Man confronts Utah woman over library phone theft then stabs her to death

Jeffrey Plante survived being stabbed after rushing to help Candace Samples and later addressed the court that sentenced her killer.

SALT LAKE CITY, Utah — Jeffrey Plante ran toward danger when another person told him a woman needed help behind a Salt Lake City store in 2018. Nearly eight years later, he stood in court as Kidus Chane Yohannes received life without parole for killing that woman, 20-year-old Candace Samples.

Plante’s role connects two parts of the criminal case that ended with Yohannes’ Sept. 29 sentencing: the murder of Samples and a separate stabbing that Plante survived. A jury convicted Yohannes, 39, of first-degree aggravated murder in August and also returned a verdict that resulted in an attempted-manslaughter conviction for the attack on Plante. Third District Judge Kristine Johnson imposed life without parole for Samples’ death and a separate zero-to-five-year prison term for the nonfatal stabbing.

At the sentencing hearing, Plante spoke about what had happened to his life since the attack. Local reporting said he described turning his life around and helping other people through his work. His appearance in court came years after a spontaneous decision to respond when a witness sought assistance at a nearby 7-Eleven. Prosecutors’ account shows that Plante had not been at the center of the original dispute. He became part of it when he went to help.

That original dispute concerned a cellphone. Investigators said Samples had taken Yohannes’ phone while they were at the Marmalade Branch Library on Nov. 7, 2018. The confrontation later moved across the area to a dumpster enclosure behind a Dollar Tree at 477 N. 300 West. Yohannes confronted Samples and another man about the phone, prosecutors said, and displayed a knife while demanding its return. Authorities said he threatened to use the weapon if he did not get the phone back.

A witness observing the confrontation left the enclosure area and went to the nearby convenience store, where Plante was told what was happening. He ran to the enclosure. Prosecutors said Yohannes attacked him after he climbed inside. Plante suffered stab wounds but survived. Another person who had been in the enclosure climbed over a wall to get away, then took a large board and returned in an effort to intervene. That person saw Yohannes attacking Samples, according to prosecutors.

The sequence ended with witnesses opening the enclosure gates and Yohannes leaving the area. Samples and Plante were transported for emergency treatment. Samples died shortly after reaching the hospital. Plante survived injuries serious enough to make his later appearance at sentencing a reminder that the violence produced more than one victim. The separate outcomes — one death and one survivor — would eventually be reflected in the two convictions and two sentences imposed in 2026.

Investigators began assembling evidence around the accounts of those who had been there. Surveillance video from the 7-Eleven showed Yohannes and Samples together before the stabbing, prosecutors said. Police found Yohannes and questioned him. Authorities said he denied involvement and denied knowing or interacting with the victims. Investigators took possession of his shoes after observing what appeared to be blood. Testing later matched blood from the evidence to Samples’ DNA profile.

That forensic result did not produce an immediate prosecution. The homicide occurred in November 2018, but Salt Lake City police did not announce Yohannes’ arrest in the case until 2021. At the time, police cited the return of crime-lab findings as an important development. The Salt Lake County District Attorney’s Office filed aggravated-murder and attempted-murder charges on July 22, 2021. The years between the killing and the filing of charges became only the first portion of an extended path through the justice system.

The case then faced more delays. Prosecutors said DNA testing, competency evaluations and witness availability affected the schedule. Trial did not begin until Aug. 4, 2026. The proceedings concluded Aug. 7, when jurors found Yohannes guilty of aggravated murder in Samples’ death. On the count involving Plante, the jury made a finding involving imperfect self-defense. That resulted in the attempted-manslaughter conviction that Johnson later punished with a term of up to five years.

The jury’s separate treatment of the two attacks reflected the different legal questions it was asked to decide, but both arose from the same confrontation. Prosecutors had charged Yohannes with attempted murder for Plante’s stabbing. The final conviction was less severe than that original charge because of the jury’s finding. No similar reduction occurred in the case involving Samples: jurors found Yohannes guilty of first-degree aggravated murder, exposing him to the sentence that ultimately eliminated the possibility of parole.

Samples’ family also addressed the sentencing court, ensuring that the hearing did not focus solely on the defendant or the mechanics of the prosecution. The people who raised her spoke about the joy of watching her grow up and about hardships she experienced, according to accounts of the proceeding. They described the absence her death had left in their lives. Family members prepared a video about Samples that Johnson allowed to be played for those gathered in the courtroom.

Those statements came after years in which Samples was frequently described in public records through the circumstances of her death: the stolen phone, the location behind the store, the forensic evidence and the homicide charge. The sentencing hearing provided her family a formal opportunity to speak about her as a person rather than merely the victim identified in the criminal case. It also placed the family’s long wait for a verdict alongside Plante’s experience of surviving the same encounter.

Salt Lake County District Attorney Sim Gill had acknowledged that delay after the August conviction. He thanked Samples’ parents for remaining involved throughout the case and said biological evidence had required multiple levels of testing. Gill credited investigators and prosecutors with continuing the case through the forensic and procedural delays. After Yohannes was sentenced, Gill said the office hoped Samples’ family had received some measure of justice, while emphasizing that the court could not return Samples to her community.

Johnson’s sentence established the legal consequences of the jury’s decisions. Yohannes was ordered to spend the rest of his life in prison without the possibility of parole for Samples’ murder. The zero-to-five-year term for Plante’s stabbing stands beside that life sentence, preserving in the judgment the fact that the encounter also nearly took another life. The two sentences arise from the same night but record two different consequences for the people who encountered Yohannes behind the store.

For Plante, the court appearance closed a circle that began not with the cellphone dispute itself, but with someone asking him to help. He survived the attack, later testified or participated in the process surrounding the case and was able to speak when Yohannes was sentenced. Samples did not have that opportunity. Her family spoke in her place, and their statements became part of the final hearing before the life-without-parole sentence was imposed.

As of Nov. 18, the reviewed public record identified no later development changing Yohannes’ sentence. His aggravated-murder conviction carries life without parole, and the attempted-manslaughter conviction carries the additional term imposed for the attack on Plante. The sentencing phase is complete, leaving a court record that reflects both the life lost in 2018 and the intervention of a man who survived after trying to help.

Author note: Last updated November 18, 2026.