Former brother-in-law kills woman and shoots her brother during store confrontation

The plea stopped a pending trial and brought a life-without-parole sentence for the 2024 killing of Tigist Lulesegud in Lilburn.

LAWRENCEVILLE, Ga. — A Gwinnett County murder prosecution that had remained on the Superior Court docket for more than two years ended before trial when Teodros Mulat Shibeshi pleaded guilty to killing his former sister-in-law and shooting her brother. Shibeshi, 64, admitted malice murder, two counts of aggravated assault and possession of a firearm during the commission of a felony. Prosecutors sought life in prison without the possibility of parole plus 25 years, and the court imposed that sentence, bringing the case to a close without a jury verdict.

The plea resolved a prosecution that court records showed had been moving through the trial calendar with multiple felony counts. A Gwinnett County Superior Court calendar published before the final disposition listed Shibeshi on charges of malice murder, felony murder, two counts of aggravated assault and possession of a firearm during the commission of a felony. The final announcement from the district attorney’s office identified four guilty-plea counts: malice murder, the two aggravated assaults and the firearm offense. The office said Shibeshi pleaded guilty before a pending trial. It did not provide a separate explanation in the public sentencing announcement for the felony-murder count previously shown on the court calendar.

The underlying case began with a shooting on April 27, 2024, at a store in Lilburn. Prosecutors said Shibeshi went to the business where 57-year-old Tigist Lulesegud and her brother, 65-year-old Abebe D. Yeshetela, were working. Witnesses said an altercation began. According to the district attorney’s office, Shibeshi shot Lulesegud multiple times, continuing to fire after she had fallen. He then shot Yeshetela in the leg. Lulesegud died at the scene, while Yeshetela survived. Those acts eventually supported the murder and aggravated-assault counts that were resolved by Shibeshi’s plea.

The prosecution also included a firearm charge tied to the commission of the felonies. Georgia law treats possession of a firearm during certain crimes as a separate offense, and the district attorney’s office included that count among the charges Shibeshi admitted. The public sentencing release did not provide a count-by-count calculation showing which convictions produced each portion of the life-plus-25-year sentence. Prosecutors instead described the total punishment as the maximum sentence they requested. The most consequential part is clear: Shibeshi received life without the possibility of parole, making him ineligible for release on parole from the life sentence.

The plea avoided a trial at which prosecutors otherwise would have had to present the evidence supporting the charges. Their final public summary identifies witnesses as central to the case. People at the store told investigators that the confrontation began after Shibeshi entered. A customer also described what happened after Lulesegud and Yeshetela had been shot. According to that account, Shibeshi made a statement signaling an intention to kill himself, then pointed the gun toward himself and fired. He survived the self-inflicted wound. Because the case ended by guilty plea, the witness did not have to provide that account to a trial jury in order for prosecutors to obtain convictions.

Shibeshi’s survival initially delayed the ordinary path from crime scene to jail. Contemporary reporting said he was taken to Northside Hospital Gwinnett in critical condition after the shooting. Yeshetela also was hospitalized for treatment of the wound to his leg. By April 30, Lilburn police said Shibeshi had been charged with murder and aggravated assault and was expected to be booked into the Gwinnett County jail when released from medical care. The charges later reflected in Superior Court records were more extensive than those first announced in the immediate aftermath, as is common when an investigation advances from an initial police arrest to a formal prosecution.

Another part of the investigative process involved correcting the identities and relationships described in the first public statements. Police initially released inaccurate information suggesting that the woman killed had been Shibeshi’s former wife. Within days, investigators said a relative had clarified the relationship. Lulesegud was Shibeshi’s former sister-in-law. The district attorney’s office later specified that she was the sister of Shibeshi’s ex-wife and identified Yeshetela as Lulesegud’s brother. That final description is the relationship used by prosecutors when they announced the guilty plea and sentence in October 2026.

The prosecution did not publicly establish a detailed motive in its final announcement. Police said in 2024 that they believed the shooting was connected to domestic violence and that the wider public was not in danger, but investigators did not release a specific explanation for why Shibeshi went to the store or what led the disagreement to escalate. The district attorney’s office later called the matter a fatal family dispute and said witnesses saw an altercation begin before the shots were fired. Those descriptions establish a relationship-based confrontation without supporting a more detailed claim about Shibeshi’s reasons, and no motive was necessary for the office’s public summary of the completed case.

During the period between the shooting and the plea, the case remained a pending criminal prosecution rather than a final finding of guilt. The distinction ended when Shibeshi entered his guilty plea. Until then, court documents listed the offenses the state intended to pursue and prosecutors prepared for a possible trial. After the plea, those allegations became convictions on the four counts identified by the district attorney’s office. The sentence followed immediately enough that the office announced the plea and punishment together, describing the result as life without parole plus an additional 25 years.

Assistant District Attorney Selwin Patterson prosecuted the case. The district attorney’s office credited Investigator Dennis Hennelly and Victim Witness Advocate Chelsey Thomas with assisting and also praised the Lilburn Police Department for its investigative work. Those acknowledgments indicate the case had continued across several parts of the local justice system after the initial emergency response: police investigated the scene and witnesses, prosecutors prepared the felony case, victim-services staff worked with those affected, and Superior Court carried the case toward a trial that Shibeshi ultimately avoided by pleading guilty.

The final statement from District Attorney Patsy Austin-Gatson did not focus on the length of the prosecution or the defendant’s decision to abandon a trial. Instead, she directed attention to the family of the woman who was killed. “We hope this outcome can bring justice to Ms. Lulesegud’s family,” Austin-Gatson said. The office released no additional comments from relatives and did not publish victim-impact statements with its announcement. It likewise did not provide a detailed update on Yeshetela beyond identifying him as the surviving brother who had been shot in the leg.

The plea also meant that the public did not receive the fuller evidentiary record a trial can produce. No jury heard a chronological presentation of witness testimony, forensic evidence or competing arguments. The district attorney’s statement therefore remains the main official account of how prosecutors would have described the shooting: Shibeshi entered the store, an altercation began, he repeatedly shot Lulesegud, wounded Yeshetela and then shot himself. Public court records establish the range of charges pending before the plea, while contemporary police reports document the hospitalizations and early investigation. Beyond those facts, authorities have not released a more complete narrative of the dispute.

For the court system, however, the outstanding question of guilt has been resolved. Shibeshi’s plea eliminated the scheduled contest over whether prosecutors could prove the charged conduct beyond a reasonable doubt. The imposed sentence also matched the punishment prosecutors requested, leaving no announced trial date or further guilt-phase proceeding. More than two years after police responded to the shooting at Tana Food Mart, the case has moved from an active homicide investigation to a final criminal judgment carrying life without parole and an additional 25 years.

Author note: Last updated November 16, 2026.