Colton Christopherson remains accused of first-degree intentional homicide in the Sept. 26 death of his father, longtime educator Allan Christopherson.
SHELL LAKE, Wis. — A Wisconsin homicide prosecution arising from the death of longtime Wayzata teacher and coach Allan Gregory Christopherson is approaching a competency hearing, shifting the case temporarily from the allegations surrounding his Sept. 26 death to a legal question about whether his son can presently participate in his own defense.
Colton Douglas Christopherson, 25, of St. Michael, Minnesota, has been charged in Washburn County Circuit Court with first-degree intentional homicide. Reporting on his October court appearance said he was being held on $5 million bail and that the court ordered a competency examination, with a hearing scheduled for Dec. 7. The criminal charge has not been proven, and a competency evaluation does not determine guilt or innocence. Instead, it addresses whether the defendant can understand the proceedings and assist counsel as the case moves forward.
The need for that evaluation has become a significant procedural development because the charging document describes statements and behavior that prosecutors say preceded and followed Allan Christopherson’s death. According to news reports based on the complaint, Colton Christopherson told investigators he believed his father had hired someone to kill him. The complaint also describes his belief that passing vehicle colors and license plates carried special meanings. Those assertions are attributed to Colton and are not evidence that such a plot actually existed.
Authorities say the case began for deputies as a welfare check rather than a reported homicide. A caller told the Washburn County Sheriff’s Office that Allan Christopherson was having difficulties with his son and that Colton had been acting unusually, according to the complaint. The caller also expressed concern about possible drug use. Deputies went to the family cabin in Casey Township near McKenzie Lake, northwest of Spooner, to locate Allan and determine whether he was safe.
The complaint says officers encountered Colton Christopherson outside or near the attached garage as they arrived. When a deputy asked about Allan, prosecutors say Colton indicated that his father was dead and then acknowledged killing him. He allegedly told officers that Allan had been dead for more than an hour and said a knife was involved. Deputies immediately detained him. The reported statements were made before officers entered the residence and form a central part of the state’s account of the initial encounter.
Inside, deputies found Allan Christopherson in a basement laundry area and confirmed that he was dead, according to the complaint. Investigators reported blood in multiple locations and found two orange-handled knives. They also described signs that parts of the cabin had been cleaned and said bloodstained clothing and shoes were found in a garbage bag in the garage. Those observations, combined with statements attributed to Colton, were incorporated into the charging narrative later filed in court.
Prosecutors allege the body had already been moved before law enforcement arrived. During an interview after his arrest, Colton Christopherson reportedly said he placed his father in a vehicle and drove to nearby hunting land because he planned to bury him there. According to the complaint, another person was present, preventing him from carrying out the plan. He allegedly drove back to the cabin and brought the body inside, intending to wait until later before returning to the hunting property. The allegation has not been tested at trial.
The hunting land is also important because another person’s observations helped fill in the hours before deputies arrived. Allan Christopherson had been hunting with a neighbor earlier that morning, but the neighbor left because of a family matter, reports based on the complaint say. After having difficulty reaching Allan, the man returned to the area and encountered Colton. The complaint describes Colton as behaving strangely and later asking the neighbor to follow him while he drove a vehicle to the hunting property so the neighbor could bring him back. The neighbor refused the request.
When investigators questioned Colton about why he had confronted his father, he allegedly said he had traveled from Minnesota because he believed Allan had arranged for someone to kill him. Prosecutors say Colton claimed his father confirmed that belief when confronted and that he then attacked him. Nothing in the reporting reviewed independently substantiates the claim that Allan had arranged to harm his son. In a criminal case, that distinction matters: a defendant’s reported belief may be relevant evidence, but it does not make the underlying belief true.
The competency issue likewise should not be confused with a final judgment about Colton Christopherson’s mental condition at the time of the alleged offense. Competency focuses on the defendant’s current ability to understand court proceedings and work with an attorney. Questions involving criminal responsibility at the time of an offense are legally distinct and may involve different standards and evidence. The publicly available reporting reviewed for this article does not establish how the competency examination will be resolved or what additional legal arguments the defense may raise.
The prosecution has also affected a large community outside Washburn County because Allan Christopherson spent nearly 30 years working in Wayzata Public Schools in Minnesota. He joined the district in the 1998-99 school year and became known as a math teacher and coach at Wayzata High School. Principal Scott Gengler told families that Christopherson was regarded as a caring and effective teacher who formed strong relationships with students and colleagues. His wife, Tina Christopherson, has also worked for the district, according to the Minnesota Star Tribune.
Christopherson’s coaching record gave him a particularly visible place in Minnesota high school sports. His obituary says he coached girls and boys basketball before becoming Wayzata’s head golf coach in 2009. The golf program won state championships in 2010, 2011, 2015 and 2017 during his tenure. In 2026, he was again involved with golf as a developmental coach in the girls program. The team said after his death that he had influenced hundreds of young golfers over the course of his career.
The contrast between that public record and the allegations in the criminal complaint has shaped coverage of the case. School officials and former athletes have focused on Christopherson’s work as an educator and mentor. Court filings, by comparison, document the alleged events of one day, the physical evidence deputies say they found and statements attributed to his son. Neither body of information changes the presumption that Colton Christopherson is innocent unless and until the state proves the charge against him.
For now, the next publicly reported decision is procedural. The Dec. 7 competency hearing is expected to determine whether the criminal case can continue on its ordinary track or whether further steps concerning competency are required. Until the court acts, the first-degree intentional homicide allegation remains pending, Colton Christopherson remains accused rather than convicted, and the claims contained in the charging document remain allegations subject to the judicial process.
Author note: Last updated November 20, 2026.