Police say Orlando doctor waited five minutes as 7-year-old boy in her care drowned

Florida authorities say Sukanthini Subbiah’s responsibility for a 7-year-old boy and her medical training make her alleged inaction criminally significant.

ORLANDO, Fla. — The criminal case arising from 7-year-old Khushil Bandi’s drowning is built around a question of responsibility: whether the adult supervising him failed so seriously to respond to an obvious emergency that her conduct amounted to culpable negligence under Florida law.

Police have charged Sukanthini “Suki” Subbiah, 48, with aggravated manslaughter of a child, a first-degree felony under Florida law when the state proves that culpable negligence caused the death of a person younger than 18. Investigators say Subbiah was entrusted with Khushil during an April 10 trip to an Orlando community pool and let crucial minutes pass after he began struggling. Her lawyer says the drowning was an accident, disputes that criminal liability is appropriate and says Subbiah will fight the case. She has pleaded not guilty.

That legal dispute gives the facts a different significance than they had when police first responded. The issue is not simply whether Subbiah could have reacted more quickly or whether another choice might have produced a better outcome. Criminal prosecutors would have to establish the much more serious proposition that her alleged conduct satisfied the law’s culpable-negligence standard and caused Khushil’s death. The defense, in turn, can challenge the state’s account of what she perceived, what she was capable of doing and whether a delayed or panicked response to an emergency can fairly be treated as a felony.

Investigators place particular weight on the relationship created when Subbiah took the children to the pool. She was visiting family in Orlando with her own 7-year-old son. Her son had befriended Khushil and his twin sister, and police said their mother gave Subbiah permission to take the twins to swim. Investigators therefore describe Subbiah as the adult responsible for Khushil at the time. Her mother was present, but Subbiah told detectives that her mother could not swim. Police say that left Subbiah as the adult with direct responsibility and the ability to respond.

Her profession is another part of the police theory. Investigators repeatedly noted that Subbiah is a physician. They argue that medical training gave her knowledge about the consequences of prolonged submersion and the urgency of restoring breathing. Police said Subbiah later acknowledged that it would not be realistic for a 7-year-old child to remain underwater intentionally for roughly two minutes. Investigators contend that such knowledge matters when evaluating whether she should have recognized that Khushil was in immediate danger rather than playing or voluntarily holding his breath.

The defense has pointed to the same medical career for a very different purpose. Attorney Rajan Joshi has described Subbiah as someone whose professional life has been devoted to helping and saving people and who had no previous trouble with the law. He said she cooperated with the investigation and voluntarily turned herself in. His position is that a devastating accidental drowning should not automatically become a criminal case because an adult’s response can be criticized afterward. That disagreement places intent, perception and the legal threshold for negligence alongside the physical timeline captured by the pool’s cameras.

Before the emergency, Subbiah told police she believed Khushil could swim. His twin sister wore a life vest, while Khushil did not, and Subbiah said she assumed that difference meant he was capable in the water. The children entered the pool shortly after arriving. Surveillance footage later reviewed by police showed Khushil moving toward the center before turning and splashing in a way investigators interpreted as active drowning. He went beneath the surface after more than a minute of visible distress, according to the police account.

The alleged failure to intervene begins there. Detectives say Subbiah was near the pool and could see the area where Khushil had disappeared. The video also recorded ordinary activity continuing around the emergency, including Subbiah attending to her son’s request for goggles. According to police, she did not proceed into the pool to reach Khushil until about five minutes after he had gone underwater. Even then, investigators allege, she stopped in shallow water rather than moving to the location where the boy was submerged.

Police say Subbiah then asked the other children, themselves about 7 years old, to try to get Khushil. When they could not, she sought help from another adult at the pool. That man entered the water and retrieved Khushil. By investigators’ calculation, the boy had been underwater for more than seven minutes. Subbiah performed CPR after he was brought out, and emergency services were called. Khushil was taken to a hospital but later died. Those later efforts are part of the record, but detectives say they came only after the period of inaction they consider central to the offense.

Subbiah’s explanations are also likely to matter in determining whether the state can prove its case. She initially described a much shorter period before intervention, telling investigators that she noticed Khushil underwater for about 45 seconds. In a later account, she gave an estimate closer to two minutes and said she froze. An emergency can produce confusion and distorted perception, an issue the defense may emphasize. Police, however, say the objective video timeline removes much of the uncertainty about how much time actually passed, even if it cannot by itself establish what Subbiah was thinking.

That distinction is important because the recording does not decide the legal case on its own. Video can show where people stood, when they moved and how long events lasted. It cannot automatically establish whether a person’s mental state or conduct meets a statutory standard. Investigators believe the footage, Subbiah’s responsibility for the children, her medical knowledge and her statements combine into evidence of culpable negligence. The defense is entitled to contest each part of that theory and to argue that police are assigning criminal meaning to conduct that occurred during a frightening and unexpected accident.

The charge also does not require the state to allege that Subbiah intended Khushil to die. The theory publicly described by police is about an omission rather than a deliberate attack: investigators contend that she had an urgent duty to act and failed to do so despite the danger, time and opportunity available. That makes causation another significant question. Police have said earlier intervention could have changed the outcome. In court, prosecutors would have to support the connection between the alleged negligence and the death with admissible evidence rather than relying solely on the conclusions contained in an arrest report.

The criminal process therefore places several layers of evidence before a judge or jury: the surveillance chronology, testimony about supervision, Subbiah’s own interviews, witness accounts, medical evidence concerning the drowning and the legal meaning of her conduct. The defense can test those claims through motions, cross-examination and its own evidence. The presumption of innocence applies throughout. An arrest affidavit states what investigators believe they can establish; it is not itself a verdict.

Subbiah was arrested months after Khushil’s death and booked in Orange County on the aggravated manslaughter charge. Her not-guilty plea means the state’s culpable-negligence theory remains contested. No later disposition located in the reporting reviewed through Nov. 17 establishes that she has been convicted or otherwise found criminally responsible. What began as a child’s fatal day at a neighborhood pool is now a case about where Florida law draws the line between tragic failure and criminal neglect.

Author note: Last updated November 17, 2026.