Illinois woman calls ex-boyfriend over then fatally shoots him

Jurors concluded Tara Anderson committed first-degree murder after hearing competing accounts of why she fired toward Phillip Armstrong through a fence.

EDWARDSVILLE, Ill. — Tara Anderson called it a warning shot. Madison County prosecutors called it murder. A jury ultimately accepted the prosecution’s account, and the difference between those two explanations now carries a 55-year prison term for the Illinois woman who shot and killed her former boyfriend, Phillip Armstrong.

The central dispute followed Anderson from her May murder trial into her Oct. 6 sentencing. There was no serious question by the time of trial that Anderson fired the shot that killed Armstrong on Sept. 24, 2023. Instead, the defense focused on what she meant to do when she fired. Anderson testified that she wanted to scare Armstrong away and did not intend to strike him. Prosecutors answered by pointing to where Armstrong was standing, why he had come to the property, what witnesses said Anderson had threatened beforehand and the direction in which the handgun was fired. Jurors deliberated a little more than three hours before finding her guilty of first-degree murder.

The physical setting was important to both sides. Armstrong, 39, had gone to Anderson’s residence in the 1400 block of Madison Avenue in Granite City to retrieve a vehicle at her request. Prosecutors said he was trying to place the vehicle on a trailer when Anderson came outside and confronted him. She then went back inside the home and returned with a .45-caliber handgun. Armstrong was roughly 100 feet away. Anderson fired once. The bullet traveled through a wooden privacy fence and struck Armstrong, who was later found dead in the roadway when police arrived.

A fence between the shooter and Armstrong did not end the prosecution’s effort to prove intent. Assistant State’s Attorney Morgan Hudson told jurors that Anderson had previously told people she wanted Armstrong dead. Prosecutors said a person inside Anderson’s home heard her say shortly before the shooting that she was going to kill him. Hudson argued that those statements mattered because they came before the gunfire rather than after it, when Anderson described the shot as a warning. Prosecutors also stressed that Armstrong had not arrived unexpectedly: Anderson had asked him to come for the vehicle he was loading when the confrontation occurred.

Police evidence added another layer to the state’s account. One witness told investigators he was with Armstrong when Anderson came outside and began yelling. The witness said Anderson returned toward the residence before he heard a single gunshot. Another witness reported seeing Anderson leave the home with a gun and hearing her make the threat prosecutors later emphasized at trial. Investigators found a .45-caliber shell casing on Anderson’s porch and recovered a handgun of the same caliber from the basement. Police said Anderson’s fingerprint was on the gun’s magazine. Those findings helped connect Anderson to the weapon before the defense eventually acknowledged she had fired the shot.

Because Anderson admitted firing, the trial did not depend on an unknown gunman or disputed identification. The jurors instead had to evaluate her explanation against the surrounding circumstances. Fahrenkamp argued that a fatal outcome did not necessarily mean Anderson intended to kill. Prosecutors argued that firing toward an area where Armstrong was known to be standing, after the reported threats and confrontation, supported a murder finding. State’s Attorney Tom Haine said after the verdict that the phrase “warning shot” could not erase the consequences of firing in someone’s direction. The jury’s verdict established the legal conclusion that the shooting met the requirements for first-degree murder.

Sentencing raised a different question: how severe the punishment should be within the available range. Anderson’s murder sentence was set at 30 years, but the use of a firearm added another 25 years, bringing the total to 55. Local reporting said she must serve 100% of the term. Fahrenkamp asked Judge Amy Maher for 45 years, which he described as the minimum term applicable in the case. He argued that even that punishment would keep Anderson incarcerated until she was an elderly woman. Prosecutors wanted more than 55 years and said Anderson’s conduct and history justified a sentence beyond the minimum.

The state’s sentencing argument widened the lens beyond the September 2023 shooting. Hudson told Maher that Anderson’s record included two felony drug convictions along with battery charges and numerous orders of protection. The prosecutor also said Anderson had previously fired a gun at Armstrong and had fired the same weapon at another former boyfriend. Those claims were not the basis of the jury’s murder verdict, but prosecutors presented them to the judge as aggravating circumstances relevant to punishment. Hudson argued that the pattern showed a history of resorting to gunfire during troubled relationships and weighed against a minimum sentence.

Fahrenkamp asked Maher to consider mitigating circumstances from Anderson’s background. He described her childhood and life as difficult and said she had post-traumatic stress disorder and other problems. The defense argued that adding more years to an already decades-long minimum would amount to excessive punishment. Fahrenkamp also moved for a new trial before sentencing, but Maher denied that request. Anderson then spoke briefly to the court. She apologized, said she had never wanted the events to happen and acknowledged making bad choices. Her statement again reflected the defense position that she had not set out to kill Armstrong, even though the jury had resolved the criminal question against her.

The sentencing hearing also gave Armstrong’s family a formal opportunity to describe what the shooting had cost them. His identical twin brother, Patrick Armstrong, submitted a statement remembering Phillip Armstrong as kind and loving. Armstrong’s daughter, now 13, spoke about losing her father when she was 10. She said his death had permanently affected her life and that future milestones would carry reminders of his absence. The statements did not determine whether Anderson was guilty — the jury had already done that months earlier — but they informed the judge about the human consequences of the crime before Maher chose the final sentence.

The path from a single gunshot to a 55-year prison term took more than three years. Police initially responded to Madison Avenue on the evening of Sept. 24, 2023, and described the killing as an isolated domestic incident. Anderson was arrested and charged soon afterward. The case later proceeded under Circuit Judge Maher, with Hudson and Assistant State’s Attorney Lauren Maricle handling the prosecution and Fahrenkamp representing Anderson. Trial began May 12, 2026. By May 14, the jury had heard the evidence, received the competing interpretations of the shot and returned its first-degree murder verdict.

For prosecutors, the verdict and sentence turned the phrase “warning shot” from the central defense theory into an argument the jury had expressly declined to accept. For the defense, the same phrase remained relevant at sentencing because Anderson continued to maintain that the killing was not what she intended. Maher’s 55-year sentence left the punishment between the 45 years requested by Fahrenkamp and the term exceeding 55 years sought by the state. Haine said the outcome held Anderson accountable, while acknowledging that no sentence could repair the loss to Armstrong’s family.

Anderson is now serving the prison term imposed for Armstrong’s murder. The reports reviewed for this article did not identify a later ruling that changed Maher’s sentence. The case therefore stands with both its central factual event and its central legal dispute resolved: Anderson fired the shot, Armstrong died, and a jury rejected the argument that describing the gunfire as a warning prevented it from constituting murder.

Author note: Last updated November 18, 2026.