Prosecutors changed one charge because Marquisha Williams’ body was left in Illinois, but said the revision did not reduce the agreed sentence.
ST. LOUIS, Mo. — A prosecution that began with a first-degree murder accusation ended with a negotiated 42-year sentence after attorneys revised the charges against Trenton D. Ivy, including replacing a corpse-abandonment count that prosecutors feared might not withstand an appeal.
Ivy pleaded guilty Oct. 5 to second-degree murder in the death of Marquisha Williams, the 29-year-old mother of his four children. He also pleaded guilty to second-degree tampering with a motor vehicle and two counts of tampering with physical evidence. St. Louis County Circuit Judge Stanley James Wallach sentenced him to 30 years on the murder count and four years on each of the three other offenses. Because Wallach ordered the terms served consecutively, the total sentence is 42 years.
The final set of charges reflected both a plea negotiation and an unusual jurisdictional issue created by what happened after Williams was killed. Ivy had originally been charged with first-degree murder and later indicted for abandonment of a corpse and evidence tampering. Assistant Prosecuting Attorney Brianna Baldwin said the abandonment count was replaced shortly before the plea after lawyers reviewed the Missouri statute. Because Williams’ body had been transported out of Missouri and left in Illinois, prosecutors believed the corpse-abandonment charge could face an appellate challenge. The replacement motor-vehicle count avoided that issue, Baldwin said, while leaving the negotiated 42-year punishment unchanged.
The legal adjustment did not change the prosecution’s description of the underlying crime. Prosecutors said they were prepared to prove at trial that Ivy killed Williams following a physical fight, damaged her cellphone to interfere with efforts to find her and concealed her body after her death. Police said Ivy himself provided an important part of that account during an interview in Wisconsin in December 2023. After his arrest there on unrelated allegations, detectives said he admitted killing Williams in St. Louis following a physical altercation and admitted disposing of her body in an unknown location.
By then, the case had already produced evidence well beyond that statement. Williams was reported missing by family on Dec. 20, 2023. She had been with Ivy in her 2020 Jeep Compass after the two took their children to daycare, school and relatives, according to family accounts. Williams never returned as expected. Two days after she was reported missing, authorities in Racine County, Wisconsin, arrested Ivy while he was alone in her Jeep. St. Louis County investigators said apparent blood, other biological material and personal belongings belonging to Williams were found inside the vehicle.
The search continued because Williams had not yet been located. Her relatives organized recovery efforts while police examined information suggesting the Jeep had traveled north through Illinois. St. Louis County prosecutors obtained a first-degree murder charge before investigators had recovered her body. Illinois State Police found Williams on Dec. 28. Although early public statements did not give a precise location, Cook County medical examiner records later showed that she was located in a wooded preserve near Algonquin Road in the Chicago suburbs, hundreds of miles from St. Louis. The medical examiner determined that Williams died from strangulation and classified her death as a homicide.
The later release of medical examiner records clarified details that had caused confusion in the court record. An early grand jury document had listed Litchfield, Illinois, as the place where Williams’ body was found. Prosecutors later amended the filing and said the Litchfield reference came from preliminary police information. The medical examiner’s records instead placed Williams near Park Ridge in the Chicago area. Those records also showed that investigators had searched the area earlier and that phone information connected Ivy to the location. The factual correction mattered because the state line, rather than the exact Illinois municipality, eventually became relevant to the abandonment charge.
The prosecution had grown more complex in the months after Ivy’s initial arrest. After he consented to extradition from Wisconsin, he was returned to St. Louis County in January 2024. A grand jury indicted him the next month on first-degree murder, abandonment of a corpse and two felony evidence-tampering counts. Authorities alleged that he damaged Williams’ cellphone and concealed her body in an effort to hinder the murder investigation. The first-degree murder count exposed Ivy to a substantially different trial than the one ultimately avoided through the plea, while the additional counts addressed what prosecutors said he did after Williams’ death.
Nearly three years later, the negotiated resolution shifted the murder count to second degree. Unlike the earlier stage of the case, when the charges remained allegations and Ivy was entitled to the presumption of innocence, his guilty plea was an admission of criminal responsibility to the four offenses accepted by the court. The plea also meant prosecutors did not have to present their evidence to a jury and Williams’ family did not have to wait for the scheduled trial process to conclude. The parties instead presented Wallach with a sentencing agreement that called for each prison term to be served one after another.
The hearing nevertheless gave Williams’ relatives an opportunity to put the consequences of the crime into the court record. Her mother, Norvette Chavis, told the judge about searching for her daughter during the cold days after the disappearance. Chavis said Williams should have been able to watch her children grow up and described the family as carrying a punishment that no court sentence could end. Williams’ cousin, Cori Curry, submitted a statement describing the ordinary experiences the children lost with their mother, from holidays and graduations to the ability to hear her voice or ask for guidance.
The children themselves attended the hearing. Local reports said they confronted Ivy about why he had killed Williams. Their presence gave the sentencing a dimension that the plea agreement’s numbers could not express. The court could divide the punishment into one 30-year term and three four-year terms, but Williams’ relatives described the crime as a loss that would recur at family milestones for years. Chavis also told Ivy that although he had taken her daughter’s life, he could not take away the love Williams had left with her children.
For prosecutors, the case ended with a legal compromise that altered the charges without changing the sentence they had negotiated. The most notable revision was driven not by a change in the evidence but by a territorial limit prosecutors believed was built into Missouri law: Williams’ body was left across the state line. The motor-vehicle tampering count took the place of the abandonment charge, while the second-degree murder plea replaced the original first-degree accusation. Baldwin said those changes did not affect the 42-year total that had already been settled with the defense.
Wallach’s judgment now closes the Missouri criminal case without a trial. Ivy faces consecutive sentences for second-degree murder and the three tampering offenses, while the evidentiary record developed over nearly three years preserves the path from Williams’ disappearance, to the recovery of her Jeep in Wisconsin, to the discovery of her body in Illinois and finally to the St. Louis County courtroom where Ivy entered his guilty pleas.
Author note: Last updated November 17, 2026.