Ex-boyfriend forces his way inside and kills Florida woman’s new lover

Stuart Beck admitted firing the fatal shot, but jurors rejected his justification while stopping short of finding a premeditated murder.

CLEARWATER, Fla. — Stuart Beck’s claim that he shot Michael Conrad to protect himself survived as the central issue of his murder trial, but it did not persuade the Pinellas County jury that ultimately convicted him of second-degree murder and sent him toward a 30-year prison sentence.

The legal dispute was unusual because the basic identity of the shooter was not contested by the time Beck testified. He acknowledged firing the gun that killed Conrad, 20, inside a Clearwater apartment in the early hours of July 6, 2022. The central question was what the circumstances meant. Beck said he feared Conrad would take control of the firearm during a struggle and believed shooting was necessary. Prosecutors said Beck could not reasonably cast himself as the defender after arriving armed and forcing his way through the apartment door. That disagreement shaped both a pretrial attempt to obtain self-defense immunity and the later jury trial.

Beck had already lost one major self-defense argument before jurors were selected. In July 2025, Sixth Judicial Circuit Judge Philippe Matthey rejected his request for immunity under Florida’s self-defense law. A Florida Bar summary of Tampa Bay Times reporting said Matthey found that Beck had moved out of the apartment months before the shooting and no longer had a legal right to enter it, even though his name had remained on the lease. The judge rejected the claim that the killing was justified, allowing the first-degree murder prosecution to continue. That decision did not prevent Beck from raising self-defense before jurors, but it meant the case would have to be decided through a full criminal trial.

The forced entry later became one of the prosecution’s strongest answers to Beck’s account of the gun struggle. Clearwater police had said from the opening days of the investigation that Beck broke down the apartment’s front door. Prosecutors argued that the events inside could not be separated from that act. In closing arguments, the state emphasized that Beck entered while armed and confronted a man prosecutors described as unarmed. The prosecution’s theory was that Beck had created the dangerous encounter himself and could not rely on the final seconds of the confrontation to erase the significance of how he got into the room in the first place.

Beck’s testimony nevertheless gave jurors a detailed explanation for the moment he fired. He said that he and Conrad were wrestling over the gun and that he began losing his grip. Beck testified that he tried to strike Conrad with the firearm to make him release it but that Conrad held on. He said he believed Conrad would gain control of the weapon unless he fired. Beck also told the jury that he had been afraid because Conrad and two friends had previously beaten him. To the defense, that earlier encounter helped explain why Beck perceived a threat. To prosecutors, it did not change who had initiated the final armed confrontation at the apartment.

The testimony also exposed a major change from Beck’s earlier description of the shooting. From the period after his arrest through much of the case, he had maintained that the gun discharged accidentally, according to courtroom reporting. On the witness stand, Beck instead acknowledged an intentional trigger pull while drawing a distinction between intending to fire and intending to kill. He told jurors he meant for the weapon to go off but did not mean to kill Conrad. Prosecutors used that admission to undermine the earlier accident account. The defense, however, could still argue that an intentional gunshot was legally justified if jurors believed Beck reasonably feared he was about to lose the weapon and face serious harm.

The relationship among Beck, Conrad and Kaitlyn Nash-Koehler supplied the broader context. Nash-Koehler testified that she and Beck had broken up several months before Conrad’s death, although Beck remained listed on the lease. She said she later began seeing Conrad while still occasionally spending time with Beck. Beck denied arriving at the apartment knowing Conrad was there. Prosecutors countered with Nash-Koehler’s testimony that Beck had called and said he knew Conrad was inside because he had seen Conrad’s truck. The state used that evidence to argue that Beck’s arrival was purposeful and driven by the relationship conflict rather than by any innocent reason for visiting the apartment.

Defense attorney Scott Tremblay urged jurors to see the case through a different lens. He characterized the fatal confrontation as a heat-of-passion shooting linked to a volatile romantic triangle rather than a planned killing. That argument gave the defense another path even if jurors rejected complete self-defense: Tremblay maintained that the evidence supported manslaughter at most. Prosecutors, by contrast, sought a first-degree murder conviction and argued that Beck’s actions before the shooting showed the necessary intent and planning. The competing positions left jurors with sharply different ways to classify a killing that Beck himself admitted causing.

The jury’s verdict rejected both extremes. After less than two hours of deliberations, jurors found Beck guilty of second-degree murder. They did not accept his claim that the shooting was legally justified, and they did not reduce the case to manslaughter. But they also declined to convict him of first-degree murder, meaning they did not find the state had proved the premeditation required for that charge. Matthey later said at sentencing that he considered the jury’s distinction meaningful and believed the second-degree verdict was supported by the evidence. The result became a central reason the punishment hearing was not simply a choice between acquittal and life imprisonment.

The prosecution also relied on what Beck did after Conrad was shot. Conrad was taken to Morton Plant Hospital, where he died. Beck did not call 911 for him, prosecutors said, and he left the scene with the firearm. Assistant State Attorney Nash Licona later told the sentencing court that Beck went into the woods and hid the gun. Earlier reporting about the case said he traveled by Uber to Brooksville. Police found Beck in Pasco County the next day and arrested him. Those actions did not decide the self-defense question by themselves, but prosecutors argued they were inconsistent with the behavior of someone who believed he had just lawfully defended himself in an unavoidable emergency.

By sentencing, however, the courtroom debate had broadened beyond the technical question of self-defense. Conrad’s relatives asked for life in prison and described the damage his death had caused their family. Jessica Robertson, one of Conrad’s aunts, said the killing had removed laughter and quiet moments that should have been filled with her nephew’s voice. Ashley Anderson, another aunt, spoke about the pain of burying a 20-year-old family member. They also drew attention to a difficult part of Beck’s own history: He had witnessed his father being murdered when Beck was 15 and later testified at the trial arising from that killing.

That history became the strongest mitigation offered for Beck. His mother, Suzanne Beck, told the court that her son’s life changed after his father’s death. A longtime family friend asked Matthey to consider Beck’s character apart from the shooting. Defense attorney Keith Hammond argued that Beck’s emotional development and ability to make rational decisions had been affected. Prosecutor Licona acknowledged that Beck’s childhood experience inspired sympathy, describing the hearing as involving grief on both sides. But he argued that someone who knew firsthand what homicide did to a family had nevertheless inflicted the same kind of loss on Conrad’s relatives.

Matthey said he considered Beck’s experience of losing his father but would not treat it as an excuse. The judge also emphasized that the jury had chosen second-degree murder rather than first-degree murder. Under the sentencing rules applicable to the case, Matthey said he had to impose at least 25 years in prison. Prosecutors and Conrad’s family wanted life. Matthey selected 30 years. His sentence therefore reflected the same middle ground that had emerged from the verdict: Beck’s claim of justified self-defense had failed, yet the state’s accusation of premeditated first-degree murder had also failed to convince the jury.

The sentence, imposed Oct. 9, closed the principal trial-level proceedings more than four years after Conrad’s death. Beck entered the case claiming an accident, later testified that he intentionally fired in self-defense, and ultimately was convicted of a form of murder that did not require the jury to find premeditation. The progression illustrates why the moments before a claimed act of self-defense can be as important as the final confrontation itself. In Beck’s case, prosecutors repeatedly returned to the broken apartment door, the gun he carried inside and the choice to confront Conrad. Jurors ultimately found those circumstances supported criminal responsibility for murder, and Matthey’s 30-year sentence turned that verdict into a punishment measured in decades.

Author note: Last updated November 19, 2026.