Otis Parks faces capital murder in John Donat’s death as court records raise separate questions about four previously dismissed felony charges.
HOUSTON, Texas — The man charged with capital murder in the Sept. 30 killing of a chef who was feeding people in need had previously been accused of four felonies while jailed on another case, records reviewed by ABC13 show. Those charges against Otis Parks were ultimately dismissed while he was serving a prison sentence, years before police accused him of killing 58-year-old John D. Donat outside a west Houston extended-stay hotel.
The earlier cases have become a secondary issue surrounding a homicide prosecution that is still pending. Parks, 30, has not been convicted in Donat’s death, and the dismissal of his previous charges does not establish anything about whether he committed the current alleged offense. The old records instead raise a separate question about how his earlier cases were handled. ABC13 reported that prosecutors dismissed four felony counts filed while Parks was in the Harris County Jail, with court documents stating that he was already serving time on an aggravated assault conviction.
That conviction stemmed from a 2018 case. Records cited by ABC13 show Parks received a seven-year prison sentence, out of a possible 20 years, after an aggravated assault. Police said at the time that he stabbed a friend during an argument. While he remained in jail awaiting transfer to prison, authorities filed four additional felony cases accusing him of assaulting jail employees and possessing contraband. The station reported that those cases did not add prison time because they were dismissed rather than carried forward to trial or another disposition.
The record was complicated by competency proceedings. ABC13 reported that Parks was found incompetent to stand trial in 2020 and later found competent in 2021. Two of the jail-related cases were dismissed on the same day as the 2021 competency ruling, another was dismissed the following day and a fourth had been dropped months earlier, according to the station’s review. A defense lawyer not involved in the case said there could have been strategic reasons for the decisions beyond the short explanation listed in the paperwork, but his comments were an outside assessment rather than evidence of what prosecutors actually decided.
The current Harris County District Attorney’s Office told ABC13 that the dismissals occurred before District Attorney Sean Teare took office in 2025 and said it could not comment on prosecutorial choices made during the prior administration. That response leaves the record of the dismissals intact without supplying a fuller official explanation. It also underscores the separation between those old cases and the new prosecution, which will turn on evidence from the Sept. 30 shooting rather than speculation about what earlier prosecutors might have done differently.
The present case began shortly after 2 a.m. outside an extended-stay property at 2130 South Highway 6. Houston police said Donat was driving a Chevrolet Tahoe and offering food to people in the parking area. One witness told investigators that a man approached the passenger side and demanded money. She began walking away, then heard gunfire and the sound of the Tahoe crashing. Other witnesses reported hearing the shots and crash before seeing a suspect run away. When officers arrived, they found Donat wounded and the SUV through a wooden fence.
Houston Fire Department paramedics pronounced Donat dead at the scene. Police initially described the person later identified as Parks only as a person of interest. Officers from a patrol support team were in the area and found a man matching the description witnesses had provided. Police detained and questioned him and booked him into the Harris County Jail on a separate offense while detectives continued their work. On Oct. 2, Houston police announced that Parks had been charged with capital murder in the 208th Criminal District Court and publicly identified Donat as the victim.
Local reporting supplied additional detail about the theory investigators were examining. ABC13 described the confrontation as an attempted carjacking and reported that police believed Parks shot Donat as Donat tried to drive away. The station said the Tahoe went through fencing as the wounded driver attempted to escape. Police also said a handgun may have been thrown away while the suspect fled. The weapon had not been recovered by the afternoon after the shooting, according to ABC13. Houston police have not publicly released a complete forensic account of the shooting or a detailed inventory of evidence recovered from the scene.
Against the legal focus on Parks’ record, Donat’s history tells a markedly different story. His son, Nick Donat, said the former chef had been feeding homeless people for years. A fundraiser organized after the killing said Donat collected food from a local food bank, cooked meals and distributed them to people in need. It said he had experienced addiction himself and had particular empathy for people facing similar problems. Houston police Sgt. Josh Nielsen told ABC13 that Donat had been recovering, had turned his life around and wanted to give back to his community.
Those accounts help explain why Donat was outside the hotel with food in the early morning. The fundraiser said he lived at the extended-stay property and had returned at about 2 a.m. before feeding a woman outside. Police did not identify the people receiving food as part of a formal charity, and there is no indication that Donat’s efforts were connected to an organization. His son instead described the work as something his father had repeatedly chosen to do on his own. Witnesses interviewed by police independently confirmed that he was offering food immediately before the fatal encounter.
The distinction between verified police findings, family accounts and prosecutorial allegations remains important. Houston police confirmed Donat’s identity, the location and approximate time of the shooting, the crashed Tahoe, the witness reports of a demand for money and Parks’ arrest and charge. The family supplied details about Donat’s career, South Carolina roots, two sons, recovery and food-bank work. Local television reporting, citing police, characterized the case as an attempted carjacking. None of those sources, however, can substitute for the testing of evidence that occurs in a criminal proceeding.
The same caution applies to Parks’ earlier history. A past aggravated assault conviction is a matter of record, but the four jail-related cases were dismissed and did not lead to convictions. The competency findings from 2020 and 2021 also concerned Parks’ ability to participate in legal proceedings at those times; they do not by themselves establish his mental condition during the 2026 shooting or determine how the present case will proceed. His attorney declined to discuss the new prosecution with ABC13, and no publicly reviewed filing established that a competency or insanity defense has been raised in Donat’s case.
For prosecutors, the homicide investigation will depend on evidence from Sept. 30. Witnesses placed Donat in the Tahoe distributing food and described a person approaching the passenger side before the gunfire. Police said a suspect matching their description was found nearby. Investigators had the crash scene and vehicle available for examination, while the reported discarded firearm presented another potential evidentiary question. Authorities have not publicly detailed ballistics testing, surveillance footage, DNA or fingerprint evidence, if any, or statements attributed to Parks after he was detained.
For Donat’s family, the case has a more immediate consequence. A fundraiser created to cover funeral expenses and travel described plans to return him and his belongings to his sons in South Carolina. It had received more than 100 donations and raised more than $8,000 by November. Nick Donat said his father had become someone the family loved, trusted and depended on. That personal loss sits alongside the legal questions now moving through Harris County courts and the retrospective debate over decisions in Parks’ earlier cases.
Questions about Parks’ older cases may continue to draw attention, but they are separate from the evidence that will decide the prosecution over Donat’s death. Prosecutors must establish the capital murder allegation through the facts of the Sept. 30 shooting, while Parks has the right to challenge that evidence and remains presumed innocent unless convicted.
Author note: Last updated November 16, 2026.