Maya Thomas was being homeschooled before her death, prompting lawmakers to revisit oversight while her mother and stepfather face murder charges.
PAULSBORO, N.J. — The death of 9-year-old Maya Thomas has moved beyond a murder investigation in this South Jersey borough, raising a broader question at the Statehouse: whether children educated at home have enough regular contact with adults outside their households to help expose possible abuse.
Maya’s mother, India Miller, 27, and stepfather, Sean Scott, 45, are charged with first-degree murder and related crimes in her Oct. 13 death. Authorities say the couple initially claimed Maya might have been struck by a vehicle while walking the family dog, but investigators say surveillance video and medical findings contradicted that account. An autopsy documented multiple blunt-force injuries, including injuries in different stages of healing, and the death was ruled a homicide. Both defendants remained jailed while their cases proceeded and have not been convicted.
The discovery that Maya had been homeschooled became significant after prosecutors alleged that some of her injuries reflected prolonged abuse rather than one isolated event. State lawmakers representing the area began discussing changes to New Jersey’s relatively limited regulation of homeschooling. State Sen. John Burzichelli, a Gloucester County Democrat and former Paulsboro mayor, was among those calling for additional oversight after the killing. The policy discussion centers on whether some form of registration, evaluation or contact could create additional opportunities for signs of harm to be detected.
Nothing publicly established so far proves that enrollment in a traditional school would have prevented Maya’s death. Nor have authorities announced a final finding that a particular agency or official missed a legally required intervention. But the circumstances have forced officials to confront the difficulty of recognizing possible abuse when a child has limited routine contact with teachers, school nurses, counselors or other professionals outside the home. Maya lived close to Loudenslager Elementary School, according to local reporting, but was not attending classes there.
The criminal investigation underscores why that question gained urgency. Police said Scott called 911 at about 1:10 a.m. Oct. 13 to report that Maya was not breathing. He suggested she had been hit by a car. Miller said she had heard a noise resembling screeching tires before Scott found the girl near a shed. Officers initially launched a search for a possible hit-and-run driver, examining the area for damaged vehicles and urgently trying to obtain surveillance footage from nearby properties.
That outside search soon pointed investigators back toward the residence. Police said cameras showed no traffic consistent with the alleged crash in the relevant period. Medical personnel treating Maya reported injuries that authorities said did not fit a collision. She had extensive bruising and facial trauma, and later examination found multiple injuries in different stages of healing. Maya was pronounced dead at Cooper University Hospital later that day. The medical examiner ruled the death a homicide caused by multiple blunt-force injuries, according to authorities.
Evidence collected at the house added to investigators’ suspicions. Police said they found wet children’s clothing with suspected blood in an upstairs bathroom and suspected blood on nearby surfaces and cleaning items. Detectives also interviewed Maya’s 4-year-old sibling, who authorities say reported that Scott had struck Maya in the face and eyes. Those claims form part of the state’s case but have not yet been tested at trial. Prosecutors have continued to describe the evidence as showing abuse that extended beyond the final hours of Maya’s life.
At Miller’s detention hearing on Oct. 27, prosecutors expanded on that allegation. A prosecutor told the judge that relatives had described previous episodes involving Maya and that one family member said Miller acknowledged she and Scott had struck the girl before she lost consciousness. Another relative reportedly told investigators of witnessing physical and verbal mistreatment during an earlier visit. Prosecutors argued those accounts, combined with the medical findings, showed a pattern. Miller’s attorney disputed the prosecution’s portrayal and urged the court to consider evidence that Miller herself had allegedly been abused by Scott.
The defense argument illustrates one reason the case cannot be reduced to a single policy explanation. Attorney Justin Moore said investigative reports included accounts from people who had seen or learned of violence against Miller. He argued that Scott’s alleged conduct affected Miller’s decisions and her initial statements to authorities. Prosecutors countered that Miller still had opportunities to protect Maya and accused her of helping divert investigators with the vehicle story. A judge ordered Miller held while the case is pending. Scott separately agreed to remain incarcerated.
Meanwhile, the New Jersey Department of Children and Families opened an investigation involving allegations of physical and sexual abuse connected to Maya, according to a department spokesperson cited in local reporting. Miller’s younger child was removed from the residence and placed in emergency care. The agency investigation is separate from the criminal prosecution, and its full findings have not been publicly released. That means important questions about prior contacts, reports or possible opportunities for intervention remain unresolved in the public record.
Those unknowns matter to the emerging legislative debate. Increased homeschooling oversight can involve several different questions: whether families should notify school districts, whether children should receive periodic academic reviews, and whether some contact with mandated reporters should be required. New Jersey lawmakers had not established that any particular proposal would have changed Maya’s circumstances. The case instead became a catalyst for renewed discussion because authorities allege she endured repeated harm while largely outside the ordinary school environment.
For Paulsboro, the policy debate is unfolding alongside grief and an unfinished prosecution. Residents gathered for a vigil after Maya’s death, while stuffed animals and other memorial items appeared near the home. The public response has focused on the child whose life ended, even as lawmakers consider what protections might be strengthened for other children. Any legislative changes will require a separate debate over parental rights, educational freedom and child safety rather than a conclusion drawn from one criminal case alone.
Miller and Scott remained detained as prosecutors continued pursuing the murder charges. The Department of Children and Families investigation and discussions over homeschooling oversight were also continuing. What is established is that Maya died from injuries authorities say were not caused by a vehicle; what remains to be decided in court is who bears criminal responsibility, while lawmakers determine whether her case exposes a gap in New Jersey’s broader system of child protection.
Author note: Last updated November 21, 2026.