Mom fights to save 3-year-old son after strange woman follows family from Ohio grocery store

Ohio appellate judges repeatedly applied the demanding plain-error standard while rejecting efforts to overturn Bionca Ellis’ murder convictions.

CLEVELAND, Ohio — Several of Bionca Ellis’ strongest appellate complaints faced an immediate obstacle before judges considered their substance: her attorneys had not made the same objections during the trial that ended with her conviction for killing 3-year-old Julian Wood.

That procedural fact runs through the Eighth District Court of Appeals’ Oct. 8, 2026, decision affirming Ellis’ convictions. Her appellate lawyers challenged testimony about Ohio’s insanity defense, prosecutors’ repeated appeals to “accountability,” one inaccurate summary made during the state’s closing argument and the scope of the defense’s questioning during jury selection. But because trial counsel had not objected to several of those matters when they happened, the appeals court reviewed them under the much stricter doctrine of plain error. The panel ultimately concluded that none justified disturbing the jury’s verdict or the life-without-parole sentence imposed after Julian’s 2024 killing.

Plain-error review is designed for exceptional circumstances. The appellate opinion said a defendant generally must demonstrate an obvious error affecting substantial rights and show a reasonable probability that the result would have been different without it. That is a different posture from an appeal built around objections clearly raised and ruled on during trial. Ellis’ first claim illustrates the difference. She argued that the prosecution’s psychiatric expert gave jurors an improper description of the insanity defense, but her attorneys had not objected to his explanation at trial. The appellate court therefore did not simply ask whether some language could have been clearer. It asked whether there was a plain, outcome-changing legal error serious enough to require reversal.

The judges found there was not. Dr. Stephen Noffsinger, the state’s psychiatric expert, testified that Ellis had schizophrenia but did not meet Ohio’s legal definition of insanity when the attack occurred. He repeatedly described the controlling question as whether a severe mental disease or defect caused Ellis not to know the wrongfulness of her acts. The defense’s psychiatrist, Dr. Sara West, reached the opposite conclusion, telling jurors that Ellis’ symptoms prevented her from understanding that what she was doing was wrong. The appellate defense argued Noffsinger improperly suggested an insanity claim required evidence that Ellis actually believed the attack was right. The judges said his testimony, viewed as a whole, correctly stated the law.

The trial judge’s instructions provided another reason the panel refused to reverse. Jurors were explicitly told that Ellis had to prove, by the greater weight of the evidence, that she suffered from a severe mental disease or defect and as a result did not know the wrongfulness of her actions. The appellate court said it presumed the jury followed that instruction. Because Noffsinger repeatedly articulated the same core test and the judge formally supplied it again, the panel found no plain error. The ruling did not say every phrase used during the trial was perfect; instead, it concluded the jury was not left with a materially false legal standard that undermined confidence in the verdict.

The appeal’s second issue followed a similar procedural path. Prosecutors had urged jurors during closing arguments to hold Ellis accountable for what happened to Julian and his mother, Margot Wood. On appeal, the defense said that wording could lead jurors to assume a not-guilty-by-reason-of-insanity verdict would mean Ellis escaped accountability altogether. Trial counsel, however, had not objected or asked the judge to explain the court-supervised consequences that can follow an insanity acquittal. The appeals court again applied plain-error review and concluded the prosecution never told jurors Ellis would simply be released. It also noted that the judge instructed them not to consider punishment in deciding the verdict.

The panel encountered a sharper problem when it examined another part of the prosecutor’s closing. The prosecutor summarized Noffsinger as having said that, to prevail on the insanity defense, Ellis had to prove she thought what she did was right. The appellate court expressly said that summary was incorrect. Noffsinger had testified that some people who satisfy the insanity standard believe their conduct is right because of delusions, but he had not said that such a belief was the exclusive legal test. Even so, the court did not find ineffective assistance in defense counsel’s failure to object. The correct standard had been repeated during testimony and in the judge’s instructions, and the judges said avoiding an interruption during closing argument can be a reasonable tactical choice.

That reasoning linked the preserved-error question to Ellis’ broader ineffective-assistance claim. To win on that ground, she had to show that her lawyers performed below an objective professional standard and that the shortcomings created a reasonable probability of a different outcome. The appellate judges rejected the claim. They said counsel was not ineffective for failing to object to matters that did not amount to plain error. As for the prosecutor’s inaccurate summary, they concluded an attorney could reasonably decide that objecting late in closing argument might emphasize the statement rather than diminish it. The court declined to substitute hindsight for trial strategy where the jury had already been given the correct rule.

Ellis also argued that her trial team should have explored prospective jurors’ views of mental illness more deeply. The appellate record showed that defense lawyers told the panel they intended to spend significant time discussing the not-guilty-by-reason-of-insanity defense and asked jurors about experiences with depression, bipolar disorder, schizophrenia, post-traumatic stress disorder and other mental-health issues. Counsel followed up by asking how those experiences shaped the jurors’ views. Ellis’ appellate attorneys proposed more direct questions about whether mental illness could make conduct legally noncriminal. The appeals court said the extent and wording of voir dire questions are among the most subjective decisions lawyers make and declined to second-guess the approach.

Behind those appellate rules was a case in which the underlying sequence of events was largely established rather than disputed. The court record says Ellis returned to the North Olmsted Police Department on June 3, 2024, several days after a shoplifting arrest, asking about money she believed had not been returned. She then went to a Volunteers of America thrift store and took two knives. She dropped one on the way to the adjacent Giant Eagle. Surveillance footage showed her enter the grocery store with the remaining knife, observe Margot Wood and Julian and then follow them after they left. Julian was sitting in a shopping cart as his mother prepared to load their vehicle.

A witness in the parking lot saw Ellis approach and attack the child and his mother. Wood attempted to protect Julian and pull him from the cart. Police and emergency medical workers responded, and both victims were taken to a hospital. Julian was pronounced dead. A North Olmsted police officer soon located Ellis walking toward Dover Center Road with the knife. The appellate opinion says she discarded it after the officer confronted her with his gun drawn and ordered her onto the ground. Authorities said there was no known prior relationship between Ellis and the Wood family, and prosecutors described the attack as random.

The case was delayed while courts addressed whether Ellis was competent to stand trial. In September 2024, the parties stipulated to a psychiatric report finding her incompetent, and she was ordered to inpatient treatment at Northcoast Behavioral Health. By February 2025, both sides stipulated to a report saying her competency had been restored. Her attorneys later entered a not-guilty-by-reason-of-insanity plea. At the October 2025 trial, the legal effect of her mental illness became the main disputed issue. Jurors rejected the insanity defense and convicted her on nine counts after the judge dismissed a tampering-with-evidence charge.

Judge John Russo sentenced Ellis on Oct. 27, 2025, to life in prison without the possibility of parole. The Eighth District’s decision nearly a year later did more than reject her substantive challenges; it showed how decisions made in real time at trial can narrow the arguments available on appeal. The panel overruled all three assignments of error, affirmed the convictions and returned the case to the trial court for execution of the sentence. That judgment remained in place as of Nov. 19, 2026.

Author note: Last updated November 19, 2026.