Ohio daycare worker complained about fussy twins before killing 5-month-old boy

Kashan Crawford-Chatman’s parents had entrusted their premature twins to an in-home caregiver before one child suffered fatal head trauma.

COLUMBUS, Ohio — When Stacia Crawford returned to work after the premature birth of her twin boys, she placed them in a Reynoldsburg home daycare. Nearly three years after one of those babies died from severe head injuries, the woman trusted with their care has been sentenced to life in prison.

Tammra R. Straughter, 54, received the life sentence Oct. 7 after a Franklin County jury convicted her of murder and child endangerment in the death of 5-month-old Kashan Roman Crawford-Chatman. Judge Bill Sperlazza ruled that Straughter may first become eligible for parole after serving 15 years and credited her with 54 days already served. The punishment followed an Aug. 20 verdict and closed the main trial-court proceedings in a case rooted in a basic arrangement familiar to working families: young children being cared for in someone else’s home while a parent returned to work.

Kashan and his twin brother were born April 25, 2023. According to a wrongful-death lawsuit later filed by Crawford, both boys were premature and spent weeks in a neonatal intensive care unit before they were able to go home. Crawford, a licensed counselor, eventually returned to her job. On Oct. 9, when the twins were just over 5 months old, she dropped them off at the home where Straughter operated a child care service. Prosecutors later said Straughter was by herself caring for the twins and six other children that day.

Hours later, the routine child-care day turned into a medical emergency. Police contacted Crawford after emergency crews responded to Straughter’s home because Kashan had stopped breathing. According to records described in news reports, the infant was breathing again by the time responders evaluated him. Crawford was told he appeared stable enough to be released to her, but she remained concerned and brought him to an urgent care facility. There, his condition deteriorated sharply. He stopped breathing again and required emergency transportation and prolonged resuscitation before he was transferred to Nationwide Children’s Hospital.

At the hospital, doctors found evidence of serious trauma that authorities concluded could not be explained by an ordinary choking episode. The Franklin County Coroner’s Office ultimately ruled Kashan’s death a homicide caused by a closed head injury consistent with shaken baby syndrome. He died Oct. 13, 2023. Prosecutors later said a deputy coroner considered the swelling in his brain exceptionally severe and believed it strongly indicated abusive head trauma. Hospital employees also made a report to Franklin County Children Services after identifying signs of suspected physical abuse.

Straughter told investigators that Kashan had seemed healthy when he arrived. She said he became fussy as the day continued and that she held him frequently. Her account, as described in an affidavit, was that she placed him on his back so she could attend to another child and returned to find he had spit up and appeared to be aspirating. She said she tried to clear his airway, patted his back, gave rescue breaths and called for emergency help. Crawford’s civil complaint also described Straughter saying that she had struck Kashan on the back after he choked on formula.

That explanation became only one part of the investigation. Detectives obtained video recorded inside Straughter’s home that prosecutors said showed Kashan appearing well earlier in the day before his condition changed. The available reporting does not indicate that the cameras captured the fatal assault itself. Investigators also examined Straughter’s phone and found deleted messages in which she expressed frustration about the twins being fussy, according to an affidavit. Those digital records, together with the medical findings and the timing of Kashan’s decline, were among the pieces of evidence prosecutors used to challenge Straughter’s account.

The number of children in the house gave the case a separate child-care context. Prosecutors said Straughter was alone with eight children: Kashan, his twin and six others. Ohio’s rules distinguish between licensed family child care homes and smaller home-care arrangements. Current state guidance says a person may provide child care in a home without a license for no more than six children, with no more than three under age 2. Licensed Type B family child care homes currently may care for up to seven children under state rules, subject to age and capacity requirements. The reports reviewed do not show that Straughter’s murder case included a separate conviction for violating child-care licensing rules, so no regulatory offense should be inferred from the reported head count alone.

The criminal investigation instead centered on who was responsible for the injuries that killed Kashan. Crawford’s wrongful-death lawsuit said Franklin County Children Services later substantiated physical-abuse allegations involving Straughter and found allegations involving Crawford and Kashan’s father, Jontue Chatman, to be unsubstantiated. Police arrested Straughter after a grand jury indicted her in February 2024. At her arraignment that month, Kashan’s parents appeared in court with supporters while prosecutors publicly described the evidence that had been developed during the four months after his death.

The parents’ presence became a continuing part of the public record. At the arraignment, Chatman held photographs of his son as the family sought accountability. At the 2026 sentencing, he again spoke about Kashan and about the trust he and Crawford had placed in Straughter as a caregiver. That issue of trust was not an abstract point for the family. The twins had survived premature births, had spent their earliest weeks in intensive medical care and had finally gone home before their parents had to make the ordinary decision of arranging care while working.

Crawford used her sentencing statement to describe what followed. She told the court she had carried rage, heartbreak and questions that might never be answered. But she also said she did not want to spend most of the limited time she had before the judge talking about Straughter. Her remarks instead focused on Kashan. An obituary published after his death described him as a smiling, expressive baby who was born alongside his twin brother. He was 5 months and 18 days old when he died.

For the jury, the legal question was whether the evidence proved beyond a reasonable doubt that Straughter caused Kashan’s injuries while responsible for his care. The prosecution relied on medical evidence, the timeline inside the home, Straughter’s statements, the recovered video and the deleted texts. Jurors answered that question with guilty verdicts on murder and child endangerment on Aug. 20, 2026. Six weeks later, Sperlazza imposed the life sentence. Although Straughter may eventually be considered for parole, she must first serve the minimum period required by the judgment.

The sentencing does not erase the distinction between the criminal case and broader questions about home child care. Ohio allows several forms of care in private residences, and the requirements depend on the number of children, their ages and whether a provider is licensed. Nothing in the verdict establishes that every small home daycare presents the conditions alleged in Straughter’s case. What the verdict established was narrower and more consequential: a Franklin County jury found Straughter criminally responsible for the death of the infant who had been placed in her care.

A report published after sentencing said Straughter’s defense had 30 days to file an appeal. No reliable later report located through Nov. 18 confirmed that her conviction or sentence had been overturned or modified. The life term therefore remains in place, while Kashan’s death continues to be reflected in both the criminal judgment and the civil litigation brought by his mother over what happened after she entrusted her sons to Straughter that October morning.

Author note: Last updated Nov. 18, 2026.