Former sheriff deputy admits hammer killing of her teenage stepdaughter before Walmart shift

Friends and relatives spent more than a decade waiting for answers, but her remains have still not been recovered.

FAIRMONT, N.C. — Sara Graham was 18, working at Walmart and beginning a new chapter in North Carolina when she vanished in 2015. Eleven years later, the stepmother who helped report her missing pleaded guilty to killing her.

Connie Graham, 65, admitted in Robeson County Superior Court on Sept. 30 that she killed Sara after an argument on the morning the teenager disappeared. She pleaded guilty to second-degree murder and received a 20-to-25-year prison sentence. The conviction gave Sara’s mother, friends and other relatives an answer to the question that had followed them for more than a decade, but it did not give them everything they had sought. Sara’s remains have not been recovered, and authorities continue searching while two of Connie Graham’s sons face pending charges tied to the alleged concealment of evidence.

Before her name became associated with a cold case, Sara was remembered by friends as a young woman making plans and forming new relationships. Reporting by the Border Belt Independent said she was a member of the Lumbee Tribe of North Carolina and had moved to Robeson County about six months before she disappeared. Sabrina Nickerson, who knew Sara from high school in Texas, later recalled a friend who was direct, cheerful and interested in learning creative things. Those memories became more prominent after arrests were made in 2026, when a vigil brought relatives and community members together to remember Sara as a person rather than only as the subject of an investigation.

Her last known morning initially seemed ordinary. Sara was expected to report to a Walmart in Pembroke on Feb. 4, 2015. She never arrived. A white van associated with the family was found later near East McDonald Road in the Fairmont area. Public appeals described Sara as a dependable employee, making the missed shift especially concerning. She had dark hair, wore glasses and braces, and was 5 feet 4 inches tall, according to the FBI’s missing-person material. For years, those identifying details accompanied requests for information as authorities tried to determine whether anyone had seen her after she left home.

Inside the family, investigators later learned of tension that was not visible in the early public appeals. Hubert Graham, Sara’s father, told authorities his wife could become jealous or confrontational over how he treated Sara compared with her children, according to the prosecution’s account reported after the plea. Hubert Graham said the last time he saw his daughter was the night before she disappeared, when he kissed her goodnight. He was away from the house the next morning and initially believed Sara had taken his van to work. Prosecutors would later say that assumption was part of a false picture of what actually happened.

For much of the next decade, Sara’s relatives lived without a confirmed explanation. The FBI joined the Robeson County Sheriff’s Office and offered a reward for information leading to her location. In a 2022 appeal, an FBI investigator said the agency had followed hundreds of leads and interviewed dozens of people. The agent said everything learned about Sara indicated she had not voluntarily walked away from her life. She had a job, was making friends and appeared happy with her new surroundings. The agency also said it believed someone close to Sara knew more than had been disclosed.

Years of investigative work produced repeated searches but no public announcement that Sara had been found. Teams searched locations in Robeson County in 2023 and again in 2025. The persistence mattered to people who had followed the case because a decade without an arrest had created the appearance of a disappearance that might never be solved. Sheriff Burnis Wilkins rejected that characterization, saying investigators and FBI agents continued working leads behind the scenes. Sara’s name remained on missing-person materials while her mother pursued a separate legal step that would change the status of the case.

On the 11th anniversary of the disappearance, Sara’s biological mother filed court papers seeking to have her declared legally dead. The petition said there had been no verified evidence that Sara was alive during the years since she vanished. A judge granted the request on June 1, 2026. Wilkins said the ruling allowed authorities to move from treating the matter as a missing-person investigation to formally treating it as a homicide case. Less than a month later, officers arrested Connie Graham and her sons Bobby Matthew McLellan and Luke Locklear.

The arrests transformed information that had long been kept from Sara’s family and the public into specific criminal allegations. Connie Graham was charged with first-degree murder before later accepting the plea to second-degree murder. Prosecutors accused McLellan and Locklear of taking part in efforts to conceal evidence. The indictments alleged that evidence was burned and that Sara’s remains were removed from the scene and disposed of. Neither man has been convicted, and their cases remain pending. Connie Graham, meanwhile, had worked as a Robeson County sheriff’s deputy when Sara vanished, a fact that added another layer to the case’s long history.

At the September plea hearing, Sara’s relatives finally heard the state’s account of her final morning. Connie Graham admitted striking Sara in the head with a hammer during an argument. Prosecutors also recounted statements from women who had shared jail space with Graham after her 2026 arrest and said she confessed to them. Sara’s mother, Cathy Armenta, delivered an emotional account of the deception she believed followed the killing, including Graham’s participation in family efforts to find and remember Sara. Graham told the court she regretted what happened. Prosecutors said Sara’s relatives approved the negotiated plea and sentence.

For Nickerson, the guilty plea brought relief but not closure. She told WMBF that the conviction answered questions her friends had carried for 11 years while also creating new ones. Most important was the continued absence of Sara’s remains. The sheriff’s office said investigators had received reliable information pointing to an area near East White Pond Road outside Fairmont. Search crews, divers, federal investigators and anthropology specialists have participated in efforts there. Authorities have not publicly said who provided the information or announced that the search has recovered Sara.

The remaining criminal cases may also determine how much more becomes known. McLellan and Locklear were released on $50,000 bonds under house-arrest conditions after initially facing much higher bonds. Court records accuse them of evidence-related offenses and conspiracy, and McLellan has also faced an accessory-after-the-fact allegation. Their next reported court appearance was set for Dec. 7. The charges are accusations unless proved in court or admitted in a plea, and Connie Graham’s conviction does not by itself establish their guilt.

Sara’s family therefore reached an unusual point in September: the person responsible for her killing admitted it in court, but Sara was still physically missing. Authorities say the effort to locate her will continue. For friends who spent years seeing her face on missing-person notices, the case is no longer about wondering whether she chose to leave. It is about recovering her remains, completing the pending prosecutions and allowing the people who knew her before 2015 to give her the final goodbye they have been denied for more than a decade.

Author note: Last updated November 16, 2026.