Police say frustrated caregiver choked resident unconscious during overnight snack dispute

Jimmy Alexis acknowledged physically restraining Jason Similien but denied choking him, according to records describing the 2023 death investigation.

FORT LAUDERDALE, Fla. — Jimmy Alexis did not tell investigators there had been no physical contact with Jason Similien during the disabled resident’s final night. Instead, police say, the former group-home worker maintained that he repeatedly restrained Similien but did not choke him — a distinction now central to an aggravated manslaughter prosecution.

Fort Lauderdale police allege that the encounters were more dangerous than Alexis described. Another employee told detectives she witnessed Alexis place an arm around Similien’s neck until he lost consciousness twice during the early morning hours of June 30, 2023. She said she recorded audio during the second episode after previously warning Alexis to stop. Similien, 26, was later found unresponsive and died at a hospital. A medical examiner ruled the death a homicide. Alexis, 43, was arrested more than three years later and has denied the allegations.

According to the arrest affidavit, Alexis told police that Similien was moving around the residential facility and making noises that could disturb other patients. He said he used a restraint method he called “vertical immobilization” four or five times during the shift. In one statement reported from the investigation, Alexis summarized his position by saying he had to restrain Similien, not choke him. That explanation placed the nature and degree of the force used at the center of the inquiry from its earliest stages.

The witness described something different. Police said the employee appeared distressed while investigators were at Genuine Love and Care Group Home after emergency crews responded. She later sought out officers away from the building and said she had seen Alexis choke Similien until the resident became unconscious. The woman told investigators that during an earlier incident she warned Alexis that he was hurting Similien and told him to stop. Her account turned what began as a death investigation with competing possible explanations into an inquiry focused on another worker’s use of force.

The first alleged choking occurred around 1 a.m., according to the witness account summarized in court records. Similien had been awake and moving around the facility. Alexis told him to return to bed, but Similien did not comply, investigators said. The witness alleged that Alexis wrapped an arm around Similien’s neck while the resident sat on a blue foam mat and maintained the hold until Similien lost consciousness. Similien later woke up, according to the records, leaving investigators to examine both that encounter and a second one reported a few hours later.

Around 3 a.m., Similien walked to a snack closet looking for a cookie, the witness told police. Investigators said Alexis became frustrated and again used a hold around Similien’s neck. The employee said the resident lost consciousness. Because she had already objected to the earlier incident, she began recording audio on her phone during the second episode, according to police. Officers later said the recording captured Similien moaning. Law&Crime reported from the affidavit that Similien did not regain consciousness after the second alleged choking, although Alexis later gave investigators a different account of what happened afterward.

Alexis told police that Similien eventually returned to bed by himself at about 5 a.m. and went to sleep. He said he tried to wake the resident around 6:45 a.m. and discovered that he was unresponsive. Emergency crews were called, and Similien was taken to a hospital, where he was pronounced dead at 7:42 a.m. Those statements created another disputed point for investigators: the witness described Similien as remaining unconscious after the second alleged choking, while Alexis described him as later going to bed on his own.

Investigators also had to consider information from the facility about Similien’s condition and behavior. Staff told police he had autism and experienced anxiety and psychosis. They also described him as prone to self-injury, including banging his head against surfaces. Such information was relevant to determining whether an injury or death could have resulted from causes unrelated to another person’s actions. But the medical examiner later classified the death as a homicide, and police continued investigating Alexis. Local 10 reported that the specific cause of death was redacted from the arrest form it reviewed.

The police case also includes a controlled call made after the coworker agreed to cooperate with investigators. According to the arrest documents, Alexis told the woman what he intended to tell police and urged her to provide a similar account in her own words. Police said he also advised her not to mention the facility’s logbook or the mat and warned against giving investigators too many details that might lead to further questions. Prosecutors could argue that the conversation bears on Alexis’ state of mind, while the defense can contest the meaning and context of his statements. The complete call has not been publicly aired in the reports reviewed for this article.

The criminal charge did not come quickly. Similien died in June 2023, and the medical examiner ruled the death a homicide in November of that year. Fort Lauderdale police said they continued working with prosecutors before obtaining a warrant in 2026. The department’s Fugitive Unit arrested Alexis on Oct. 6. His attorney challenged the timing of the case in court, saying it was strange for an arrest to occur more than three years after the death. The defense has said Alexis denies the allegations, and the passage of time is expected to be part of the broader dispute over the evidence.

Similien’s family is separately pursuing civil claims against the group home and others connected with it. Family attorney Adam Finkel has said coworkers had previously complained about Alexis’ conduct and has argued that the facility should have acted before Similien’s death. He also described Similien as a kind and loving young man. Those allegations about prior complaints have not been established as findings in the criminal case. NBC 6 reported that representatives for the facility had not responded to its request for comment when the arrest became public.

The wording of the criminal charge is significant because prosecutors are not simply being asked to prove that physical contact occurred. Alexis acknowledged using restraint. The unresolved question is whether prosecutors can prove beyond a reasonable doubt that his conduct met the elements of aggravated manslaughter of a disabled adult and caused Similien’s death. The defense, meanwhile, can argue from Alexis’ account, medical evidence, witness credibility, the meaning of the recordings and any other evidence presented in court. A homicide ruling describes the manner of death; it is not itself a criminal conviction of a particular person.

At trial or in later court proceedings, the central factual dispute would remain the same: whether Alexis used permissible restraint, as he has maintained, or force that caused Similien’s death, as police allege. Alexis has been released on bond and continues to deny the charge. No reliable report reviewed through Nov. 18 establishes a final adjudication.

Author note: Last updated November 18, 2026.