Recordings from a downstairs resident became part of a wider evidence trail that ended with third-degree murder convictions for the boy’s mother and her boyfriend.
PHILADELPHIA, Penn. — Days before 4-year-old Damari Carter disappeared from view inside a West Philadelphia apartment, a downstairs neighbor told the city’s child welfare agency that she believed a young child upstairs was being beaten, according to testimony that later became part of the murder case against Damari’s mother and her boyfriend.
The warning did not prevent the child’s death. Nearly three years later, however, the neighbor’s recordings and hallway surveillance helped prosecutors reconstruct Damari’s final days and build the case that resulted in third-degree murder convictions against Dominique Bailey and Kevin Spencer. Jurors also convicted both defendants of conspiracy to commit murder, endangering the welfare of a child, criminal use of a communication facility, false reports to law enforcement, tampering with evidence and abuse of a corpse. Bailey and Spencer are scheduled to be sentenced Dec. 4.
The neighbor, Tiajuana Jennings, lived below Spencer’s apartment on the 3800 block of Reno Street. At a 2024 preliminary hearing, she described increasingly disturbing sounds after Bailey and Damari moved into the apartment. Jennings said she heard a child crying along with yelling and sounds she interpreted as physical violence. She began making recordings from outside the unit. On Dec. 7, 2023, she contacted Philadelphia’s Department of Human Services to report what she believed was happening to the child.
Jennings said a worker took her information and later advised her to contact police. She told the court she feared retaliation and did not make that call. Prosecutors said at the preliminary hearing that it appeared DHS employees did not intervene before Damari died. Jessica Shapiro, then an official with the city’s Office of Children and Families, said Damari was not in DHS custody and was not receiving services at the time. She also said state confidentiality law prevented the city from publicly discussing further details of the agency’s involvement.
The DHS contact became one part of a broader timeline rather than the sole basis of the criminal case. Prosecutors said a hallway surveillance system recorded Damari entering Spencer’s apartment on Dec. 5. It was the last time he appeared on the camera. Audio from Dec. 5 through Dec. 7 captured the boy crying and sounds prosecutors characterized as beatings. On Dec. 8, the camera showed Spencer leaving with a large trash bag. On Dec. 9, he left carrying a black Puma duffel bag over his shoulder, according to the District Attorney’s Office.
Investigators later obtained another source of evidence from Spencer’s cellphone. Forensic examination recovered deleted videos from Dec. 7 showing Damari with visible injuries to his head and face, prosecutors said. One video presented during earlier court proceedings showed Spencer confronting the boy while Damari sat in front of breakfast. Prosecutors used the footage to show the child’s physical condition shortly before he disappeared. At trial, they argued that the videos, neighbor recordings and hallway camera formed a continuous picture of escalating mistreatment inside the apartment.
Damari’s arrival at the Reno Street home followed a period in which Bailey had been living with her father in West Philadelphia after moving from Texas. Prosecutors said Damari was developmentally delayed and nonverbal. Frank Bailey, the boy’s grandfather, had helped care for him. After he confronted his daughter about leaving Damari alone, prosecutors said, she left the household and moved with the boy into Spencer’s apartment. The family’s contact with Damari then became increasingly limited. Relatives last heard from him around his fourth birthday in late November.
After Damari disappeared, Bailey offered relatives an explanation that investigators would later determine had no supporting record. She said the boy had been struck and killed by a vehicle. Family members grew suspicious and began looking for confirmation. They contacted hospitals, sought information and reached out to local news organizations. Philadelphia police opened a missing-child investigation on Dec. 30 after a news outlet alerted the Special Victims Unit to the case.
Detectives then tried to verify the alleged collision. They checked with hospitals, the city medical examiner and the Crash Investigation Unit, according to prosecutors. No matching accident or death was found. Police located Bailey on Jan. 4, 2024. Prosecutors said she first claimed she had been walking with Damari near 40th Street and Lancaster Avenue when he dropped a toy and was struck. She later said Spencer had been walking with the boy instead. When police found Spencer, he initially denied knowing Damari before repeating a similar crash story.
Both defendants told detectives that an ambulance had taken Damari to Children’s Hospital of Philadelphia, where he died, and that the hospital had lost the child’s body, prosecutors said. Detectives found no evidence supporting the account. A search of Spencer’s apartment also found no sign of Damari and none of his belongings. Investigators then began drawing together evidence from the neighbor, the building’s cameras and the defendants’ phones. Bailey and Spencer were arrested in January and charged while the boy’s whereabouts remained unknown.
The absence of Damari’s body left a major gap in the case for more than two months. On March 18, 2024, workers cleaning an area behind the 600 block of North 38th Street came across a black duffel bag containing the badly decomposed remains of a child. The condition of the body initially made identification impossible. DNA testing later confirmed the child was Damari. Prosecutors said the bag matched the type Spencer had been recorded carrying on Dec. 9 and that Damari was wearing the same clothing seen in video from the days before his death.
The medical examiner determined that Damari died of homicidal violence. By the time of trial, prosecutors could therefore present several forms of evidence that reinforced one another: the neighbor’s description of what she heard, her recordings, hallway surveillance, recovered cellphone videos, the false crash story, the lack of hospital or accident records, the defendants’ changing statements and the eventual recovery of Damari’s remains. Prosecutors argued that Spencer inflicted the fatal violence and that Bailey permitted the abuse and participated in the effort to conceal the boy’s death.
Defense attorneys challenged that account from different directions. Spencer’s lawyer emphasized the lack of a witness who directly saw either defendant strike Damari and questioned how accurately Jennings could interpret sounds from the apartment above her. Bailey’s defense maintained that she was not present when Damari died and noted evidence that the neighbor generally heard the troubling noises after Bailey had left for work. Her attorney argued that Bailey’s conflicting accounts reflected confusion and her relationship with Spencer rather than proof that she intended her son to be killed.
The jury’s verdict showed that it accepted substantial parts of the prosecution’s case while rejecting its most serious murder theory. Both defendants were acquitted of first-degree murder. They were nevertheless found guilty of third-degree murder and every group of related offenses announced by prosecutors after the trial. The difference matters because the jury did not make the finding required for first-degree murder but still concluded that the evidence established murder and shared criminal responsibility at the third-degree level.
The proceedings also turned Jennings’ Dec. 7 call into a lingering question beyond the criminal trial: what happened after an outside witness tried to alert the city that a child might be in danger? The limited information publicly available has not established that an agency worker reached Damari before his death. At the preliminary hearing, prosecutors said they had subpoenaed DHS records to learn more. Confidentiality restrictions have constrained public discussion of those records, and the criminal verdict itself did not decide whether any public agency violated a legal duty.
For the homicide case, the next confirmed step is sentencing. Bailey and Spencer are due before Covington on Dec. 4, 2026. Spencer’s lawyer has said his client wants to appeal the verdict, while Bailey’s post-trial plans have not been publicly detailed in the material reviewed for this report. The murder convictions now stand alongside the unresolved questions about whether an earlier intervention might have changed the final days of a 4-year-old whose cries had already drawn a neighbor’s attention.
Author note: Last updated November 17, 2026.