Off duty cop strangled to death by cousin during family gathering at Pennsylvania cabin police say

Witness accounts, emergency-call statements and an autopsy later formed the basis for murder and strangulation charges against a 25-year-old man.

CUMMINGS TOWNSHIP, Pa. — At 2:38 a.m. on July 11, Lycoming County emergency dispatchers received a call from a rural cabin reporting that off-duty police Officer Michael McGeehan was not breathing, beginning an investigation that authorities say ultimately showed he had lost consciousness while being restrained with pressure against his neck.

Police and emergency medical personnel reached the Dam Run Road cabin about 19 minutes after the call. They found the 44-year-old Middlesex Township officer unresponsive on the front porch after a family gathering. McGeehan could not be revived and was pronounced dead. What first appeared publicly as an unexpected death would, over the next several months, become a homicide investigation built around what relatives said they had seen during a roughly 10-minute confrontation and what a later autopsy found.

Statements attributed to the 911 caller gave investigators an early indication that McGeehan had not simply suffered an unexplained medical emergency. Reporting based on the criminal complaint said the caller told dispatchers that people at the cabin had been trying to make McGeehan sleep because he was intoxicated and referred to him having been choked. Those statements were made before investigators had the autopsy findings that would later identify compression of McGeehan’s neck as the cause of death.

Detectives then reconstructed the gathering through interviews. Witnesses said McGeehan had consumed a substantial amount of alcohol and had become difficult to manage. People at the cabin were trying to get him to go to bed, according to the affidavit of probable cause. His son told investigators that McGeehan discussed going for a swim or riding a four-wheeler. Several people tried to restrain him, turning what had been an effort to keep him from leaving into an extended struggle on the porch.

The son’s account placed Paden Edward Frey, then 25, in the central role alleged by police. According to the affidavit, the son said Frey held McGeehan down and placed a forearm across the middle of his neck. Another man was described as restraining McGeehan’s arms. The son told investigators his father continued fighting and had difficulty breathing for about 10 minutes or longer while the pressure was being applied. Those are allegations contained in the charging record, not findings by a judge or jury.

McGeehan’s wife described another part of the confrontation. She told investigators that Frey yelled for her to move away as he lay on McGeehan, according to the affidavit. She said Frey warned McGeehan that he would “put him to sleep” if he did not stop. Investigators allege McGeehan eventually became unconscious. The documents say Frey then left him on the porch. Police later emphasized that witnesses said Frey did not provide aid before going inside.

Frey’s own initial account became another component of the probable-cause case. Investigators said Frey acknowledged that he and another person had been fighting with McGeehan in an effort to get him to sleep. He told police that they eventually got McGeehan to lie on the porch and that McGeehan fell asleep there. What investigators said was missing from that account was Frey’s alleged application of pressure to McGeehan’s neck until he lost consciousness. Police cited that omission after comparing Frey’s statement with witness interviews and the medical evidence.

The autopsy was performed July 13. Investigators said it determined that McGeehan died from manual strangulation caused by forearm compression of the neck. The Lycoming County Coroner’s Office classified the death as a homicide. Reports describing the examination also cited other injuries and medical factors, including blunt-force head injuries, alcohol-related findings, cardiovascular disease, obesity and a history of sleep apnea. The official homicide investigation nevertheless identified neck compression as the cause that connected the medical findings to the restraint described by witnesses.

For nearly three months, no arrest was announced. Lycoming Regional Police and the coroner’s office continued their joint investigation while Middlesex Township police and McGeehan’s family publicly mourned him. Then, on Oct. 7, regional police went to Frey’s home in Cogan Station with the Lycoming County Sheriff’s Office. Authorities said he was taken into custody without incident. The arrest converted the investigative findings into a criminal case that now includes allegations ranging from reckless endangerment to murder.

Frey faces third-degree murder, strangulation, involuntary manslaughter and recklessly endangering another person. He was arraigned before Magisterial District Judge Denise Dieter and committed to Lycoming County Prison without bail. Later reporting based on court records said the court concluded that no bail condition would sufficiently protect the community. Frey is presumed innocent unless proven guilty. The filing of multiple charges does not mean prosecutors have established any of them beyond a reasonable doubt.

The allegations require prosecutors to address different levels of criminal responsibility. Pennsylvania law places third-degree murder below intentional first-degree murder and felony-related second-degree murder, but it still requires proof of murder rather than simple negligence. State courts have described third-degree murder as requiring legal malice, which may be shown through conduct reflecting a conscious disregard for an unjustified and extremely high risk of death or serious bodily injury. The involuntary manslaughter charge gives prosecutors a separate theory based on a lower level of culpability if supported by the evidence and applicable law.

The strangulation count is tied specifically to the breathing restriction described by witnesses and to the autopsy. Pennsylvania’s statute makes it an offense to knowingly or intentionally impede another person’s breathing or blood circulation by pressure to the throat or neck or by blocking the nose and mouth. The Commonwealth has not yet presented its full evidence in court, and Frey’s lawyer will be able to dispute witness recollections, medical conclusions, intent and other elements relevant to the charges.

The investigation unfolded against a markedly different public account of McGeehan’s death in July. Middlesex Township police initially announced what they called an unexpected passing and focused on his service. The department said McGeehan had spent 12 years on its force and had become a dependable leader to fellow officers. Regional police later said he had been involved in law enforcement since 2001. His obituary described him as a Northern High School graduate who later completed HACC’s Municipal Police Academy and served as president of his academy class.

McGeehan was also remembered for a life centered on his family. He was married and had five sons. His obituary and a memorial fundraiser described him as involved in his children’s activities, including coaching track and football. After criminal charges were announced, Middlesex Township Police Chief Andrew Bassler said he had initially been surprised by the homicide determination but believed the charges made sense in light of what investigators had learned. The department later promoted McGeehan posthumously to corporal.

The next scheduled opportunity for prosecutors to present the case publicly is a preliminary hearing. It was first set for Oct. 21 but was later continued to Dec. 23, according to subsequently reported court docket information. Frey remains jailed while the case is pending. As of Nov. 18, authorities had not announced a trial date, and Lycoming Regional Police continued to list the underlying homicide investigation as active.

Author note: Last updated November 18, 2026.