A brief pause in the shooting produced witness accounts and video evidence that became central to the homicide case.
MILWAUKEE, Wis. — The evidence in the murder case against Terry Jefferson included not only what happened when shots were fired but what witnesses said they saw in the interval between them: Charles Williams wounded on an apartment hallway floor, Jefferson nearby with a handgun and a second burst of gunfire still to come.
That sequence was described in the criminal complaint that led to Jefferson’s prosecution for first-degree intentional homicide. A Milwaukee County jury convicted him in July 2026, and Judge Laura Crivello sentenced him Oct. 8 to life in prison for killing Williams, a friend who had been helping him move into an apartment. Jefferson, 35, will become eligible for release to extended supervision after 35 years, the minimum period established by the court.
The case began with an unusually immediate police response because officers were already inside the apartment building near North 27th Street and West Highland Avenue on Feb. 26, 2025. They were looking for a wanted person on an unrelated matter shortly before 5 p.m. when one officer heard a loud bang. The sound initially seemed as though it might have been a door. Minutes later came a rapid series of gunshots, and officers headed toward the second floor.
By the time they reached the hallway, Williams was on the ground near an elevator and Jefferson was standing within a few feet of him holding a handgun in his right hand, according to the complaint. Police ordered Jefferson to drop the weapon. He complied and was arrested. Officers then provided aid to Williams before he was taken to a hospital, where he was pronounced dead. The medical examination determined that he died from multiple gunshot wounds.
The investigation showed that the shooting had unfolded in separate stages. A resident near the hallway told detectives that one gunshot had been heard before the later group of shots. After that first report, the resident looked outside and saw Williams already wounded on the floor. Jefferson was holding a black semiautomatic handgun. The witness said Jefferson claimed at one point that Williams had shot himself and also said Williams had tried to take his gun. Jefferson asked for paramedics to be called.
That witness dialed 911, and Jefferson took the phone during part of the call, according to the complaint. Williams remained alive and was trying to move or get up, the resident told detectives. The resident eventually withdrew into the apartment. Only after that did the witness hear another six or seven shots in quick succession. The account provided investigators with a clear break in the reported gunfire and helped establish that events continued after the first wound was inflicted.
Detectives also obtained a doorbell-camera recording from the same general period. The 22-second clip captured activity after the initial gunshot and before the later volley, according to court filings summarized by local news reports. Jefferson could be seen standing over Williams. Williams was on the floor and was not moving during the recording. The video did not answer every question about the encounter, but investigators said it was consistent with the witness’s description of what happened in the hallway.
A separate witness supplied another piece of the sequence. That resident said Williams was near the elevator on his knees with his head lowered and appeared to reach toward a shopping cart filled with belongings. The shopping cart was part of the moving work Williams had been doing with Jefferson that day. The witness said Jefferson was telling Williams to remain down while manipulating the handgun, then fired additional rounds. The witness told investigators that Williams did not have a weapon that could be seen.
Physical evidence gave detectives another way to compare the accounts. Authorities recovered a black Taurus .45-caliber handgun where Jefferson was arrested and found eight spent .45-caliber casings in the area of the hallway. The location also showed where Williams had been lying after he was shot. Those findings were added to the witness statements and video as detectives questioned Jefferson about his conduct before the first shot, during the pause and when the later shots were fired.
Jefferson did not deny shooting Williams. In a police interview after his arrest, he said he had been carrying his handgun in the pocket of his hooded sweatshirt while moving into the building. Williams, whom Jefferson described as helping with the move, knew about the gun, Jefferson said. The men had been unloading a vehicle and taking items upstairs with a shopping cart. Jefferson said the confrontation developed near the elevator when Williams got close and began grabbing for things.
Jefferson said he interpreted Williams’ movement as an effort to reach his firearm, so he drew the gun and fired the initial shot. He believed that round struck Williams in the face. Jefferson said he then directed Williams to lie down. The gun malfunctioned after the shot, he told investigators, and he worked to clear it. Jefferson’s description therefore placed a mechanical interruption between his first use of the weapon and the additional rounds that were later fired.
His account also included a detail about the belongings he and Williams had been moving. After seeing that Williams was bleeding, Jefferson told investigators he moved the cart so that blood would not get on his possessions. That action occurred while Williams was wounded and before the confrontation was over, according to Jefferson’s statement as reported from the complaint. Jefferson later said Williams again moved toward him and reached for him, which he offered as the reason for firing the remaining rounds.
Other portions of the same interview put limits on that explanation. Jefferson acknowledged that he never saw Williams holding a gun or another weapon. When demonstrating the positions of the men, Jefferson indicated they were roughly one to two feet apart at the first shot. During the later shooting, however, Williams was farther away and could not simply reach out and touch him. Jefferson also said that once the second shooting began, Williams moved backward while continuing to face him.
The prosecution therefore entered the case with several types of evidence describing the same short span of time: residents’ observations, the video, the spent casings, the gun recovered when officers arrived and the defendant’s own account. The criminal complaint did not depend on a single witness who claimed to have seen every moment. Instead, the reported evidence covered different portions of the event, including the first shot, the pause that followed, Williams’ condition in the hallway and the later burst of gunfire.
Jefferson was formally charged with first-degree intentional homicide with a dangerous-weapon allegation. At his initial court appearance on March 2, 2025, cash bond was set at $200,000. The prosecution then continued through pretrial proceedings until the case reached a jury in July 2026. Jefferson argued that he had acted because he believed Williams was reaching for his firearm. Jurors nevertheless found him guilty of intentional homicide, rejecting his claim that the killing was legally justified.
Crivello’s sentencing on Oct. 8 completed the principal trial-court phase of the case. The judge imposed life imprisonment but set Jefferson’s eligibility for release to extended supervision after 35 years. That distinction means Jefferson may seek release after serving the required period, not that release occurs automatically at that point. The court’s order leaves him facing decades in prison for the shooting of the man who had entered the building that afternoon to help him carry his belongings.
The final legal result rests against the detailed record of the hallway itself: an elevator, a moving cart, a wounded man, residents looking out from nearby apartments and police already close enough to hear the shots. What began as an investigation into conflicting explanations of a shooting ended with a jury verdict assigning criminal responsibility. Jefferson is serving a life sentence for Williams’ death, and his earliest opportunity for release to extended supervision will come only after 35 years of imprisonment.
Author note: Last updated November 20, 2026.