A carpenter’s account of the home invasion was reinforced by DNA testing and evidence recovered from Karl Stanley’s vehicle.
McKINNEY, Texas — The capital murder case against Karl Andrew Stanley began with an eyewitness inside Paola Becvar’s home and expanded through DNA testing, search warrants and evidence recovered from Stanley’s vehicle before a Collin County jury convicted him and sent him to prison for life without parole.
A carpenter working at Becvar’s Celina residence on Nov. 25, 2024, became a central witness to the killing, according to the Collin County District Attorney’s Office. The worker reported seeing Stanley enter the home armed with a car jack and begin striking Becvar. Rather than merely watching the assault, the carpenter intervened and wrestled the tool away. Prosecutors said Stanley then followed Becvar farther through the house and strangled her. The worker’s call brought police to the property and gave investigators an immediate firsthand account against which they could compare the physical scene.
When Celina officers arrived, they found Stanley still inside the residence and only feet from Becvar’s body, prosecutors said. Officers also observed blood and hair on his hands. Becvar, 51, died at the scene. Stanley was arrested there, meaning the initial investigation unfolded with the alleged attacker, the victim, the eyewitness and the location of the attack all identified. The central question was not who had been present but how the evidence would establish the precise sequence of events and explain why Stanley had entered the home.
Detective Joseph Shires obtained warrants that allowed investigators to search the residence, collect Stanley’s DNA and examine his vehicle. The car jack described by the carpenter was recovered outside the home, the district attorney’s office said. Laboratory testing later confirmed Becvar’s blood on Stanley’s hands. Those findings gave prosecutors physical evidence that they could present independently of the witness’s recollection. The evidence from the scene also reinforced the responding officers’ observations and placed the object described as the initial weapon outside the home after the carpenter said he had taken it away.
The vehicle search produced evidence of a different kind. Investigators found a document titled “grudge list,” with Becvar’s name at the top, according to prosecutors. That discovery became significant because the state was also gathering records showing that Becvar had repeatedly contacted police about Stanley before her death. The list did not stand alone as proof of motive. Prosecutors linked it with testimony about the stalking reports, the trespass warning, Stanley’s recent arrest and an outstanding stalking warrant to argue that he had gone to Becvar’s home in retaliation for her efforts to involve law enforcement.
Detective Frank Alegre testified that Becvar had begun reporting Stanley’s harassment and stalking behavior to Celina police in early November 2024. Police eventually issued Stanley a criminal trespass warning connected to Becvar’s home. Authorities said he violated that warning and was arrested shortly before her death. He was no longer in custody when the fatal home invasion occurred. The earlier police actions became part of the prosecution’s proof that Stanley knew Becvar had reported him and that escalating legal consequences were developing from those complaints.
On the day of the killing, that escalation had reached another stage. Alegre had obtained a warrant to arrest Stanley for stalking about two hours before the home invasion, according to his testimony. Police had not arrested Stanley on that warrant before he arrived at Becvar’s home. Prosecutors described the short interval between the warrant and the killing as part of the factual timeline supporting their retaliation theory. The case therefore combined two kinds of evidence: direct proof about what happened inside the house and documentary or testimonial proof about the conduct that preceded Stanley’s arrival.
The earliest public reports did not contain all of those details. Celina police said after the killing that officers had responded to a home on Seattle Slew Drive after a break-in and found a woman who died at the scene. Police said Stanley and the victim knew each other, and he was arrested on charges that included capital murder and stalking. As detectives executed warrants and the case moved toward trial, prosecutors assembled a fuller account that connected the home invasion to the prior complaints and law-enforcement contacts.
At trial, Stanley pleaded not guilty to capital murder. Jurors heard the carpenter’s testimony about the break-in and his intervention, evidence about what officers saw when they entered the house, DNA findings, the recovery of the car jack and the document found in Stanley’s vehicle. They also heard the chronology of Becvar’s stalking reports and Stanley’s previous trespass arrest. Taken together, prosecutors argued, those pieces established both the killing and the reason Stanley had targeted his former girlfriend.
The jury returned a guilty verdict after deliberating for less than an hour. The conviction carried a mandatory sentence of life imprisonment without the possibility of parole, according to the Collin County District Attorney’s Office. Judge Richard Davis formally imposed that sentence. The result meant there was no separate jury decision over whether Stanley should eventually become eligible for release. His punishment was fixed by the capital murder conviction returned after the presentation of the state’s evidence.
Collin County District Attorney Greg Willis said the case was about a woman killed after reporting stalking to police. His public statement emphasized that Stanley entered Becvar’s home, attacked her and would now spend the rest of his life in prison. The prosecutor also acknowledged that a criminal sentence could not restore what Becvar’s family lost. That observation framed the verdict as both a legal resolution and a permanent consequence for people who knew Becvar outside the courtroom.
Becvar was born April 26, 1973, in Trujillo, Peru, according to funeral information published after her death. She was survived by her daughter, her parents, a sister, a brother, nieces, a nephew and her daughter’s father. Those details rarely appeared in the evidentiary account of the trial, which necessarily focused on the hours and weeks surrounding her death. They provide a fuller picture of the person behind the name repeatedly appearing in police reports, search warrants, testimony and forensic findings.
The evidentiary record ultimately moved in a chain from witness to scene to laboratory to motive evidence. The carpenter described what he saw; officers encountered Stanley and Becvar inside the home; investigators recovered the car jack and collected biological evidence; detectives searched Stanley’s vehicle; and prior police records supplied the chronology of the stalking complaints. The jury’s verdict showed that the state had persuaded jurors beyond a reasonable doubt of the capital murder charge despite Stanley’s not-guilty plea.
With Davis’ sentence imposed, Stanley is to remain in prison for life without the possibility of parole. The trial resolved the principal criminal case arising from Becvar’s killing, while the evidence presented in court preserved the sequence by which investigators said an eyewitness report, physical evidence and earlier stalking complaints converged into the prosecution that followed.
Author note: Last updated November 21, 2026.