Her family described a prolific crafter, gardener and grandmother while Joseph Petrella contests charges arising from her September death.
PENFIELD, N.Y. — Amy Hogan was a mother and grandmother whose family remembered her kitchen, garden, craft projects and holiday traditions. Since September, however, her name has also become attached to a homicide prosecution after authorities charged her 39-year-old son, Joseph Petrella, with killing her inside their Ewald Drive residence.
Hogan, 60, died in mid-September under circumstances that are now the subject of a pending murder case in Monroe County Court. Prosecutors allege Petrella stabbed and cut her multiple times during a confrontation between the night of Sept. 12 and Sept. 13. Petrella has pleaded not guilty to second-degree murder, second-degree burglary and petit larceny. He has been held without bail. The prosecution has not publicly identified a motive, and an assistant district attorney has said investigators may never know exactly what preceded the alleged attack or why it occurred.
Before those allegations became public, Hogan’s life had been defined for her relatives by other details. Her obituary says she was born May 3, 1966, in Rochester to Judith and Ronald and developed a broad range of creative interests. She painted, crocheted, made pottery and soap, sewed, worked with papier-mâché, cooked and gardened. Her family described her as someone who was usually occupied with one project while already planning several more. Food and handmade creations were often shared with relatives and friends, and celebrations were marked by decorations and traditions she helped produce.
The obituary gives particular attention to Hogan’s two grandchildren, Clementine and Benedict. Family members wrote that being a grandmother brought her unusual happiness and recalled sleepovers filled with games, art, cooking, time in nature and family entertainment. Her garden was another point of pride, described as a place filled with flowers and vegetables along with small decorative fairy doors. Hogan also read extensively and maintained close friendships through concerts, evenings at friends’ homes, card games and long-running stories and jokes. She was survived by her mother, brothers Tim and David, her four children and her grandchildren.
Her death entered the public record almost by accident. Monroe County sheriff’s deputies were not sent to her residence because anyone had reported Hogan missing or in danger. Instead, at about 3 p.m. Sept. 13, deputies responded to a nearby home on Ewald Drive after a resident reported a burglary. Local reporting based on a supporting deposition said the resident’s vehicle had been ransacked and property was missing. Security footage contributed to suspicion that Petrella might have been involved, and deputies began questioning him as part of that investigation.
The sheriff’s office said Petrella gave a deputy permission to enter his residence. Chief Deputy Michael Fowler later said the deputy noticed circumstances inside that seemed unusual and caused concern. Petrella was detained while the investigation continued. Deputies then found Hogan dead in the residence, transforming the nature of the response. The scene was secured, and the sheriff’s Major Crimes Unit assumed responsibility for the investigation. Evidence technicians processed the home, investigators conducted a search under a warrant and a crime victim’s advocate responded to help Hogan’s family.
The condition in which Hogan was found became a major part of the later criminal complaint. Prosecutors allege her body was inside a bathtub and had been wrapped in a plastic shower curtain. The complaint said frozen items had been placed around her body, which an investigator described as an apparent effort to conceal it. The document also accused Petrella of stabbing and cutting Hogan several times with a sharp object during a confrontation. The allegations are serious but remain unproven. The sources reviewed for this report do not identify a definitive motive or provide a complete account of what occurred between mother and son before Hogan was killed.
Investigators arrested Petrella after processing the residence and gathering evidence. The sheriff’s office charged him with second-degree murder in Hogan’s death and with second-degree burglary and petit larceny in connection with the neighboring property investigation. He was arraigned in local court and remanded to the Monroe County Jail without bail. The unusual connection between the burglary complaint and the homicide investigation became one of the case’s defining facts: deputies investigating allegedly missing property in one residence were led to the man who lived nearby and then to the discovery of Hogan.
Nearly a month after Hogan’s death, Petrella appeared in Monroe County Court for another arraignment and pleaded not guilty. Assistant District Attorney Ellie Laloudakis said afterward that authorities believed Petrella killed Hogan during the period spanning Sept. 12 and Sept. 13, but she cautioned that the full story of the confrontation may remain unknown. She said investigators do not have a clear motive and may never determine one. Petrella’s attorney declined to comment after the hearing, according to local reporting. The absence of a publicly stated defense means the court record, rather than competing public narratives, remains the central arena in which the allegations will be tested.
Hogan’s relatives were also present in the prosecutor’s comments after the arraignment. Laloudakis said she had met Hogan’s three daughters and noted that Hogan’s mother, Judith, attended court. She described relatives as deeply affected by the death. Those remarks did not supply additional evidence about the charges, but they underscored the human consequences of a case that otherwise has been reported through arrest records, a felony complaint and descriptions of the crime scene. The obituary similarly makes no attempt to litigate the allegations. It concentrates instead on the woman relatives knew through food, art, gardening, reading, family gatherings and friendships.
That distinction matters because homicide reporting can leave the victim’s biography smaller than the criminal case that follows. Hogan’s funeral notice identified calling hours and a Mass in September and described her as a mother, grandmother, daughter, sister and friend. It recalled how she made holidays elaborate for those around her and how she welcomed her grandchildren into activities she already loved. Those are details unrelated to whether the state can prove its case against Petrella, but they establish who Hogan was before deputies entered the residence on Sept. 13 and her death became evidence in a prosecution.
The legal questions remain separate and unresolved. Prosecutors must prove Petrella committed the crimes charged, and his not-guilty plea means the allegations have not been admitted. Authorities have disclosed the basic sequence they say connects the burglary investigation to Hogan’s discovery, along with allegations concerning how she died and how her body was found. They have not made public every piece of evidence collected from the residence, and the criminal complaint itself is an accusation rather than a verdict. No trial date was identified in the reporting reviewed for this article.
For Hogan’s family, the court case is proceeding alongside a very different record of her life — one centered on her children, grandchildren, garden, cooking and creative work. Petrella, meanwhile, remains jailed without bail as he awaits further proceedings on charges he denies. His next reported appearance in Monroe County Court was scheduled for Dec. 4.
Author note: Last updated November 18, 2026.