that the medical examiner found traces of kratom and nitrous oxide in Nevaeh’s system and that the death was ruled a homicide. WSB-TV also reported that the medical examiner concluded the cause of death was a drug overdose. Some other local reports have used more cautious language, saying toxicology testing was completed and the manner of death was then classified as homicide. FOX 5 Atlanta reported that authorities had not released the exact cause of death or explained precisely how the recovered items factored into the toddler’s death. That unresolved difference in public detail is important because the underlying reports themselves have not all described the medical findings in the same depth.

Kratom, one of the substances mentioned by investigators, is made from the leaves of a tropical tree native to Southeast Asia. The DEA says its psychoactive compounds can produce stimulant effects at lower doses and sedative effects at higher doses. It is not federally controlled under the Controlled Substances Act, though the DEA lists it as a drug and chemical of concern. Police said the family residence contained an empty container of kratom capsules, but they have not publicly disclosed the brand, strength, number of capsules originally in the container or any residue-testing results. Nor have they released a quantity from Nevaeh’s toxicology report. Without those details, the public cannot determine from the reporting alone how investigators connected the product container to the substance detected in the child.

The nitrous oxide evidence is likewise incomplete in the public record. Investigators said they recovered used canisters, and Hinds said toxicology detected nitrous oxide. Yet no report reviewed for this story identifies how many canisters were found, whether they were in the child’s reach, whether they were tested for fingerprints or residue, or how recently they had been used. Police have not publicly described the alleged mechanism of exposure. That absence of detail does not weaken or strengthen the case by itself; it simply defines the boundary between what authorities have announced and what remains unknown. In a criminal case, especially one involving a child’s death, reporting beyond that boundary risks turning inference into accusation.

Wynn and Dysart were arrested more than four months after the May 3 death. Police announced the charges Oct. 1, and several Atlanta-area outlets reported that both were being held without bond in the Rockdale County Jail. Law&Crime reported that an initial court appearance was scheduled for Oct. 7. Public searches for this update did not locate reliable later reporting that described the result of that appearance, a plea, an indictment, a preliminary hearing or a trial date. It is therefore not possible from the available material to say how far the case has moved procedurally since the initial reports. The absence of a published update should not be mistaken for a legal status determination.

The legal posture also matters for how the parents are described. They have been charged, not convicted. A homicide classification by a medical examiner means the death was attributed to the act of another person, but it does not identify the criminally responsible individual or decide whether a crime was committed beyond a reasonable doubt. Those determinations belong to the criminal process. Prosecutors would have to connect the medical evidence and the circumstances in the home to the specific statutory elements of second-degree murder as charged against each defendant. Defense lawyers, if the case proceeds, would be able to challenge the state’s evidence, causation theory and interpretation of the forensic findings.

The four-month investigative period suggests that authorities considered medical and forensic results important enough to await before making arrests. Police have said they consulted the DeKalb County Medical Examiner’s Office throughout the investigation. That chronology can matter in court because it shows when investigators obtained information and how the theory of the case may have developed. But the public reports do not disclose search-warrant affidavits, interview summaries, phone data, purchase records or other investigative material that might show what officers knew at each stage. The current public narrative is therefore narrower than the complete case file likely held by police and prosecutors.

A second-degree murder prosecution can also require the court to separate the medical conclusion from the criminal allegation. The medical examiner’s homicide classification concerns the manner of death; it does not decide which person, if anyone, is legally guilty of murder. Police may rely on the classification as part of probable cause, but a criminal conviction requires proof of the charged offense against a particular defendant. That means evidence showing what Wynn allegedly knew, what Dysart allegedly knew, who controlled the substances and what each person did before the child became unresponsive could become as important as the toxicology results themselves. None of those individual findings has been laid out in detail in the public reports reviewed for this article.

The available reporting also does not identify defense attorneys, defense statements or competing medical opinions. Without that material, there is no verified basis to describe how either parent plans to answer the allegations. It would likewise be premature to assume that the case will turn only on whether kratom and nitrous oxide were present. Prosecutors may have additional evidence that has not been publicly disclosed, and defendants may challenge the state’s interpretation of the existing evidence. Court filings, if made public, could clarify whether causation, access, supervision, knowledge or another issue becomes the main point of dispute.

There is also a personal dimension that officials have acknowledged without using it as evidence. Hinds told WSB-TV that many members of the criminal investigation division are parents and said the case was difficult for investigators. A nearby church deacon described the child’s death as heartbreaking. Those remarks explain why the case resonated in the community, but they do not answer the legal questions. Police have released limited personal information about Nevaeh beyond her name and age, and there is no verified basis in the reviewed material to describe her daily life, family history or prior care arrangements.

The unresolved legal question is not whether the case is serious; the charges and homicide ruling make that clear. The unresolved question is how prosecutors will translate the forensic findings into proof of the statutory offense charged against each parent. Until more court records are public, the available record supports only a limited account: Nevaeh died May 3, investigators recovered canisters and a kratom container, toxicology detected the substances, the death was classified as homicide, and Wynn and Dysart were charged with second-degree murder.

Prosecutors ultimately will have to do more than establish that kratom and nitrous oxide were present. To obtain a conviction, the state must prove the elements of second-degree murder against each defendant under Georgia law. Wynn and Dysart remain accused, not convicted, and the reviewed public reports do not yet show how prosecutors will argue that either parent’s alleged conduct met the child-cruelty requirement underlying the charge.

Author note: Last updated November 16, 2026.