One brother had recently celebrated his 15th birthday before both were fatally shot inside a Waxahachie home, according to authorities.
WAXAHACHIE, Texas — Days after a family celebration for a boy’s 15th birthday, he and his 21-year-old brother were dead from gunshot wounds, and their mother was in an Ellis County jail facing two counts of capital murder in a case that has left their father calling for justice.
The deaths of Christopher Scott Pitre, 21, and his younger brother have largely entered the public record through police statements, an arrest account and jail information. Their father, Scott Pitre, supplied a different piece of the story when he told NBC 5 that the family had recently celebrated the younger boy’s birthday at a lake. The teenager had just turned 15. NBC 5 reported that the family identified him as Brian Pitre, while the Ellis County Sheriff’s Office initially withheld his name because he was a juvenile.
The brothers died after deputies were called to their Waxahachie home before dawn on Oct. 1. The Sheriff’s Office said its emergency communications center received a 911 call at about 4:13 a.m. reporting an unknown emergency at a residence in the 900 block of Big Sky Drive. Deputies entered the house and found both brothers suffering from gunshot wounds. Christopher was pronounced dead there. His younger brother was transported to a local hospital in critical condition, but authorities later announced that he had also died.
For their father, the sequence compressed an ordinary family milestone and an extraordinary loss into a matter of days. NBC 5 reported that Scott Pitre said he wanted justice for his sons. The public reporting did not describe him as a witness to the shootings, and authorities said he was notified of both deaths. His comments were about the boys and the loss of them, not an explanation of what caused the violence. Investigators likewise have not publicly provided a verified motive.
The Sheriff’s Office identified the boys’ mother, Colleen Nichole Lemmon, 42, as the person investigators believe shot them. She was found at the residence with injuries that authorities described as non-life-threatening. Investigators said evidence recovered during the inquiry gave them probable cause to identify her as responsible for the shootings. She was arrested, taken to a hospital for treatment and later booked into the Wayne McCollum Detention Center on two counts of capital murder.
Details later reported from a probable cause narrative described the chaotic minutes before and after deputies arrived. NBC 5 reported that dispatchers first received a 911 hang-up call and were able to reach a female caller again. The caller allegedly said all units were needed but did not provide a clear explanation before the call disconnected. Deputies responding to the house therefore knew there was an emergency but did not have a full account of what was happening inside.
According to reports citing the arrest document, deputies encountered Lemmon with blood visible on her and found a firearm nearby. FOX 4 reported that when deputies asked about the blood, she allegedly said, “I shot both my kids.” The record also described injuries to Lemmon that appeared to have been self-inflicted. Those claims form part of the government’s probable cause narrative and have not been tested before a jury. Lemmon has been charged, but a criminal accusation is not itself proof of guilt.
The brothers’ deaths were confirmed at different times. Christopher, the older brother, was already dead when deputies entered the residence. The 15-year-old was still alive and was taken for emergency treatment. His death was announced later, adding a second homicide allegation to a case that investigators were still reconstructing. The Sheriff’s Office did not disclose whether either brother had been able to speak to first responders, and no reliable report reviewed for this story attributed any account of the shootings to either victim.
The age difference between the brothers also meant authorities handled their identities differently in the first public announcement. Christopher was named by the Sheriff’s Office as a 21-year-old Waxahachie resident. The agency withheld the teenager’s identity. His family later identified him publicly through local reporting. The distinction did not change the criminal allegations, but it shaped how the public initially learned about the victims: one by name, the other only as a 15-year-old boy who had been critically wounded and later died.
Neighbors also reacted to the deaths rather than to any known explanation for them. FOX 4 interviewed a person living near the home who described the case as heartbreaking and expressed sympathy for the family. The comments reflected the limited information available outside the investigation. Authorities had not reported a broader danger to the neighborhood, and there was no publicly verified account of another suspect being sought. The focus quickly shifted from the emergency response to the deaths of the brothers and the charges filed against their mother.
Ellis County Sheriff Brad Norman addressed that loss in the Sheriff’s Office statement. Norman said his “deepest sympathies” were with the boys’ father, other family members and loved ones. His statement did not speculate about a reason for the shootings. That restraint matched the broader public record: investigators said they had corroborating evidence supporting Lemmon’s arrest, but they did not release a theory explaining why the two brothers were allegedly targeted inside their home.
The legal case moved forward separately from the family’s mourning. Lemmon was initially treated at a hospital before being transferred to the county detention center. Early reports said bond was pending arraignment. Later jail-record reporting said her bond had been set at $2.5 million. She faces two capital murder counts, one connected to each son’s death. No final judgment has been reported, and the charges remain allegations that prosecutors would have to establish through the criminal court process.
What remains unknown is substantial. Authorities have not publicly described an argument or other triggering event before the shootings. They have not announced a motive. The publicly available reports reviewed for this article do not establish whether prosecutors have obtained additional forensic results since the initial investigation, whether further evidence has been filed in open court or what defenses might ultimately be raised. The absence of those details limits any responsible account to what investigators, court-related records and family members have actually made public.
That leaves the loss of the brothers as the clearest consequence of the case. Christopher died inside the home at 21. His younger brother, recently 15, died after first responders rushed him to a hospital. Their father went from a birthday celebration to mourning both sons within days, according to his public account. Whatever the criminal case ultimately establishes, the two deaths are not allegations: they are the confirmed event around which the investigation and prosecution have developed.
Behind the pending prosecution are two deaths that changed one family within days of a birthday celebration. Christopher Scott Pitre was 21, and his younger brother had just turned 15. Their father has publicly called for justice, while relatives continue to face the loss of both sons. The court case against Lemmon remains unresolved, but the brothers’ deaths are the lasting consequence already established beyond dispute.
Author note: Last updated November 16, 2026.