The 2024 shooting outside North Marion Middle School unfolded as students and families gathered to celebrate the end of the academic year.
CITRA, Fla. — Students and families had come to North Marion Middle School for an awards ceremony on May 22, 2024. Outside, a dispute among adults turned deadly, leaving a father mortally wounded in the parking lot while a celebration continued inside the campus.
More than two years later, that contrast between a school event and the violence outside remained at the center of the case. A Marion County jury convicted Roderick Kelvin Watson Jr., 36, of premeditated first-degree murder in the death of Joseph James Juarez Coles, 32. Circuit Judge Barbara Kissner-Kwatkosky sentenced Watson to life in prison on Oct. 8, closing the trial with the most severe outcome available short of a death sentence.
Local officials had emphasized the school setting from the beginning. After Watson’s 2024 arrest, Marion County Sheriff Billy Woods said the killing was especially disturbing because students were on campus to be recognized for their accomplishments. Following the conviction, Fifth Judicial Circuit State Attorney Bill Gladson made the same point, saying a school should be a place where children learn and celebrate rather than encounter deadly violence. Authorities reported that no students were physically injured in the shooting.
The confrontation was tied to a family dispute over the children of Coles and Watson’s fiancée. The adults had attended the school event and later discussed where the children would go. Investigators said Coles wanted to take the children while their mother said they still had school remaining and should stay with her. She told deputies that Coles grabbed her arm. Watson then became involved in the argument, setting up the question that later dominated his murder trial: whether he was protecting others and himself or escalating a dispute that was already ending.
Witnesses told investigators that Coles was moving away when Watson opened fire. Prosecutors said he was unarmed. Authorities said Watson shot him multiple times and continued the confrontation after Coles fell, repeatedly striking him and kicking him before walking away. The description was used by prosecutors to argue that Watson was not simply responding to an immediate threat but was acting as the aggressor.
The parking lot yielded physical evidence investigators would later use alongside the eyewitness accounts. Reports based on the arrest affidavit said deputies recovered six spent 9 mm cartridge cases. They also found a handgun in Watson’s vehicle. Investigators noted that the handgun’s slide was locked back, which they said could indicate that ammunition in the magazine had been fired or that the slide had been manually pulled into that position. Coles was transported from the school to a hospital and later pronounced dead.
Watson remained on the campus. Deputies located him nearby and took him into custody without a struggle. Initial reports said he acknowledged being the shooter and directed authorities to the firearm. He told investigators that he had acted in self-defense, but sheriff’s detectives said almost immediately that witness accounts and evidence did not support the claim. He was booked on a second-degree murder charge and ordered held without bond.
The shooting’s impact went beyond the criminal investigation. Coles’ relatives said his children were at the school, and family members described the loss in deeply personal terms in interviews after his death. Published obituary information described Coles as a father of four who centered much of his life on his children. His family publicly sought accountability while investigators prepared the criminal case.
The legal stakes rose in June 2024, when a Marion County grand jury indicted Watson on first-degree murder. That charge required prosecutors to prove a premeditated killing. By the time the case reached trial in October 2026, the question was not whether Watson had fired the gun. Instead, jurors had to decide what his actions meant under Florida law and whether his self-defense claim created reasonable doubt about murder.
Watson took the stand in his own defense. He told jurors he believed Coles posed a threat and said he fired because he wanted to live. He testified that he had heard Coles was a boxer and said he was uncertain whether Coles or another person nearby was armed. His lawyers argued that a self-defense decision has to be judged from the perspective of the person facing the perceived danger in the moment, not solely through facts established afterward.
Assistant State Attorney Toby Hunt challenged that account by focusing on what witnesses said they saw and the fact that Coles was unarmed. Prosecutors argued that Watson chose to enter the dispute with a gun and fired as Coles was trying to leave. They also pointed to the assault after Coles had fallen. In the state’s telling, those facts were inconsistent with a person firing only long enough to stop an imminent threat.
The defense urged jurors to consider Watson’s claim that he was responding to a volatile situation involving people he cared about. His attorneys noted that he stayed at the school, cooperated with deputies and did not try to escape. The prosecution argued that his conduct afterward could not erase the choices made before and during the shooting. The competing narratives gave the jury a case in which the identity of the shooter was settled but the legal meaning of his conduct remained contested until the verdict.
Jurors deliberated for less than two hours on Oct. 8 before reaching a decision. They convicted Watson of premeditated first-degree murder. Kissner-Kwatkosky imposed the life sentence after the verdict. The ruling transformed a case that began with an arrest for second-degree murder into a final trial-court judgment for the more serious offense sought by prosecutors after the grand jury indictment.
For North Marion Middle School, the shooting was never simply another homicide scene. The campus had been filled with children and families for an event intended to recognize student achievement. Staff members and other adults had to respond to a deadly emergency outside a place devoted to education. That setting became a recurring part of public statements from law enforcement and prosecutors, not as evidence of Watson’s guilt by itself, but as a measure of how many people were placed close to the violence.
The life sentence provides a legal conclusion to the murder prosecution, but it does not change the consequences described by Coles’ relatives after his death. A father was killed following a disagreement connected to his children, witnesses at a school event were exposed to the aftermath, and the children at the center of the original dispute lost a parent. The jury’s verdict established that, in criminal law, Watson’s actions amounted to premeditated murder rather than self-defense.
For the families who gathered at North Marion Middle School that evening, the criminal case grew out of violence intruding on an event meant to recognize students. The courtroom proceedings have now ended with Watson sentenced to life, but the lasting consequence reaches beyond the verdict: Coles’ children lost their father in a confrontation that unfolded at their school.
Author note: Last updated November 19, 2026.