Court records describe competing pieces of evidence surrounding Faith Smith’s death, while later firearm findings have opened another federal case.
AMARILLO, Texas — Leonard Torres told investigators he shot Faith Smith but said the shooting was an accident, according to court records. Amarillo police reached a different legal conclusion, accusing the 48-year-old man of murder after Smith’s body was recovered from a grave behind a residential garage.
The difference between Torres’ explanation and the charge against him now sits at the heart of a case assembled through several forms of evidence rather than a single allegation. Investigators have a cooperating witness who described the shooting, Smith’s recovered body, a vehicle police say was connected to the killing, statements attributed to Torres and evidence developed later during a search for a firearm. The public record remains incomplete, however. Authorities have not released a full transcript of Torres’ interview, complete autopsy findings or all forensic results. A murder charge is an allegation, not a conviction, and prosecutors must prove their case in court.
The cooperating witness’ account provides the clearest publicly reported description of the alleged shooting itself. According to court documents, the witness told investigators she was driving a blue Fiat with Torres and Smith as passengers in late September. As they traveled north on North Mirror Street, the witness alleged, Torres shot Smith with a handgun. Reporting on the court records lists Sept. 27 as the date. The witness also said Torres pointed the firearm at her after the shooting and threatened to kill her or members of her family if she told anyone. That alleged threat formed part of investigators’ account of what happened immediately after Smith was wounded and helped explain an aggravated assault allegation against Torres.
Investigators were able to test portions of the witness’ narrative against discoveries made after they received information about the suspected homicide. Amarillo police said the Homicide Unit learned Oct. 1 that a Colorado woman had been shot inside a vehicle and buried at an unknown location in the city. Detectives identified possible witnesses and said they confirmed details of the report. Police then identified Torres as a suspect and located him driving the same vehicle investigators believed was connected to Smith’s shooting. His presence in the vehicle did not by itself establish what happened inside it, but it gave police a tangible link to an account that had begun with information from other people.
Torres’ arrest added another element to the prosecution’s case. According to an arrest report cited by local media, officers tracked the suspected vehicle to the Rama Motel on East Amarillo Boulevard and later followed Torres as he drove away. Police attempted to stop him after an alleged traffic violation. Authorities said he fled, beginning a short pursuit that ended when another police vehicle blocked his route. He was initially booked on allegations including evading arrest or detention with a vehicle and aggravated assault with a deadly weapon. Prosecutors later added the murder charge after the homicide investigation progressed. Flight can become a disputed evidentiary issue in criminal cases, but the public reports do not establish what explanation Torres may offer for the pursuit.
What officers learned after the arrest led them to the most important physical discovery in the case: Smith’s body. Investigators went to a house on Orange Street in the Hamlet neighborhood and focused on an area behind a detached garage under construction. Crime scene personnel located a burial site and recovered the body. Police later identified the woman as Smith, 31, of Colorado, and ordered an autopsy. The witness had told investigators she was present when Smith was buried and could describe the location, according to court reporting. The recovery therefore provided police with physical corroboration for at least that part of the account, even though it did not independently establish every detail of the alleged shooting.
Torres’ reported interview with detectives may prove especially important because the documents attribute two admissions to him. He allegedly acknowledged that he shot Smith, while insisting it was accidental. He also admitted burying her body at the location where officers recovered it, according to the criminal complaint. Those statements narrow some factual disputes while leaving a crucial one unresolved: the circumstances and intent surrounding the gunshot. The sources reviewed do not provide a full version of Torres’ explanation, such as what he said he was doing with the firearm immediately before it discharged. Without the complete interview and other evidence, the precise defense theory cannot be established from public reporting alone.
The prosecution’s burden will therefore extend beyond showing that Torres possessed or fired a weapon. A court will have to evaluate the admissible evidence connected to the murder allegation, including witness testimony, forensic findings and Torres’ statements. The cooperating witness’ allegations of a threat after the shooting may be used by investigators to describe his conduct, but that testimony will be subject to the normal testing that occurs in court, including cross-examination if the witness testifies. The same applies to the state’s interpretation of Torres’ actions after Smith’s death. Burying the body is a major part of the alleged sequence, but it does not eliminate prosecutors’ obligation to prove the charged homicide offense itself.
A later gun investigation has potentially added another category of evidence, although authorities have not publicly announced a conclusive link between the firearm and Smith’s shooting. When police arrested Leonard Torres, they found several cellphones in the vehicle. One belonged to the cooperating witness, according to court records. Investigators determined that Torres had used the phone to call his brother, Salvador Torres. After the call, Salvador Torres sent a text saying he wanted his “strap” back. Authorities interpreted that slang as a possible reference to a firearm. Salvador Torres later maintained that he was referring to a BB gun, the court records say.
Police searched a North Roosevelt Street home used by family members and reported finding 9mm ammunition in Salvador Torres’ bedroom. Salvador Torres was not there during the search, but he contacted an investigator the next day and said he had located what he believed police wanted. According to court filings summarized by NewsChannel 10, he showed officers a Taurus 9mm handgun wrapped in a red bandana that he said had been beneath a dresser. Crime scene testing found reported blood residue on the gun. Investigators also found phone messages they said concerned a firearm and ammunition. Those findings led to a federal charge accusing Salvador Torres, a convicted felon, of unlawfully possessing a firearm.
The federal case against Salvador Torres should not be confused with the murder prosecution. The reporting reviewed does not say he has been charged with participating in Smith’s death. Nor does it establish that the Taurus handgun has been conclusively identified as the weapon that fired the fatal shot. Its recovery may provide investigators with an avenue for DNA, blood, ballistic or other forensic testing, but no complete set of results has been publicly reported. That distinction is important because the discovery of potentially relevant evidence is not the same as proof of what role, if any, that evidence played in a homicide.
Smith’s death thus presents prosecutors with a case containing an unusual mixture of admitted conduct and disputed meaning. Torres allegedly admits firing the shot and burying Smith but disputes, through his accident claim, the implication that the shooting was an intentional murder. Investigators have a witness who gives a more incriminating account and alleges a threat afterward. Police recovered Smith from the location described during the inquiry, found Torres with the suspected vehicle and later developed a separate trail toward a handgun. Leonard Torres remains jailed with bond denied as the murder case proceeds, while Salvador Torres faces his separate federal firearm charge. The final legal weight of those facts remains for the courts to determine.
Author note: Last updated Nov. 19, 2026.