A disagreement over lunch was followed by a renewed fight about a breakup, a house and money, according to investigators.
TAMPA, Fla. — The fatal confrontation between Alan Barber and his longtime girlfriend did not begin on East Fowler Avenue, police say. It began at a restaurant, followed them into a white pickup and escalated during the drive until Barbara Susdorf was shot and killed in the passenger seat.
Tampa police say Barber, 74, was driving on Oct. 3 with a woman in her 70s whom he had known for more than two decades when an earlier disagreement continued inside the truck. Officers later arrested Barber and charged him with murder. A probable-cause affidavit reported by Law&Crime identifies the woman as 74-year-old Susdorf and describes a far more complicated dispute behind the argument: The couple had been discussing a breakup, the home they shared was in Susdorf’s name, and Barber was demanding $300,000 he claimed to have contributed toward the property.
The restaurant episode provides the immediate starting point in the timeline. According to the affidavit, Barber and Susdorf went to lunch together despite the strain in their relationship. They argued after she would not give him a dollar for the tip, investigators wrote. Tampa police did not include that detail in their public announcement, saying only that a disagreement began at a local restaurant. The two then left in Barber’s pickup, with him behind the wheel and Susdorf sitting beside him.
Once they were in the truck, the subject allegedly shifted from the lunch dispute to the much more consequential disagreement over their future. Barber told police that he and Susdorf had been together for more than 25 years and had recently expressed a desire to separate, according to the affidavit. Their relationship may have been ending, but Barber said their finances remained tied together through the home where they lived. That property, he told investigators, was held in Susdorf’s name.
Barber claimed he had put $300,000 into the house and believed that money should be returned to him if the couple split up, according to investigators. The available public material does not verify that figure. It does not show what payments Barber made, whether he had an ownership interest, whether the couple had a contract concerning the home or whether Susdorf accepted his view of their finances. Instead, the figure appears in the affidavit as part of Barber’s own explanation of the conflict that preceded the shooting.
The affidavit says Susdorf rejected Barber’s demand that the home be sold and that he receive $300,000. During the argument in the pickup, she told him she was not going to pay him, investigators wrote. She also threw a cup at him, according to the document. Barber allegedly continued pressing the financial demand. Authorities say the argument became threatening, with Barber telling Susdorf he would shoot her if she did not give him the money. The reported affidavit also says he had made a similar threat during earlier disputes about the house.
Investigators allege the confrontation then moved from words to the firearm inside the vehicle. Barber allegedly handed Susdorf a holster containing his gun. When she had the weapon, he challenged her ability to use it, according to the affidavit. Authorities say he then took the firearm from her, removed it from the holster and pointed it toward her. Barber later told investigators he “snapped,” according to the document. Police say he fired and fatally wounded Susdorf while the truck was still part of the unfolding confrontation.
The vehicle eventually came to a stop in the parking lot of a business in the 4100 block of East Fowler Avenue. Tampa police said Barber stopped there after the shooting. Law&Crime reported from the affidavit that Barber called 911 at about 11:30 a.m. and told authorities he had shot his girlfriend. Officers responding to the scene found Susdorf dead in the passenger seat. Police recovered the firearm and secured the pickup, which was later impounded for evidence.
Barber did not flee, according to police. Officers took him into custody without incident on the same day. The department announced the murder charge on Oct. 5 and said Barber had been transported to the Orient Road Jail. Law&Crime reported that the specific charge was second-degree murder. The difference in wording between the police release and the affidavit-based report reflects the level of detail each source supplied; the department’s public statement referred more generally to a murder charge.
Police also initially withheld Susdorf’s name from their public announcement, identifying her only as a woman in her 70s. That release confirmed the long relationship, the restaurant disagreement, the shooting inside the truck, the arrest and recovery of the firearm. It did not discuss the couple’s alleged breakup or the claimed $300,000. Those details became public through the probable-cause affidavit obtained by Law&Crime, making careful attribution necessary because the financial narrative largely comes from Barber’s reported statements to investigators.
That distinction also affects how the final argument can be understood. Authorities have evidence supporting their allegation that Susdorf was killed inside Barber’s vehicle and that a firearm was recovered. But the publicly reported account of what each person said before the shooting is not a complete two-sided record. Susdorf died at the scene and cannot respond to Barber’s description of their financial history, his claimed contributions to the home or his characterization of their breakup. No independent witness to the conversation inside the truck is identified in the reports reviewed for this story.
Acting Tampa Police Chief Brett Owen framed the case as a dispute that never should have become violent. “Violence is not the answer to conflict, and there is never a disagreement that should end with the tragic loss of a life,” Owen said in the department’s Oct. 5 statement. Police said a victim advocate would assist Susdorf’s family and loved ones. The department also preserved the vehicle as evidence, giving investigators a physical scene to examine alongside Barber’s statements and other evidence collected in the case.
The case is now a criminal prosecution rather than simply a police investigation. A probable-cause affidavit is designed to explain why authorities believe there is a lawful basis for a charge, but its allegations are not a determination of guilt. Prosecutors must still prove their case in court, and a defendant may contest the state’s evidence. Nothing in the publicly reviewed material establishes that a court has resolved the disputed financial claims or reached a final judgment on the murder allegation.
What the record does establish is a sequence that police say moved rapidly from an ordinary public setting to lethal violence: Barber and Susdorf ate at a restaurant, argued there, drove away together and continued fighting inside the pickup. Investigators allege that an argument over a dollar became intertwined with months or weeks of conflict about separation and property. By the time the truck stopped on Fowler Avenue, Susdorf was dead, a gun was evidence and Barber was about to enter the criminal justice system.
Barber was booked after his arrest, and Law&Crime reported that he was being held without bond when its story was updated Oct. 7. No final court disposition was found in the sources reviewed through Nov. 17. The murder case therefore remains defined by the contrast between the modest setting where the day’s argument began and the much larger unresolved dispute investigators say followed the couple from lunch into their final drive together.
Author note: Last updated November 17, 2026.