Jealous ex-cop ambushes romantic rival inside motorcycle shop and burns him alive

Prosecutors said Otto Lenke’s preparations for killing Richard Benson reflected planning by a man with decades of law-enforcement and fire-rescue experience.

FORT PIERCE, Fla. — Long before Otto Lenke became a defendant in a death-penalty case, he spent years working in two professions built around emergencies and investigations: policing and fire rescue. Prosecutors later argued that his experience helped explain the precautions taken before Richard Benson was killed.

Lenke, 67, has now been sentenced to death for Benson’s Feb. 17, 2021, murder at Fast Frank’s Cycle Concepts in Fort Pierce. Circuit Judge Michael Linn imposed the punishment Oct. 14 after a jury found Lenke guilty of first-degree murder with a firearm and first-degree arson and recommended death by an 11-1 vote. The judge concluded that the homicide was extensively planned and that the aggravating circumstances justified capital punishment. The sentence capped the trial-court stage of a prosecution in which Lenke’s former public-service career became part of the broader story of how the state said he prepared for the attack and tried to conceal his identity.

Public records show Lenke joined the Melbourne Police Department in December 1980 and remained there until December 1995, when he medically retired. He later worked for Indian River County Fire Rescue, serving for roughly 16 years before leaving in May 2016. When he was arrested in 2021, county officials said his fire-rescue personnel file did not show major disciplinary problems. Nothing in that employment history itself established guilt. But once prosecutors laid out the preparations surrounding Benson’s death, they argued that Lenke’s familiarity with police work was relevant to understanding why he took steps that appeared designed to reduce obvious evidence linking him to the scene.

Those preparations began before he reached Fort Pierce, according to the sentencing order. Lenke removed the license tag from a Pontiac Bonneville registered to him and drove about 40 minutes toward Benson’s motorcycle shop. He did not park directly in front of the business. Instead, records said he stopped at the far end of the commercial strip and waited about 20 minutes. Before entering, he wore gloves and a motorcycle helmet fitted with a tinted face shield. He carried a handgun as well as a bag containing two lighters and two containers of denatured alcohol. Linn later treated those steps as evidence that the killing was calculated rather than the result of a sudden dispute.

Assistant State Attorney Brandon White made the same point after sentencing. He said Lenke’s more than 20 years of law-enforcement experience gave him knowledge that could be applied to planning an attack and trying to avoid detection. Prosecutors emphasized the missing license plate, covered face and decision to leave a cellphone away from the scene. The argument did not depend on the idea that every precaution succeeded. In fact, several of those same choices became evidence against Lenke once investigators were able to identify the vehicle, compare surveillance recordings and reconstruct his movements. The state’s position was that the efforts themselves demonstrated preparation, even though they ultimately failed to conceal who committed the crime.

Inside Fast Frank’s, cameras recorded the attack that would later be shown to jurors. Benson, 57, had arrived to open the motorcycle business and was working near the front. According to the sentencing order, Lenke entered through a rear door, approached Benson and shot him. Benson repeatedly tried to reach the front entrance, but the attacker stopped him from escaping. Lenke fired three times in all and then used the denatured alcohol to start a fire before leaving. Emergency personnel responded to the structure fire and found Benson inside the building. He was pronounced dead at 9:21 a.m. Investigators recovered three spent cartridge casings and two empty containers near the front of the shop.

The state’s theory of motive involved a relationship that had ended before the homicide. Benson was dating a woman who had been a longtime friend of Lenke and had previously been romantically involved with him. Court records said the woman and Lenke were no longer a couple by 2021. Around Jan. 19 of that year, Lenke brought her a boat he had built. During the visit, Benson called. Lenke saw Benson’s name on the phone and became emotional, according to the sentencing order. The record said he questioned why the woman did not love him and whether she was seeing someone. Prosecutors presented that episode as part of the evidence that jealousy preceded the attack.

Lenke’s attempt to hide his appearance also did not prevent someone who knew him from recognizing the man on the surveillance recording. Benson’s girlfriend told investigators she identified Lenke from his particular walk and the style of his black motorcycle helmet. Detectives then worked outward from that identification. Other video showed the Bonneville traveling toward the shop and parking nearby without a visible license plate. Because the car was registered to Lenke, investigators had a second connection between him and the area. Fort Pierce detectives said shortly after the arrest that information from the public and the business’s surveillance system helped them identify a suspect within about two days.

Investigators also examined Lenke’s cellphone and later movements. Court records said the phone itself was at his residence during the killing. Afterward, investigators tracked activity involving Lenke to locations that included a hobby shop, a canal and a shoreline area along the Indian River Lagoon near Sebastian. Authorities recovered part of a Glock firearm from the lagoon area that was consistent with the weapon used to kill Benson. The available sentencing account said records did not identify who originally bought the firearm secondhand. Prosecutors nevertheless presented the recovery alongside the vehicle evidence, video and witness recognition as part of a case assembled from numerous pieces rather than one decisive item.

When Lenke was arrested in February 2021, the case was still largely hidden from public view. Prosecutors sought to keep probable-cause affidavits confidential while investigators continued working, saying early disclosure might interfere with efforts to locate or prosecute other possible participants. Lenke was jailed without bond. As the investigation became public and the prosecution moved forward, the case ultimately focused on Lenke alone. It then remained pending for years before reaching a St. Lucie County jury in May 2026. He did not testify in his own defense during the guilt phase, according to local reporting.

Jurors convicted Lenke on May 8. The case then shifted into a separate capital-sentencing proceeding in which the state had to establish aggravating circumstances and the defense could present mitigating evidence. The defense sought life without parole. Jurors found that the murder was especially heinous, atrocious or cruel; that it was cold, calculated and premeditated; and that it was committed during another felony, the arson. On May 21, after several days of penalty-phase testimony, 11 of the 12 jurors recommended death. Florida requires at least an 8-4 jury recommendation before a judge may impose that punishment.

Linn later conducted the independent weighing required before sentencing. His order described the evidence of preparation and the circumstances captured inside the shop. He concluded that death was a just sentence for the murder. Lenke also received punishment for the arson conviction. For prosecutors, the sentence resolved the trial-stage question that had remained open since the jury’s recommendation: whether the judge would accept death or impose life without parole instead. Linn chose death.

The decision does not end judicial review. Florida death sentences automatically go before the Florida Supreme Court, where the conviction and punishment are examined on appeal. No execution date has been set. Lenke’s long career in public safety, once cited simply as background when he was arrested, is now part of a much different public record: that of a former police officer and firefighter convicted of a planned murder and awaiting review of a capital sentence.

Author note: Last updated Nov. 21, 2026.