Illinois man accused girlfriend of cheating before he stabbed her in the neck

Anthony Jimenez remained jailed for more than two years before admitting first-degree murder in the 2024 death of Jessica Reyes.

VILLA PARK, Ill. — Anthony Jimenez’s murder case began with an arrest inside his apartment in July 2024, moved through more than two years of pretrial detention and ended without a jury trial. After pleading guilty to first-degree murder in the death of Jessica Reyes, the 28-year-old Villa Park man has been sentenced to 55 years in prison.

The legal path matters because the case changed substantially between Jimenez’s first court appearance and his sentencing. When he was charged after Reyes’ death, the state’s description of the killing consisted of allegations that had not yet been tested at trial. A judge ordered Jimenez detained while the case was pending. On May 8, 2026, however, Jimenez voluntarily entered a guilty plea to one count of first-degree murder. DuPage County Judge Mia McPherson then imposed the 55-year sentence Oct. 15. Prosecutors said he must serve the entire term before becoming eligible for parole.

Jimenez had been jailed since July 19, 2024, two days after Reyes was killed. During his initial court proceedings, Judge Joshua Dieden granted prosecutors’ request for pretrial detention. Reporting on the court order at the time said Dieden concluded that Jimenez had demonstrated conduct that posed a danger and that release conditions would not adequately address that risk. The detention ruling was not a finding of guilt. It governed where Jimenez would remain while prosecutors pursued the first-degree murder charges against him.

The case itself arose from a confrontation beginning around 8 a.m. July 17, 2024, at Jimenez’s apartment in the 1600 block of South Michigan Avenue. Prosecutors said Jimenez and Reyes, 24, were arguing when he blocked the door and would not let her leave. Reyes found another route out: She climbed down from the third-floor balcony to the parking lot. Jimenez went outside and spoke with her. Authorities said the argument settled enough that they returned to the apartment, where Reyes intended to collect belongings.

Early court records offered additional detail about that period. According to contemporaneous reporting based on prosecutors’ detention filings, Jimenez had accused Reyes of infidelity. Reyes went to her car after leaving the apartment, and the two spoke again outside. Those filings said she returned to retrieve property, including her phone, and later told Jimenez that she believed they should take a break from their relationship. Because those descriptions appeared in filings made at the start of the prosecution, they were initially allegations rather than established findings. Jimenez’s later guilty plea established his responsibility for the murder itself.

Prosecutors said the argument restarted while Reyes gathered her things. Jimenez pulled a knife from his pocket and stabbed her in the side of the head, according to the state’s attorney’s office. Reyes fought back as Jimenez continued the attack. Authorities described wounds to her neck, face, arms, chest and hands. The state’s sentencing account said the attack stopped when Jimenez’s mother entered the room. The description was presented in restrained terms by prosecutors but showed that the fatal violence occurred only after Reyes had already escaped once and returned for her property.

The police response followed shortly before 11 a.m. Jimenez told a 911 dispatcher that he had stabbed his girlfriend in the neck, prosecutors said. Officers arriving at the residence found him at the door with apparent blood on his hands and chest and took him into custody. They located Reyes bleeding on the floor of a back bedroom and began giving aid. Paramedics transported her to a hospital, where she was pronounced dead at about 11:26 a.m. Jimenez was arrested at the scene rather than after a separate search.

The original prosecution included two first-degree murder counts. The distinction between that charging document and the final disposition is significant: Jimenez ultimately pleaded guilty to one count. A guilty plea generally removes the need for the state to prove its case to a jury because the defendant admits criminal responsibility as part of the court proceeding. The state’s attorney’s office described Jimenez’s plea as voluntary. Its sentencing announcement did not identify a remaining homicide charge to be tried separately after the 55-year term was imposed.

The sentence also carries a provision prosecutors specifically emphasized. Jimenez is required to serve 100% of the 55 years before he can be eligible for parole. The Daily Herald reported the sentence was handed down by McPherson on Oct. 15, with the state’s attorney announcing it publicly the following day. Jimenez was born in February 1998, making him 28 at sentencing. He had been 26 when Reyes was killed. The prison term therefore reaches far beyond the time he had already spent in the county jail while the case was unresolved.

Reyes’ age remained unchanged throughout a court process that lasted more than two years: She was 24 when she died. Her relatives’ public description of her provided a counterweight to a legal record dominated by charging language, hearings and sentencing dates. A family fundraising page described Reyes as selfless, resilient and funny. The family said she served in the military for six years and had become a veteran. They wrote that she was someone who made herself available when other people needed help.

The sentencing also came during Domestic Violence Awareness Month. DuPage County State’s Attorney Robert Berlin used the occasion to say no one should have to live in fear of a spouse, significant other or family member. He called the case a reminder of the potentially deadly consequences of domestic violence and expressed condolences to Reyes’ relatives and friends. Berlin also credited the assistant state’s attorneys who handled the prosecution that produced Jimenez’s guilty plea and sentence.

The completed case record is notable for the continuity between the first allegations and the facts prosecutors repeated after the guilty plea. From the beginning, authorities said Reyes had tried to leave, was prevented from using the door, escaped by another route and returned to gather belongings after the confrontation appeared to calm. That sequence remained part of the state’s description when Jimenez was sentenced in 2026. It also distinguishes the killing from a confrontation in which the victim had simply remained inside throughout an uninterrupted dispute.

With McPherson’s sentence in place, the principal legal proceeding over Reyes’ death has reached its conclusion. Jimenez is no longer a pretrial detainee facing an unresolved murder allegation; he is a convicted defendant sentenced to the Illinois Department of Corrections after admitting first-degree murder. Prosecutors said no parole eligibility will arise until the full 55-year term has been served. The sentencing closes the trial-level case while leaving Reyes’ family with the permanent loss described in their public tribute to her.

Author note: Last updated Nov. 21, 2026.