Ex-boyfriend storms Minnesota woman’s home then opens fire on her and her new boyfriend

A boy’s emergency call began a case that ended nearly a year later with two consecutive life sentences for Randy Zimmerman.

NEW ULM, Minn. — Before detectives assembled charges, before a grand jury returned a nine-count indictment and before Randy Thomas Zimmerman admitted to two first-degree murders, the case began with a child calling 911 from a house in Hanska before dawn.

Authorities said the caller was the 13-year-old son of Tabitha Trescott. At about 4:20 a.m. on Nov. 2, 2025, he reported that his mother’s former boyfriend had broken into the home and shot her. According to the criminal complaint, the boy had awakened to yelling and heard Zimmerman tell Trescott, “I gave you a chance,” shortly before a gunshot. When the child opened his bedroom door, investigators said, he saw Zimmerman in the hallway holding a long gun. The complaint said Zimmerman pointed the weapon toward him and ordered him back into his room. The boy waited, then sought help.

Deputies entered the home and found Trescott, 32, and her partner, Justin Reinarts, 50, dead. Investigators found two spent shotgun shells upstairs. The killings immediately set off a search for Zimmerman, then 45, a Courtland resident and Trescott’s former boyfriend. Brown County authorities issued information to other agencies as the investigation expanded beyond the small city, where a violent double homicide in a residential home quickly became a regional law-enforcement operation. The child’s account gave investigators an early identification of the person he said had entered the home, and later filings added evidence and allegations gathered after officers arrived.

The search moved south into Iowa. Authorities said Zimmerman drove hundreds of miles from Brown County while deputies tried to locate him. In southeastern Iowa, officers attempted to stop his vehicle. The Louisa County sheriff said Zimmerman fired a shotgun backward from the moving vehicle toward a pursuing deputy during the chase. The deputy was not injured. Officers eventually used a vehicle intervention maneuver to force Zimmerman’s car off the road, then chased him on foot before taking him into custody. The arrest came roughly 12 hours after the emergency call that first brought deputies to the Hanska house.

Zimmerman’s capture did not immediately define the final shape of the prosecution. He was initially charged with second-degree murder. As investigators and prosecutors continued their work, a Brown County grand jury returned a much broader indictment later that month. The nine felony counts included two first-degree premeditated murder charges, two first-degree felony-murder charges, a first-degree murder charge involving a past pattern of domestic abuse, two second-degree intentional murder charges, first-degree burglary and second-degree assault with a dangerous weapon. The Minnesota Attorney General’s Office assisted the Brown County Attorney’s Office in the case.

The charging expansion reflected two separate strands in the evidence. One concerned the entry into Reinarts’ home and his killing there. The other concerned Zimmerman’s former relationship with Trescott and prior domestic-abuse cases. KEYC reported that court records listed misdemeanor domestic assault convictions involving Trescott in December 2023 and December 2024. The station also reported that Zimmerman faced pending felony stalking charges connected to a July 2025 incident in which Trescott was the alleged victim. Those records later became important because prosecutors pursued a first-degree murder count based on a past pattern of domestic abuse.

By August 2026, the case was headed toward resolution without a trial. Zimmerman pleaded guilty in Brown County District Court to two counts of first-degree murder. In the plea documents, he admitted entering Reinarts’ home without consent while armed with a dangerous weapon and intentionally killing Reinarts, conduct supporting first-degree murder during a burglary. He separately admitted intentionally killing Trescott, with whom he had been in a romantic relationship, under the first-degree murder provision involving a past pattern of domestic abuse. The state agreed to seek dismissal of the remaining counts, including the premeditated murder charges.

The plea guaranteed life sentences but left one question for the court: whether the terms would run together or one after the other. That issue became especially important to Trescott’s relatives. Her mother, Terri Smith, said publicly before sentencing that she was grateful the plea could keep her grandson from having to testify, but she wanted the judge to impose consecutive terms. The family feared a concurrent structure would make Zimmerman eligible for release consideration much sooner. Minnesota law requires life imprisonment for first-degree murder and sets a minimum term before supervised release can even be considered for certain life sentences; eligibility does not guarantee release.

On Oct. 5, 2026, the court imposed two consecutive life sentences. KEYC reported that Zimmerman received credit for 345 days already served. The decision gave the families the sentencing structure they had requested and ended the central criminal proceeding less than a year after the killings. Prosecutors’ dismissal of the premeditated counts meant Zimmerman was not sentenced to life without release under those charges. Instead, the two first-degree convictions preserved the possibility of release under Minnesota law after the applicable minimum terms, with the consecutive order making the punishment more severe than if both terms had run at the same time.

For the families, the sentencing closed a legal process that had repeatedly required them to confront the events inside the Hanska home. Smith said after the sentence that the decision lifted a heavy burden. Reinarts’ relatives expressed a similar sense that the court had reached the strongest result available under the plea, while making clear that a prison sentence did not erase the loss. The distinction between legal closure and personal grief was especially visible in their comments: the case had reached a final judgment, but the families were still raising children who had lost parents and adjusting to lives changed by the killings.

Reinarts was remembered locally as a volunteer firefighter and longtime Brown County resident. Friends and relatives described a man closely tied to his community and family. Trescott was remembered as a mother with an outgoing personality and a strong presence around those close to her. Violence Free Minnesota later identified her as one of the state’s confirmed intimate-partner homicide victims of 2025. Its memorial said she and Reinarts had recently moved in together. Both had two sons from previous relationships, according to local reporting, leaving the consequences of the case concentrated heavily on their children.

The child who called 911 occupied an unusual place in the case: he was both a surviving family member and a crucial early witness. The guilty plea meant prosecutors did not have to put him on the stand to prove the murders at trial. Smith cited that outcome when explaining why she felt some relief despite her reservations about the plea deal. His account nevertheless remained central to the public record because it described the first minutes known to investigators, identified Zimmerman at the scene and documented the danger inside the home without requiring the case to be narrated solely through forensic findings or later courtroom arguments.

A final financial issue remained after sentencing. KEYC reported that the court allowed 30 days to finalize restitution for the families, but no later public report reviewed for this story gave a final amount. The criminal convictions themselves are settled. Zimmerman stands convicted of two first-degree murders and is serving consecutive life terms in Minnesota. The long arc of the case — from a frightened child’s emergency call, through a multistate pursuit, indictment and plea — ended with the court’s decision that the punishment for the two deaths would not be served at the same time.

Author note: Last updated November 17, 2026.