Missouri woman pleads guilty after 4-year-old neighbor girl dies in freezing pond abuse

The Missouri prosecution has produced separate plea proceedings for two neighbors and both parents of the 4-year-old victim.

WARSAW, Mo. — Kourtney Aumen’s guilty plea to second-degree murder and first-degree assault has moved another branch of the Jessica Mast case toward sentencing, nearly six years after one child’s death led Missouri authorities to prosecute four adults whose cases have followed markedly different paths.

Aumen entered her plea Oct. 5 and is scheduled for sentencing Dec. 21. The development is significant not only because it eliminated her scheduled jury trial, but because the investigation into Jessica’s December 2020 death has never been a single criminal case. Authorities charged Aumen, neighbor Ethan Mast and Jessica’s parents, James and Mary Mast. Since then, guilty pleas, competency litigation, efforts to undo a plea and unresolved sentencing questions have produced four separate legal histories arising from the same night.

Ethan Mast was the first of the four to plead guilty to a homicide charge. In February 2022, he admitted to second-degree murder and assault in connection with Jessica’s death. Authorities said he and Aumen were neighbors of the Mast family and had participated in violence against Jessica and others in the household. Officials also stressed that Ethan Mast was not related to Jessica’s family despite the identical surname. His plea established his own criminal responsibility but did not determine Aumen’s guilt or resolve the cases against the child’s parents.

The parents’ prosecutions moved on different tracks. Mary Mast pleaded guilty to endangering the welfare of a child. James Mast pleaded guilty in November 2024 to second-degree murder and first-degree assault, according to court reporting, but then attempted to withdraw his plea. By 2026, a judge had denied one attempt to undo it, while James Mast continued pursuing additional motions. Those proceedings are important because a guilty plea can end the fact-finding phase of a criminal case without necessarily ending later disputes over whether that plea should remain in force.

Aumen’s case remained positioned for trial after the other pleas. Prosecutors had accused her of participating in severe abuse that culminated in Jessica’s death on Dec. 20, 2020. The case eventually moved to Webster County on a change of venue. As an October 2026 trial approached, the court dealt with questions about whether Aumen was mentally competent to participate in her defense. A judge found her competent in September, clearing one of the final major barriers to trial even though her attorneys said they continued having substantial difficulty communicating with her.

Then came a rapid series of procedural changes. Aumen sought to waive a jury trial, but Judge M. Brandon Baker declined to accept the waiver because of the seriousness of the case. A jury trial remained set for Oct. 26 and was expected to run for several days. On Oct. 5, however, the court docket reflected a change-of-plea hearing. Aumen pleaded guilty to second-degree murder and first-degree assault, replacing the imminent trial with a sentencing proceeding scheduled for December.

All four cases stem from what deputies discovered at the Mast home in rural Benton County shortly before Christmas 2020. Law enforcement responded to what was initially described as a possible domestic disturbance and found Jessica dead inside. Authorities said the 4-year-old had been badly abused. Investigators described beatings and said she had been repeatedly put into a cold pond. Jessica’s mother and a 2-year-old boy also suffered significant injuries, while an infant child was reported unharmed.

The statements gathered by investigators added another disturbing dimension to the case. James Mast told authorities that Aumen and Ethan Mast had harmed members of the family and had threatened the parents if they intervened. Investigators said claims about a “demon” were used in connection with the violence. Benton County Sheriff Eric Knox referred publicly to the episode as having a religious character, though the criminal cases were based on the alleged acts of violence, abuse and failures to protect rather than on religious beliefs themselves.

That distinction also helps explain why prosecutors pursued several adults instead of treating Jessica’s death solely as an allegation against the people accused of directly striking or immersing her. Investigators examined what happened to the other child and Jessica’s mother, what the parents knew or did, what threats were allegedly made and how long the abuse had continued. The resulting charges differed by defendant and changed over time as plea negotiations and court rulings narrowed the issues each prosecution would have to resolve.

The separate procedural histories also caution against treating any one plea as a blanket account of the entire case. Ethan Mast’s 2022 admission does not automatically establish every allegation once made against Aumen. Mary Mast’s child-endangerment plea is legally distinct from a murder conviction. James Mast’s effort to withdraw his own plea creates a different set of questions from those now facing Aumen. And Aumen’s October plea means her case no longer depends on whether prosecutors could have persuaded an October jury to convict her at trial.

Instead, the court must now determine Aumen’s punishment on the offenses to which she admitted guilt. Reports confirming the plea establish second-degree murder and first-degree assault as the convictions headed toward sentencing. They do not establish what punishment the judge will impose. Sentencing considerations, any recommendations made by the parties and the judge’s ultimate decision remain matters for the upcoming hearing rather than facts that can be assumed in advance.

The case has drawn public attention since the first arrests. Benton County is a largely rural community, and Jessica’s death prompted vigils and support efforts for emergency workers affected by the scene. One community project collected stuffed animals for first responders to provide to children during future emergency calls. Sheriff Knox spoke publicly about the emotional toll on deputies and medical personnel. Those reactions illustrate the impact of the case but have remained separate from the evidentiary and procedural standards governing the four prosecutions.

The long delay before Aumen’s plea also reflects issues particular to her case. Competency proceedings can halt or complicate a prosecution because a defendant must be able to understand the proceedings and assist counsel to the degree required by law. Local reporting showed that Aumen had been the subject of more than one competency determination. Defense lawyers argued at one point that she should be treated in a state mental health facility. The September 2026 finding that she was competent allowed the prosecution to resume its course toward trial.

Her attempt to waive a jury then presented a different legal question. A defendant may seek a judge-only proceeding, but the court did not accept Aumen’s request. Baker’s ruling left a jury trial as the next expected stage until the plea intervened. That chronology makes the Oct. 5 hearing more than a routine filing: in a matter of days, Aumen moved from competency litigation and a dispute over trial format to an admission that removed the central question of guilt from a jury’s consideration.

As of Nov. 17, Aumen’s case is therefore the branch of the four-defendant prosecution with a clearly scheduled near-term milestone. Her sentencing is set for Dec. 21. Proceedings involving the other defendants have their own records and unresolved issues, and those outcomes should not be conflated with hers. What began with one emergency response in December 2020 has become a collection of separate criminal cases, each requiring its own final judgment.

Author note: Last updated November 17, 2026.