The case developed from an unsolved May 2025 death into Billy Buford’s first-degree manslaughter conviction and sentencing.
OKLAHOMA CITY, Okla. — The call came shortly after midday on May 2, 2025: someone had found a dead person at a northwest Oklahoma City car wash. Seventeen months later, the homicide investigation that followed has ended with a guilty plea and a life sentence for Billy Buford.
The case moved through distinct stages, beginning with a scene where police publicly identified no suspect and ending with Buford, now 60, accepting criminal responsibility for the death of 48-year-old Douglas Eugene Smitherman. Buford pleaded guilty in May 2026 to first-degree manslaughter. In October, he received a life sentence with all but the first 16 years suspended, according to prosecutors. The sentence followed a presentencing investigation and a plea that did not include a predetermined punishment. Although the prosecution has now been resolved, authorities still have not publicly supplied a definitive motive for the fatal confrontation.
Police records place the start of the investigation at 12:36 p.m. on that Friday in May. Officers were sent to a car wash at 2012 NW 122nd St., near North Pennsylvania Avenue, after receiving a report of a deceased person. They found Smitherman there and observed injuries that appeared consistent with homicide. Police later released his full name and date of birth and classified the case as Oklahoma City’s 24th homicide investigation of the year. No suspect was in custody when the department issued its initial public bulletin nearly two weeks after his death, and detectives asked people with information to contact the homicide unit.
The uncertainty was still evident when police spoke publicly about the case on May 14. Investigators said they had little information about exactly what had occurred and were working to reconstruct Smitherman’s final hours and determine who had killed him. The Oklahoma medical examiner’s office had confirmed that the manner of death was homicide, but that determination answered only one of the major questions. Police had not announced a suspect, and the busy commercial setting around the car wash did not immediately produce a public explanation for what had happened. The investigation therefore remained centered on evidence gathering rather than an identified defendant.
That changed as detectives developed the case against Buford. Investigators eventually determined that he had repeatedly struck Smitherman in the head with a wooden 2-by-4 at the car wash. Buford was taken into custody and later faced a first-degree murder charge. The prosecution marked a major shift from the initial police bulletin, when authorities had only a homicide victim and an appeal for information. By the time charges were filed, officials had moved from asking who was responsible to alleging in court that Buford had caused Smitherman’s death. As in any criminal case before a guilty plea or verdict, the murder charge itself was an accusation rather than proof of guilt.
The emerging investigation also uncovered evidence of conflict before the killing. Authorities said Buford and Smitherman had fought in the days leading up to Smitherman’s death and had thrown bricks at one another during an earlier confrontation. That history provided context for investigators, but officials did not publicly identify a final motive or say exactly what prompted the encounter at the car wash. The distinction is important: evidence that two people had previously fought does not by itself explain what caused the later fatal assault. Even after the criminal case ended with a guilty plea, the public record remained incomplete on the immediate trigger for the violence.
The next major turn came not through a trial but through Buford’s plea in May 2026. He pleaded guilty to first-degree manslaughter rather than continue toward trial on the original murder prosecution. The plea was entered without an agreed sentence, meaning Buford knew the conviction but did not have a fixed punishment negotiated in advance. That left sentencing to the court after additional review. Prosecutors said a presentencing investigation was conducted before the sentence was imposed. Public accounts do not disclose the entire report, the full sentencing arguments or every consideration that informed the court’s decision, so those parts of the process cannot be reliably reconstructed from the released material.
In October 2026, the court imposed a life sentence and suspended all but the first 16 years. That wording is significant. It does not mean that Buford received only a 16-year sentence, nor does it mean that the entire life term is necessarily to be spent in prison. The judgment, as described by prosecutors, leaves the first 16 years of the life sentence unsuspended and suspends the remainder. Available reporting does not provide enough verified information to calculate a release date or explain how every future correctional rule might apply, so the safest description remains the one used in the sentencing announcement.
While detectives were building the case, Smitherman’s family was describing the person behind the homicide number. His mother, Barbara Smitherman, said he was a registered nurse, had worked as a house supervisor at McAlester Regional and was exceptionally intelligent. Friends and relatives knew him as “DougE Fresh.” His obituary said he graduated from McAlester High School in 1995 with a 4.0 grade-point average, later worked as a certified personal trainer and then earned his nursing degree from Eastern Oklahoma State College. It said he finished in the top third of his nursing class and worked at hospitals around Oklahoma, including as a traveling nurse.
Those details emerged after the earliest stages of the police investigation, when public reporting centered almost entirely on the location, Smitherman’s age and investigators’ request for leads. His family said he had recently returned to Oklahoma City because he wanted to make a fresh start away from McAlester. His mother recalled his clothing and style as readily as his academic ability and professional life. She also said the death followed another family loss: Smitherman’s father had died the previous September. Even while discussing her own grief, she expressed sympathy for Buford’s relatives and the consequences they would face as the case moved through court.
The case’s chronology therefore tells two parallel stories. One is procedural: a body found at a car wash, a homicide classification, a period without an announced suspect, an arrest, a murder charge, a manslaughter plea and a sentence. The other is personal: a nurse who had been trying to begin again in Oklahoma City became the victim at the center of a criminal investigation. Those strands converged at sentencing, when the court imposed punishment for conduct Buford had already admitted. A jury was never asked to determine whether prosecutors could prove the initial murder charge because the guilty plea resolved the case on first-degree manslaughter.
The roughly 17 months between the discovery of Smitherman’s body and Buford’s sentence transformed the status of the case, but they did not fill every gap in the public record. Officials have not released a definitive account of what started the fatal confrontation, and the public accounts of the sentencing do not disclose all material considered by the court. What is established is that investigators attributed Smitherman’s death to Buford’s repeated blows with a wooden board and that Buford ultimately admitted first-degree manslaughter.
With sentencing completed, the investigation that began as Oklahoma City’s 24th homicide case of 2025 has reached its principal criminal resolution. Buford faces the unsuspended portion of his life sentence, while Smitherman’s family continues to remember him beyond the police chronology as a father, son, brother and nurse who had returned to Oklahoma City looking for another start.
Author note: Last updated Nov. 21, 2026.