Hialeah police investigated Marcia Sangronis while her own department separately removed the probationary officer from duty with pay.
NORTH BAY VILLAGE, Fla. — A domestic dispute investigated by police in one South Florida city quickly became an employment matter in another after Hialeah officers arrested North Bay Village Officer Marcia Sangronis over an alleged confrontation with her boyfriend during her scheduled time off.
North Bay Village police said it learned of Sangronis’ Oct. 6 arrest from the Hialeah Police Department and relieved her of duty with pay under agency protocols. The department emphasized in its public response that officers are expected to meet standards of conduct both on and off the job. That administrative action unfolded alongside, but independently from, a criminal case in which Sangronis, 38, was initially arrested on an aggravated battery allegation before a judge found probable cause the next day for the lesser offense of misdemeanor battery. The different actions illustrate the multiple reviews that can begin when an officer is accused of misconduct outside work.
Sangronis was not working when the reported incident occurred, according to her department. Hialeah police therefore handled the investigation because the alleged confrontation took place at her Hialeah residence. Her boyfriend approached Hialeah patrol officers that morning and reported that he had been physically attacked after trying to end their relationship. The officers were not Sangronis’ co-workers, and North Bay Village police said Hialeah authorities made the decision to arrest her after their own investigation. That division is important because the employing department’s immediate role was administrative rather than investigative.
North Bay Village’s response came while Sangronis was still a relatively recent member of the force. NBC 6 reported that she was sworn in as an officer in 2025, and CBS Miami described her as being on probation with the department when she was arrested. The agency did not announce a finding that she had violated policy in the statements reviewed for this article. Instead, it placed her off duty with pay while the criminal allegation proceeded. The publicly reported action was therefore an interim employment decision rather than a final disciplinary judgment.
The conduct under investigation was described in a Hialeah arrest report. Sangronis’ boyfriend told police that the couple, who had been together for about two years, had repeatedly argued about his career direction. He said Sangronis wanted him to show greater interest in pursuing law enforcement work and alleged that discussions of the subject could become angry and volatile. The topic surfaced while he stayed at her home the night before the arrest and again the following morning, he told investigators. Those statements came from the boyfriend and have not been established as facts by a court.
The boyfriend said he decided the next morning to end the relationship. When he tried to leave, he alleged, Sangronis stood at the doorway and blocked his exit. According to the arrest report cited by local outlets, he said he tried to reach the doorknob and was told he could not leave. The man said another attempt to exit was followed by a physical struggle in which Sangronis scratched him and bit his left forearm. He later told investigators that she pulled him away from the door while he was trying to get out.
Police said the man eventually left the residence and flagged down two Hialeah officers. Investigators documented three bite marks on his left arm, including one that broke the skin, and scratches on his face, arms and other parts of his body. A technician photographed the injuries. The documentation gave investigators physical evidence of the injuries visible after the encounter, but the publicly available reports do not establish that independent video recorded the events inside the residence. Sangronis also gave police a statement, but that portion of the arrest report was redacted.
The redaction leaves the public record weighted toward the allegations that supported the arrest. Sangronis’ full explanation to investigators is not available in the arrest document reviewed by news organizations, and she did not offer a detailed public account immediately after leaving jail. For that reason, the police narrative cannot be treated as a complete presentation of both sides of the confrontation. An arrest requires probable cause; it does not establish guilt. Any disputed factual questions remain for the criminal process to resolve if the case proceeds.
Hialeah police initially arrested Sangronis on an aggravated battery allegation involving great bodily harm. Florida law treats aggravated battery as a second-degree felony in circumstances that include intentionally or knowingly causing great bodily harm, permanent disability or permanent disfigurement. But at Sangronis’ first court appearance, Local 10 and CBS Miami reported that the judge found probable cause for simple battery, a first-degree misdemeanor under the ordinary battery provision. The court set a $1,000 bond and prohibited Sangronis from contacting the boyfriend. She later posted the bond and was released.
The reduction at that hearing changed the immediate criminal posture but did not settle the case or the employment question. The court was addressing probable cause and release conditions. North Bay Village police, meanwhile, had to decide what duty status was appropriate for an officer facing an off-duty criminal allegation. Those are separate standards. A department can remove an officer from normal duties while an allegation is pending without making a criminal finding, just as a judge’s preliminary ruling does not decide whether an employee should remain with an agency.
The case also places the department’s public accountability statement in a concrete setting. North Bay Village police said after the arrest that it holds personnel to high standards and expects accountability for actions on and off duty. The statement did not disclose the details of any internal-affairs review, specify a disciplinary timetable or announce a final employment outcome. Public reporting likewise did not establish that the department itself had concluded whether the boyfriend’s allegations were true. The confirmed personnel action was that Sangronis had been relieved of duty with pay.
For Hialeah police, the central questions were narrower: what happened at the residence, what injuries were documented and whether the evidence supplied probable cause for an arrest. For North Bay Village, the immediate concern was how to handle the duty status of one of its officers after being notified of that arrest. For the court, the first issue was what offense was supported at the preliminary stage and what release conditions were appropriate. That separation of responsibilities helps explain why the case produced several official actions within a short period without producing a final determination of guilt or discipline.
No final disposition was established in the reliable public reports reviewed for this article as of Nov. 18. The latest clearly confirmed employment status was that Sangronis had been relieved of duty with pay, while the most clearly reported court action was the finding of probable cause for misdemeanor battery, the $1,000 bond and the no-contact order. Her complete police statement remains outside the public arrest narrative because it was redacted. Until later court or agency records establish otherwise, both the criminal allegation and any final employment consequence remain unresolved.
Author note: Last updated November 18, 2026.