Pregnant Florida woman intentionally crashed car after fight exploded on highway over boyfriend’s texts

What began as a serious-injury investigation changed repeatedly as Daniel Waterman awakened, spoke to police, died and became the victim in a homicide prosecution.

BUNNELL, Fla. — The criminal case against Leigha Mumby did not begin as a homicide prosecution. It became one over eight months marked by a catastrophic crash, Daniel Waterman’s prolonged hospitalization, a rare interview after he emerged from a coma and, eventually, his death.

That progression ended in a Flagler County courtroom on Oct. 14, 2026, when a jury convicted Mumby, 25, of vehicular homicide and reckless driving causing serious bodily injury. Jurors deliberated about 71 minutes after a two-day trial. Mumby was taken into custody after Circuit Judge Dawn Nichols revoked her bond, and she is scheduled to return for sentencing Dec. 2. She faces up to 20 years in prison. The verdict closed the trial phase of a case whose legal character had changed several times as Waterman’s condition and the available evidence evolved.

The sequence began on Super Bowl Sunday, Feb. 9, 2025. Mumby and Waterman had been at a gathering in the Palm Coast area before leaving in Mumby’s 2019 Honda Passport. Earlier that day, Mumby had learned that she was pregnant. Prosecutors later said she also became upset over messages Waterman had received from another woman. The couple argued while traveling on Interstate 95. Near mile marker 291, with Mumby driving north, the Honda left the roadway at high speed and struck trees. Both occupants survived the initial collision, but their medical paths soon diverged sharply.

Waterman suffered a broken neck and other severe injuries and was left paralyzed from the neck down, according to prosecutors and reporting from the trial. For weeks, he could not provide investigators with his own account of the crash. Mumby was also injured. She later told investigators that she did not remember what caused the SUV to leave the road, only the aftermath. That left police initially reconstructing the event through the vehicle, the crash scene and statements from people who had interacted with the couple before the wreck.

Then, on May 15, 2025, Waterman was able to communicate with a Florida Highway Patrol investigator after emerging from a coma. Reports said he could not speak normally and used a letter board to help answer questions. He told investigators that he and Mumby had been arguing and accused her of driving recklessly. According to the criminal complaint, Waterman said Mumby slowed the vehicle to about 50 mph, then accelerated after he tried to get out. He said he remembered her telling him, “I don’t care what happens, you’ll get what you deserve,” before the Honda went off the road. His statement gave investigators an eyewitness account from the only passenger in the SUV.

The investigation soon produced criminal charges. Mumby was arrested in July 2025 on allegations that included aggravated battery with a deadly weapon and reckless driving causing serious bodily injury. At that stage, Waterman was still alive, and the case focused on the injuries he suffered and the allegation that the collision had been intentional. Mumby was released on bond while prosecutors continued preparing the case. The formal prosecution would change again before it reached trial.

Waterman died Oct. 8, 2025, after developing pneumonia. He was 22. Prosecutors then amended the case to add vehicular homicide, converting the consequences of the February crash into the central element of a death prosecution. Mumby surrendered on the added charge later that month and was released on a higher bond. Three days after Waterman’s death, Mumby gave birth to the child she had learned she was carrying on the morning of the crash, according to local reporting. The child became the subject of a separate family dispute involving Waterman’s relatives, but that proceeding was not part of the criminal jury’s task.

As the criminal trial approached, another major change occurred. Waterman’s post-coma account had helped propel the case forward, but it would not be heard by jurors. Mumby’s defense challenged the statements as inadmissible hearsay and raised her right to confront evidence used against her. At a Sept. 30 hearing, prosecutor Melissa Clark acknowledged that she could not establish a legal basis to present Waterman’s account. Nichols excluded it. Prosecutors then dropped the aggravated-battery charge, leaving vehicular homicide and reckless driving causing serious bodily injury for trial.

The ruling meant the trial could not simply replay the version of events contained in the criminal complaint. Instead, prosecutors built the case around what the Honda recorded and what witnesses could describe independently. Electronic evidence placed the SUV at about 93 to 95 mph in the seconds before the crash. Trial testimony described a sharp steering movement while the vehicle was traveling about 94 mph. The state argued that Mumby’s speed and driving behavior during the argument constituted reckless conduct likely to cause death or great bodily harm, whether or not jurors believed she had intended to crash.

The defense approached the evidence from the opposite direction. Attorney Reid Hart argued that an unexpected event caused Mumby to lose control and that subsequent steering movement showed an effort to avoid a collision. He emphasized that she had every reason to preserve her own safety because she was inside the Honda and had learned that day she was pregnant. The defense’s theory attacked the idea of deliberateness, but intention was no longer the central legal question after prosecutors dropped the aggravated-battery count. Jurors instead had to decide whether the state proved criminal recklessness and causation.

Clark told jurors in closing arguments that Mumby had been driving at extreme speed and aggressively. The state connected that conduct to evidence that the couple was in conflict before the crash. According to prosecutors, Mumby was angry over Waterman’s communications with another woman, and testimony showed she had been upset before getting behind the wheel. Prosecutors argued that emotional context helped explain the driving but did not ask jurors to depend on Waterman’s excluded statement. The physical evidence, they contended, established the level of recklessness required for conviction.

The jury agreed. It found Mumby guilty on both remaining counts after little more than an hour of deliberation. The verdict changed her status immediately: Nichols revoked the bond that had allowed Mumby to remain free before and during trial, and she was taken to the Flagler County jail. State Attorney R.J. Larizza later praised the prosecution of what he described as a technically complicated case, and his office credited the Florida Highway Patrol investigation and Clark’s presentation at trial.

The criminal verdict did not settle every consequence flowing from Waterman’s death. His mother, Heather Waterman, filed family-court petitions concerning the daughter born after his death, including efforts related to visitation and Mumby’s parental rights, according to FlaglerLive. The outlet reported in October that a proceeding had been set for Nov. 4, but the sources reviewed for this article did not establish a final outcome of that matter as of Nov. 20. That dispute remains legally separate from the jury’s determination that Mumby was criminally responsible for Waterman’s death.

The next confirmed milestone is sentencing. Nichols is scheduled to sentence Mumby on Dec. 2, when the court will decide how much of the potential 20-year maximum she will serve. The hearing will mark another change in a case repeatedly reshaped by events outside the courtroom: first Waterman’s survival, then his ability to communicate, then his death, then the exclusion of his statement and finally a conviction secured without it.

Author note: Last updated Nov. 20, 2026.