Dexter Perkins was a stranger to Michael Freund when the men met at a Wheaton-area bar before an encounter prosecutors said ended in murder.
WHEATON, Ill. — Nearly three years after Dexter Perkins was killed during an early-morning encounter with men he had never met, a DuPage County jury convicted Michael Freund of first-degree murder in the 37-year-old father’s death.
The Oct. 9 verdict ended the guilt phase of a case that began just days before Christmas in 2023 and left Perkins’ two daughters without their father. Prosecutors said Perkins initially socialized with Freund and two of Freund’s co-workers at Rosie O’Reilly’s in unincorporated Wheaton, sharing drinks and pizza before a dispute developed. Within roughly 90 minutes of the men arriving at the bar, deputies were responding to a report of gunfire and Perkins was dead outside. Jurors later rejected Freund’s claim that the shooting was self-defense.
DuPage County State’s Attorney Bob Berlin focused on Perkins and the people left behind after the verdict. He said the killing had caused a lasting loss for Perkins’ relatives and friends and emphasized that two children had lost their father. Berlin said the conviction could not return Perkins to them but expressed hope that the jury’s decision would provide some measure of accountability. His comments shifted attention away from the unusual details surrounding the original dispute and back to the permanent consequence of the shooting.
Perkins and Freund had no reported history before Dec. 22, 2023. Authorities said Freund and two co-workers arrived at Rosie O’Reilly’s at about 7:20 a.m. after finishing a work shift. Perkins was already there. Rather than staying apart, the four men began interacting. Prosecutors said they drank and ate together, and trial reporting described surveillance video showing the men talking at the bar. Perkins also bought a round of shots for the group.
The friendly interaction later gave way to disagreement. Prosecutors said a second pizza arrived and Perkins gave Freund and one co-worker one slice each, then kept the rest. Published trial accounts said Perkins intended to take the remaining pizza with him. An argument developed involving the food and the bar tab. The bartender offered to remove the pizza from Freund’s bill, according to evidence described during the trial, but the dispute did not end.
For prosecutors, what happened next separated an ordinary disagreement from the later homicide. Freund left the immediate scene and went to his pickup truck. He obtained a 9 mm Glock handgun and returned to the bar with it, authorities said. Trial reporting also said prosecutors presented evidence that Freund offered another gun to one of his co-workers, who refused it. That sequence later became important when the defense argued that Freund fired only because he believed someone was in danger.
The group eventually went outside onto the bar’s porch or deck. There, Perkins and one of Freund’s co-workers became physically involved. Prosecutors described the incident as a brief scuffle. Video evidence discussed at trial reportedly showed the two men in close contact, including moments the prosecution characterized as a bear hug or dancing. The defense rejected that interpretation and argued that what Freund saw was significantly more threatening.
Defense attorney Dave Carlson told jurors the case involved a tragic death but argued that the evidence did not establish first-degree murder. Freund’s defense focused heavily on the confrontation outside and his belief that intervention was needed. Carlson challenged the prosecution’s description of the interaction between Perkins and the co-worker and disputed the state’s theory of Freund’s intent. The defense asked jurors to evaluate the shooting from the perspective of the danger Freund claimed to perceive at that moment.
Prosecutors instead asked jurors to view the shooting as the final stage of a longer chain of decisions. They noted that Freund had already gone to his truck to retrieve a weapon before the physical encounter outside reached its peak. They also emphasized that Perkins was unarmed. Assistant State’s Attorney Lee Roupas argued that Freund’s actions were not legally justified and urged the jury to reject the self-defense claim.
According to the prosecution, Freund pulled the Glock from his clothing while the men were outside and fired two shots into the air. The encounter between Perkins and the other man continued. Trial reporting said Perkins went to the ground before getting back up. Prosecutors said that when he moved toward the other man again, Freund fired at Perkins from the opposite side of a wooden railing. Perkins was struck multiple times and died at the scene.
The gunfire transformed a chance encounter among strangers into a homicide investigation. DuPage County sheriff’s deputies were sent to Rosie O’Reilly’s at about 8:40 a.m. after a report of shots fired. Freund remained at the bar. Authorities said he had returned the Glock to the center console of his truck after the shooting. Deputies took him into custody without incident and investigators recovered the weapon.
Prosecutors charged Freund with first-degree murder, and a judge ordered him held while the case proceeded. For nearly three years, the charge remained an allegation that prosecutors still had to prove beyond a reasonable doubt. Freund retained the presumption of innocence during that period. That changed only when the jury heard the evidence and returned its verdict in October 2026.
The three-day trial gave both sides the opportunity to frame the same morning in very different ways. Prosecutors treated Freund’s departure to obtain a gun and his later use of it as part of a continuous course of conduct that ended without legal justification. The defense concentrated more closely on the immediate confrontation outside and disputed the suggestion that the interaction was harmless before Perkins was shot. Jurors had to determine which account was supported by the evidence and the law.
They reached their decision in less than an hour. By finding Freund guilty of first-degree murder, the jury concluded that prosecutors had met their burden and rejected the defense argument that the shooting was legally justified. The verdict moved the case from a disputed accusation into the post-conviction phase of the criminal process.
The attention generated by the pizza dispute can obscure how little the men knew about one another before the encounter. Perkins had not arrived to meet Freund. There was no reported feud stretching back days or years and no established relationship that explained the violence. The men crossed paths at a bar, socialized for a time and then entered a conflict that escalated through several distinct stages before the fatal shooting.
That absence of a prior relationship made the loss particularly stark in prosecutors’ public comments. Perkins went into the morning as a patron among strangers and did not leave alive. His daughters were later referenced by officials as among those most affected by his death. The available public record does not contain extensive statements from the family itself, and their views beyond what officials reported should not be assumed.
For Perkins’ family, the verdict provided a legal answer nearly three years after his death, though it could not undo the loss described by prosecutors after trial. Freund remains convicted of first-degree murder. A presentence proceeding had been scheduled for Nov. 9, but no reliable source reviewed for this report confirmed a final sentencing outcome, leaving that part of the case unresolved in the available public record.
Author note: Last updated Nov. 20, 2026.