Man allegedly shot porch visitor after suspecting romance with child’s mother

Jaymon Trey Gilreath told investigators he suspected Noah Slinkard was seeing his former partner but reportedly could not recall the shooting itself.

BLOOMINGTON, Ind. — Jaymon Trey Gilreath gave police a detailed account of the hours leading to Noah Slinkard’s fatal shooting: missed plans, unanswered calls, a vehicle he recognized and a suspicion about his former partner. But when detectives reached the shooting itself, court records say Gilreath claimed his memory stopped.

That contrast — a reported account of what came before and after the gunfire but not the moment at the center of the case — is one of the most notable elements in the probable-cause allegations against Gilreath, 23. Investigators say other evidence fills the gap that Gilreath described, including the account of a man sitting beside Slinkard, statements from three people who had been riding with Gilreath and surveillance footage that police say captured the shooting. Gilreath is charged with murder in Slinkard’s Oct. 8 death and has entered a not-guilty plea.

According to accounts of the probable-cause affidavit, Gilreath told detectives he shared a child with a woman with whom he had been in a relationship. He said the two had expected to spend time together earlier on Oct. 8 but that she did not show up and stopped responding to his calls or messages. He told investigators he developed what he described as a “gut feeling” that she was cheating on him with Slinkard. Police later cited Gilreath’s belief about a possible relationship as a potential motive, but the public record reviewed for this article does not establish whether Slinkard and the woman were actually dating.

Gilreath was later riding with friends when he saw the woman’s vehicle near her mother’s residence and noticed Slinkard sitting on a porch with another man, according to the affidavit. The people in the vehicle told investigators that Gilreath immediately wanted to get out and said he intended to fight Slinkard. They also said he made a remark to the effect that they should leave if they heard a gunshot. The three witnesses reported hearing a shot after Gilreath left the vehicle, according to the court filing.

The man sitting with Slinkard supplied police with a more direct description. Investigators said the witness reported seeing Gilreath approach on foot, pull a handgun from his waist and shoot Slinkard before turning and walking away. Several people called emergency services at about 8:15 p.m., telling dispatchers that a man had been shot in the 1000 block of North Illinois Street and that the suspected shooter was heading east on West 13th Street. Officers arrived to find Slinkard near the front doorway or porch of the residence with a gunshot wound to the head.

Emergency medical workers transported Slinkard to IU Health Bloomington Hospital. He was pronounced dead at 9:49 p.m., authorities said. The Monroe County Coroner’s Office later identified the victim as Noah Slinkard, 24. Early police reports initially withheld his name while officials worked through the identification and notification process. The available reporting does not describe a broader confrontation on the porch or say Slinkard was armed. Police accounts focus instead on the allegation that Gilreath approached while Slinkard was sitting outside.

Gilreath’s conduct immediately afterward also became part of investigators’ case. According to the affidavit, he called 911 while officers were responding and told dispatchers he had just shot someone. Police found him at 8:23 p.m., roughly eight minutes after the initial calls, and arrested him without incident. Officers then searched the route he was believed to have taken from the residence and recovered a holstered 9 mm handgun near a park bench in the 1300 block of West 13th Street by Crestmont Park. Police said they believed it was the weapon used in the shooting.

When detectives interviewed Gilreath, he reportedly described the suspicions and circumstances that brought him to the residence but said he could not specifically remember what happened once he reached the porch. According to the affidavit, Gilreath said his next recollection was leaving the area and recognizing that he was holding his gun with the safety off. He then realized he had shot Slinkard, the filing says. The statement is an allegation about what Gilreath told investigators, not a judicial finding about his state of mind or memory.

Police said evidence outside Gilreath’s own account provided a record of the shooting. The affidavit says cameras in the area showed Gilreath shoot Slinkard and leave. Investigators also had the porch witness’s account and statements from the people who had been in the vehicle. Those sources could become important if prosecutors argue that the events can be reconstructed even though Gilreath reportedly said he could not remember pulling the trigger. The recordings and full witness interviews have not been publicly presented at a trial, leaving their precise content and any defense challenges unresolved.

The difference between an alleged motive and proof of murder is also important to the case. Investigators may use evidence of jealousy or suspicion to explain why they believe a confrontation occurred, but a motive is not itself an element that automatically proves a murder charge. Prosecutors still must establish the conduct and required mental state under Indiana law. Gilreath’s attorneys, meanwhile, can dispute the state’s evidence, question witnesses and challenge the interpretation or admissibility of statements and recordings. None of those adversarial steps is reflected fully in an initial probable-cause affidavit, which presents information used to justify a criminal charge.

After his arrest, Gilreath was taken for a medical evaluation and then booked into the Monroe County Jail. At an Oct. 12 preliminary hearing, he pleaded not guilty. Indiana Public Media reported that Gilreath asked whether he could be released to stay with his mother and children, noting that he had no prior felonies. Court Commissioner Bret Raper told him he was not eligible for bond in the murder case. During the hearing, Gilreath also asked a question about his right to remain silent after saying he only “somewhat” understood the rights being explained to him. A public defender advised him that the commissioner could not provide legal advice.

The hearing moved the case from the rapid police response into the slower court process, where the meaning of the evidence can be contested. Gilreath’s reported “gut feeling” has drawn attention because investigators cited it while describing a possible motive, but the prosecution’s case as publicly outlined is not based on that statement alone. Police have also pointed to a direct eyewitness, companions’ statements, the alleged 911 admission, the recovered handgun and surveillance footage. The weight and admissibility of each item remain matters for the court.

October reports listed a bond review for Oct. 27 and a pretrial conference for Nov. 18. Those scheduled dates have passed. As of Nov. 20, reliable publicly indexed reporting reviewed for this update did not establish the outcome of those proceedings, announce a trial result or report a change to Gilreath’s not-guilty plea. He therefore remains an accused defendant in the available record, and the allegation that he murdered Slinkard has not been adjudicated.

Author note: Last updated Nov. 20, 2026.