Prosecutors used surveillance footage, phone data and McRae’s actions around an SUV to connect a youth-game dispute to deadly gunfire.
BALTIMORE, Md. — A phone call, a gray sedan, a vehicle followed through Baltimore and a brief statement captured before gunfire became the evidence trail prosecutors used to convict Cassandra McRae in the killing of grandmother Anntoinette Jennings, a case that has now ended in a 140-year prison term.
McRae, 38, was sentenced after jurors found her guilty of second-degree murder, four counts of conspiracy to commit murder, four counts of attempted second-degree murder, five counts of using a firearm in a felony or crime of violence and reckless endangerment. The court imposed 150 years and suspended 10, leaving 140 years to serve, with the first 25 years without parole eligibility. The punishment closed a prosecution in which the state’s case depended less on an allegation that McRae fired a gun than on evidence prosecutors said showed how she helped identify, pursue and confront the occupants of Jennings’ Honda CR-V before another person opened fire.
The evidentiary sequence began at a children’s basketball game on Jan. 22, 2025. Authorities said McRae was involved in an altercation connected to Jennings’ family during or after the game. Investigators later reviewed surveillance video that showed McRae leaving while making a phone call. She then entered a gray sedan, according to the state. The sedan followed the SUV driven by Jennings as the family departed. Prosecutors relied on that footage to establish continuity between the dispute at the game and the later encounter several miles into the evening, rather than treating the shooting as an unrelated confrontation.
Additional cameras captured activity around the 5400 block of York Road, according to a charging document prepared during the homicide investigation. McRae got out of the sedan and approached the rear passenger side of Jennings’ vehicle. At about the same time, two men approached the driver’s side. The document said McRae touched the rear quarter panel and twice called attention to the vehicle, saying, “There they go right there.” Seconds later, a man fired shots into the SUV. The three people approaching the vehicle then fled, investigators said.
Inside the Honda were Jennings and four other people. Jennings, 52, was fatally wounded and pronounced dead at the scene. Two other occupants were shot, including an 11-year-old child. A 6-year-old child and another passenger were not physically struck. Jennings was later identified in Baltimore reporting as a pre-K paraeducator at Waverly Elementary/Middle School and the grandmother of the wounded child. The number of people inside the SUV became legally important because the prosecution pursued not only a homicide charge but attempted-murder and firearm counts tied to the danger faced by the surviving occupants.
Police did not rely on the video alone. The charging application said investigators obtained witness statements as well as digital and cellular data while reviewing footage of the suspects and vehicles both before and after the shooting. Authorities said that information helped identify Tavon Singleton as one of the men believed to have been present and showed what investigators described as collaboration between Singleton and McRae before the attack. The same investigative record placed their cellular devices in the area and tracked movement away after the gunfire, according to the charging document.
The evidence was strong enough for prosecutors to obtain sweeping indictments in March 2025. McRae and Singleton were charged with first-degree murder, conspiracy-related murder allegations, four counts of conspiracy to commit murder, attempted first- and second-degree murder counts, first-degree assault charges and firearms offenses. At that point, the Baltimore City State’s Attorney’s Office said both defendants faced the possibility of life without parole plus additional prison time if convicted on all charges. The charging decision reflected prosecutors’ broadest theory of the case; what jurors ultimately accepted was narrower.
At trial, the surveillance sequence was again central. Prosecutors argued that McRae helped orchestrate the attack by making the call, joining the pursuit and identifying Jennings’ vehicle just before the shooting. McRae testified in her own defense and denied the state’s interpretation of her actions. The jury’s verdict split sharply between the two defendants. Singleton was acquitted of all charges. McRae was convicted of second-degree murder and numerous related offenses, though she was not convicted on the original first-degree murder theory. That outcome left the same body of evidence producing different judgments for two people prosecutors had initially accused together.
The distinction became especially important at sentencing because McRae continued to insist that the verdict was wrong. She told the court she was innocent and had been wrongfully convicted. Defense attorney Michael Tomko asked Baltimore Circuit Judge Dana Middleton for a sentence of no more than 25 years, noting that McRae had no prior criminal record and arguing against a punishment that would amount to imprisonment for the rest of her natural life. He also pointed to the acquittal of Singleton as part of the broader context surrounding the case.
Prosecutors focused instead on the sequence the jury had accepted. Assistant State’s Attorney Megan Gallo sought a maximum term totaling 295 years, arguing that McRae’s conduct set the shooting in motion. The state’s position was that criminal responsibility did not turn solely on whose hand held the gun. McRae’s movements and statements before the shooting, prosecutors argued, showed that she was an active participant in bringing the armed men to the victims and directing their attention to Jennings’ SUV. Middleton similarly characterized McRae as the catalyst for the deadly encounter.
The judge also addressed McRae’s claim that she had been wrongly convicted. Courtroom reporting said Middleton noted that the jury heard McRae testify and had the opportunity to evaluate her account against the state’s evidence. The jurors did not accept it. Middleton then imposed the lengthy aggregate sentence. Reports describing that punishment have used both 150 years and 140 years, but the figures are not competing judgments: 150 years were imposed, 10 were suspended and 140 remain to be served. The first quarter-century carries no possibility of parole.
For investigators, the case demonstrates how a network of cameras and electronic records can reconstruct a sequence that unfolds across more than one location. The basketball gym did not contain the fatal act, and York Road did not by itself explain how the people involved arrived there. Prosecutors connected the two through McRae’s phone call, the sedan, the pursuit, the positioning around the SUV and the seconds immediately preceding the shots. Digital and cellular records supplied another layer, while witness accounts provided additional evidence described in the original charging documents.
For the victims, however, that technical reconstruction led back to a much simpler set of consequences. Jennings was killed. Two passengers were wounded. Two others, including a 6-year-old child, were inside the vehicle as the shooting occurred. State’s Attorney Ivan J. Bates said after sentencing that the punishment reflected the loss of a grandmother and the danger imposed on children and other innocent occupants. His office described the violence as having consequences that would continue for Jennings’ relatives and the community long after the criminal case.
The prosecution is now in a different posture than when investigators were assembling footage and phone records in early 2025. Singleton has been acquitted, and McRae stands convicted and sentenced to 140 years to serve. The trial record, rather than the initial allegations, now defines McRae’s legal responsibility: second-degree murder and the related conspiracy, attempted-murder, firearm and reckless-endangerment convictions. Any effort to overturn those findings would have to proceed through post-trial motions or appellate review, where the evidence and legal rulings made during the case could be challenged.
Author note: Last updated November 20, 2026.